If YOU could edit the PT

Honestly, I can ignore Jar Jar...Anakin lack of skill and self assurance was the main flaw imo.

Which was taken out. But ignoring bits doesn't make the movie go quicker, it does when you cut it out. It's about 20 minutes or so shorter. It's an illegal fan edit of course.

😆 Of all the trilogy, that movie needs the most work. Its unfortunate that it can't be changed that much.

The Phantom Edit was made at the time using the VHS copy, the original theatrical. It shows it can without much trouble, all the cuts were vry nice, even the audio transitions were pretty good.

Cool. Now lucas needs to follow suit.

The guy who made it even SENT it to Lucas, just to show what an alternative cut could have been. He didn't sell it or anything, just a fan thing.

Good for him.

cut the Jar Jar antics.
REALLY cut the Anakin antics.
Add in some more "Anakin is an intelligent, skilled, boy" clips.

👆

INterestingly enough, he just took out a lot of the oopses and Anakin BECAME an intelligent, skilled boy. He cut all the button pushing in the Naboo fighter, without all the oopses and the that's-not-it and it looked like a boy who knew what he was doing. No mistakes in looking for firing buttons to shoot droideka's... no he AIMED at the droideka's. Was pretty good.

Yeah. Its be easy to att some more digital combat with the space battle. Make him do things besides just flying around.

As I said: the Phantom Edit MADE him a pilot. Even the accidental spinning is no accident anymore if you take out the "Let's try spinning, that's a good trick". *shudders*

He still never SHOOTS anythign except for a randomly placed main reactor...which I would place in the middle of a hangar where it could easily be damged by my own dumb droid ships flying into it.

Goddamn TPM sucked.

Yeah...

TPM is the best of the prequels though...

Errm.. no... ROTS is.

Actually AOTC is...

Errm... no.

Its all about the Count my friend. TPM doesnt even mention him so thats out and ROTS gives him a pathetic 5 minutes (however a fairly nice duel) and then kills him off. Its an insult and greatly lessens my view of the movie. That leaves AOTC where he is shown pwning with the force, pwning with a sword, pwning with his army, leaving the audience in awe with his charimatic and elegant attitude and generally being the most interesting part of the movie (and entire saga). that is why AOTC is the best.

Only because some old guy is in it who you have a crush on.. Wow, talk about stupidity.

I agree... Lee was great but he couldn't save the movie.