Originally posted by Emperor Ashtar
Batman and phantom don't share the same name, have similar occurence's in their lives (Rich best friend/rival) And similar sounding and looking attacks.Actually, superman ripped off of captain marvel, prior to captain marvel superman could not fly like he did.
So your answer would be a sound " no"? Allow me to get further then, Captain Marvel who came after Superman shares:
>The same build.
>The same basic costume design with boots and caps.
>Both are dark haired.
>Both have a chest symbol that defines them.
>Both had scientists as main rivals.
>Both are the main guns in theyr universes. Thus they share the same power position.
>Both have the same basic powerset.
Phantom/Batman:
>Both are filthy rich.
>Both wer trained in numerous figthing skills.
>Both have a buttler/helper that has served the family legacy. (Alfred/Guran).
>Both use the supernatural fear as the main weapon.
>Both used guns when they first popped up.
>Both use dark costumes.
>Both use ninja like tactics (disappearing acts, etc).
>Both teach kids that will follow theyr steps (the Phantom sons and Robin).
>Both use a "mark" that defines them and again scares the underworld.
>Both are the main vigilantes in theyr respective universes.
>Both wer created due to the death of parents and by the vow of vengeance. And both when they wer young. They are basically the same character.
Now, yes. They dont share the same name. And the costumes while from the same obvious influence arent the same. However in contradiction, Ryu and Ryo share practically the same name. Both Ryo and Ken are blond. And the color scheme is alike. And both the R`s have a rich friend. But what else? The powerset? The examples above both have that. History? Not the same. Backstory? Not even alike. Personality? Lets not go there.
All in all whether your answer is that he started as a rip off or not (well, i dont consider CM and Batman ripp offs either...) one has to give some props to SNK to build him upon those similarities to a more unique character that today we have. Especially when he shows up in his original story/self as aged Ryo. Just like Batman moved upon being just another similiar "Phantom".