Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
[B]Death Proof
As quoted earlier, Vinny summorized DP right on spot. The film begins with some girlfriends doing a little road trip and talking about themselves and their relationships.
(See folks! This is good! This is exactly what every good film must have! In depth to the characters. Telling us who they are and what are they doing)
This becomes an essential factor for the film. Here are some girls who mind their own business and are trying to have a good time. This is what I can relate to! This is factor keeps interested. To sweet them even more QT delightens us the (male viewers) with some very sexy shots of the girls. Very beautiful gals who just want to have some fun. Despite what people might find boring in their conversations, we get at least a more depth to them.
Are you kidding me? The first 10 minutes of the movie is 4 chicks in a car trying to get one of them to confess to sleeping with a guy?! WHO GIVES A SHIT? This is "Death Proof" not "Truth or Dare"! All that did was establish their supposed "innocence", even though they head straight to a bar to smoke pot and drink alcohol. It was fairly obvious they were just girls. Their dialogue was about as pointless as Quentin Tarantino's came, coming in jacking his dick, "homaging" his other movies in his own feature. "Is that a tasty beverage or is that a tasty beverage?"..the Big Kahuna Burger.."Not so fast, Zatiochi"...and that stupid 10 minute diner scene in the 2nd act, gabbing about whatever muscle car movie Zoe Bell was on about.
The conversations did nothing for the characters that we couldn't already tell ourselves. 1st set of girls were innocent, 2nd set had 2 motorhead dykes, a jailbait cheerleader, and a wasted talent in Rosario Dawson.
The death sequences in Death Proof were much, much more realistic...graphic...distubing...morbid...and macabre than Planet Terror. This is where Rodriguez and QT separate. Rodriguez gives you a more extreme type of violence...whereas QT captures a more realistice and sentimental death scenes. I say sentimental because in the film you've gotten to know this people. You've gotten a more indepth characterization of them. You feel rather guilty for enjoying their deaths. QT makes a more humane type of violence (not trying to an oxymoron of course) than Rodriguez.
There were 4. In a row. In less than a minute...and you mean to tell me that
Spoiler:Give me a break. Besides, "Planet Terror", again, was Science FICTION. Sentimental? Honestly. Sentimental. You're better than that, WD. I didn't give a **** about the broads because they're a bunch of regular girls. Hardly humanitarians.
a chicks leg just falling off after being ejected from a car is realistic? A gals head being taken off because a car jumps over the car she's riding in is realistic?
Leaving that behind. We moved onto the next set of girls looking for some fun. Now, just like first set of girls we get a nice introduction to them. Except this time things will be different. By that I mean the tables are turned.
These girls, unlike the first, had the character development that was missing in the first batch. It's also where the movie got mildly entertaining, but it was still unbareable to lsiten to the black chicks butchy ghetto slang, which did NOT fit the movie whatsoever.
Death Proof have everything and anything over Planet Terror.
Yeah, dialogue perhaps. Because it was missing a PLOT the majority of the time..having been sucked up by all the non-linear gabbing.
I cannot but disagree heavily with anyone saying PT was better than DP. Simply because is NOT true! Honestly. It isn't...you're lying to yourself. Death Proof may not have the adreline action figure of Planet Terror. Because it doesn't need it!
Truth is irrelevant, it's your opinion versus ours. I could have used an adrenaline shot when I saw "Death Proof" personally. A movie billed with a killer car lacked the action you'd expect from it. That action has to be off the bat, not substituted with girls talking about kissing or drinking at bars, with Eli Roth talking about how he's going inevitably rape them all.
Death Proof stands alone! QT once again have done it! He delivers a story of violance, cruelty, sadistic justice, and revenge just like the classic cult movies and B-movies of the 70's.
..and just like the past 3 movies he's done, too. He needs a new gimmick. Female empowerment is boring. Alexander Aja perfected it in "Haute Tension".
I have to ask why you left out incredibly noticable parts in the movie, such as the poor performances from Zoe Bell, the waste of space Rosario Dawson's character was, the overkill when it came to dialogue, the lack of ACTION aside from two redundant car chases, the fact Kurt Russell actually had TWO different cars, aforementioned painful "ghetto" dialogue, and lastly the pathetic ending of the movie with Kurt Russell.
If you don't agree, fine. I'm not going to take sides..and my reply wasn't in anger..or in trying to call you out..I just think you were really unfair towards "Planet Terror", considering how much crap cinema you and I have seen...expecting such great things from an intentionally over the top movie.
The authenticity of "Planet Terror" won me over. The production was a lot smoother, the plot has been done before, like Tarantino's, but was still presented as fresh as possible, likeable, rich characters..well acted..the whole nine.