Storm vs. Meggan

Started by Blair Wind43 pages

Sure. Peak in the 616 continuity. I'm all for that. Alternate realities have alternate decisions made in them and effects that create ALTERNATE persons, with alternate powers.

Yet again. Who gives a flying fig nutton if she was elemental in an a alternate reality?

Originally posted by Grimm22
Damn Blair, with you and DC having the same Sig and icon, how am I supposed to tell you two apart? Read your nametag? 😕

Pft, reading is for nerds 😛

Mines on the left and his is in the middle 🙂

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Sure. Peak in the 616 continuity. I'm all for that. Alternate realities have alternate decisions made in them and effects that create ALTERNATE persons, with alternate powers.

Yet again. Who gives a flying fig nutton if she was elemental in an a alternate reality?

It was an alternate future not reality, marvel stating it was peak/ultimate stage is canon, no matter if it was a future this was her ultimate extent of her powers.

reread the statement
but not before the ultimate extent of Storm's mutant power was revealed in an alternate future wherein she had evolved into a wholly elemental being.

Originally posted by The Weather God
It was a alternate future not reality, marvel stating it was peak/ultimate stage is canon,no matter if it was a future this was her ultimate extent of her powers.

reread the statement
but not before the ultimate extent of Storm's mutant power was revealed in an alternate future wherein she had evolved into a wholly elemental being.

Its called advertisement. Five bucks says they kill of her character before they show that again in 616 continuity.

Alternate reality, alternate future. Tomato, tamato its all the same.

ALTERNATE being the key reference term, seeing as events that push people to certain limits, and radically change personalities are all part of ALTERNATE things. Seeing as it is an ALTERNATE (that is not the main course chosen) and seeing as comics in the continuity have not shown her to be able to do this in our little 616 universe then we have to go by peak standards shown in our little piece of heavens comics.

al·ter·na·tive Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[awl-tur-nuh-tiv, al-] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–noun
1. a choice limited to one of two or more possibilities, as of things, propositions, or courses of action, the selection of which precludes any other possibility: You have the alternative of riding or walking.
2. one of the things, propositions, or courses of action that can be chosen: The alternative to riding is walking.
3. a possible or remaining course or choice: There was no alternative but to walk.
–adjective
4. affording a choice of two or more things, propositions, or courses of action.
5. (of two things, propositions, or courses) mutually exclusive so that if one is chosen the other must be rejected: The alternative possibilities are neutrality and war.
6. employing or following nontraditional or unconventional ideas, methods, etc.; existing outside the establishment: an alternative newspaper; alternative lifestyles.
7. Logic. (of a proposition) asserting two or more choices, at least one of which is true.

1 and 7 I like best 🙂

This elemental storm has no business in this debate. Thank you for your time

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Its called advertisement. Five bucks says they kill of her character before they show that again in 616 continuity.

Alternate reality, alternate future. Tomato, tamato its all the same.

ALTERNATE being the key reference term, seeing as events that push people to certain limits, and radically change personalities are all part of ALTERNATE things. Seeing as it is an ALTERNATE (that is not the main course chosen) and seeing as comics in the continuity have not shown her to be able to do this in our little 616 universe then we have to go by peak standards shown in our little piece of heavens comics.

al·ter·na·tive Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[awl-tur-nuh-tiv, al-] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–noun
1. a choice limited to one of two or more possibilities, as of things, propositions, or courses of action, the selection of which precludes any other possibility: You have the alternative of riding or walking.
2. one of the things, propositions, or courses of action that can be chosen: The alternative to riding is walking.
3. a possible or remaining course or choice: There was no alternative but to walk.
–adjective
4. affording a choice of two or more things, propositions, or courses of action.
5. (of two things, propositions, or courses) mutually exclusive so that if one is chosen the other must be rejected: The alternative possibilities are neutrality and war.
6. employing or following nontraditional or unconventional ideas, methods, etc.; existing outside the establishment: an alternative newspaper; alternative lifestyles.
7. Logic. (of a proposition) asserting two or more choices, at least one of which is true.

1 and 7 I like best 🙂

This elemental storm has no business in this debate. Thank you for your time

Reread the statement
but not before the ultimate extent of Storm's mutant power was revealed in an alternate future wherein she had evolved into a wholly elemental being.

Source: http://www.marvel.com/universe/Storm

Doesn't matter marvel is considering this as her peak stage

Tell me what comic that's from? Alternate realities and/or futures = non canon.

Where exactly did the elemental Storm do anything impressive, anyway? Or is being a wisp in itself supposed to be impressive?

Originally posted by The Weather God
Reread the statement
but not before the ultimate extent of Storm's mutant power was revealed in an alternate future wherein she had evolved into a wholly elemental being.

Source: http://www.marvel.com/universe/Storm

Only if you do the same. 🙄

Then do it again. (just for emphasis) 😉

Originally posted by The Weather God
Reread the statement
but not before the ultimate extent of Storm's mutant power was revealed in an alternate future wherein she had evolved into a wholly elemental being.

Source: http://www.marvel.com/universe/Storm

Your premise that she can used is flawed at a foundational level.

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Only if you do the same. 🙄

Then do it again. (just for emphasis) 😉

Your premise that she can used is flawed at a foundational level.

Doesn't matter mavel states it is her peak stage and now it would mean your word against the entire marvel company.

😐

I would say something clever, but I am too busy trying to understand how a simple little word cannot be comprehended by a person who I am assuming is above the age of 9

Well i'm off to bed for now, chat about this tommorrow.

Originally posted by Blair Wind
😐

I would say something clever, but I am too busy trying to understand how a simple little word cannot be comprehended by a person who I am assuming is above the age of 9

Maybe the basic flaw is in your assumption.

damn disgust

I guess your right 😬

Originally posted by Blair Wind
😐

I would say something clever, but I am too busy trying to understand how a simple little word cannot be comprehended by a person who I am assuming is above the age of 9

I think you need to look in the mirror of your own statement, as i said it was an alternate reality, marvel still considers this her peak stage.

Bye now 😛

Marvel thinks that Wolverine is god. Do you follow everything they say that is not printed in a comic?

Example: Marvel handbooks say one thing, comics show another.

Until I see this storm in 616 continuity she basically did not exist. End of story.

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Marvel thinks that Wolverine is god. Do you follow everything they say that is not printed in a comic?

Example: Marvel handbooks say one thing, comics show another.

Until I see this storm in 616 continuity she basically did not exist. End of story.

Maybe because storm's ultimate extent has not been brought in the 616 yet, however marvel has already given us storm's ultimate extent in a alternate future, wether or not she get's there is not the point, the point of this topic is storm at her ultimate extent which is the elemental storm.

Leave the alternate out and see what they are really saying

But not before the ultimate extent of Storm's mutant power was revealed

This is as clear as day, it was revealed and marvel stated this themself, as i said before it's your word against marvel.

I'm Off to bed now

"Peak condition and powers" somehow equates to "elemental form from alternate future"? 😕

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
"Peak condition and powers" somehow equates to "elemental form from alternate future"? 😕

Peak conditions and peak Power

Now stop it

Originally posted by The Weather God
Peak concisions and peak [b]Power

Now stop it [/B]

Peak concisions?

Again the equation still doesn't add up, but I'll humor you...

So Meggan is harnessing the Power of the Beyond then, or the power of Otherworld? Okay...

Still a curbstomp for Meggan.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Peak concisions?

I edited it before you said anything 🙂

Cripes, this thread exploded. I don't know if anyone has mentioned it, but the problem with using some way far, one time version of a character is you have no idea what they can or cannot do. Chances are you have a single, usually impressive, feat and the rest you can only guess on and guesses don't have much hand in debates.