The Midnighter vs. Wolverine

Started by H. S. 677 pages

Honestly, I might split it right down the middle, 5/10.

Originally posted by batdude123
Midnighter's durability is insane though. He would last a long time.
Yeah he might last a long time against Wolverine's punches and kicks, but not the claw strikes. 1 or 2 of those can put down just about anyone unless they are truly invulnerable or they have a massive healing ability.

Originally posted by riceroost
Yeah he might last a long time against Wolverine's punches and kicks, but not the claw strikes. 1 or 2 of those can put down just about anyone unless they are truly invulnerable or they have a massive healing ability.

Midnighter DOES have a healing factor though.

I still think this is a tough call...

Originally posted by batdude123
Midnighter DOES have a healing factor though.

I still think this is a tough call...

Yeah he does, but I've never seen him shake off getting impaled in a few seconds. If he loses a limb or a head it's not going to grow back either. He also lacks a good way of dealing out damage to Wolverine. Throwing stars, nightsticks, and the telescoping staff wont do much against Wolverine.

Wolverine

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Very few are actually fully qualified to speak about both these guys. I'm probably not one of them either, since I'm a MN'er fanboy.

Well I've been reading Wolverine for over 10 years and I've read pretty much everything Midnighter has done since just before he joined the Authority....

*takes a moment to let everyone gasp in awe*

I think this is a fairly evenly matched fight for the most part:

Speed advantage to Midnighter
Durability advantage to Wolverine
Tactical advantage to Midnighter
Damage capability advantage to Wolverine
Bloodlust advantage to neither

Most of those advantages are only slight ones at that

After giving this some actual thought....

*takes another moment to let everyone gasp in awe*

I'd have to give the slight majority to Wolverine...

*takes a moment to let everyone gasp in horror*

Maybe 6 - 6.5/10... basically because he only really needs to connect once to slow Midnighter right down... whereas if Midnighter lands a damaging blow it'll just piss Wolverine off

Originally posted by Scoobless
I think this is a fairly evenly matched fight for the most part:

Speed advantage to Midnighter
Durability advantage to Wolverine
Tactical advantage to Midnighter
Damage capability advantage to Wolverine
Bloodlust advantage to neither

Bloodlust even??? I agree with pretty much everything you said, but bloodlust is def an advantage for Wolverine.

Originally posted by riceroost
Bloodlust even??? I agree with pretty much everything you said, but bloodlust is def an advantage for Wolverine.

No it isn't.... if anything Midnighter is more willing to kill than Wolverine

Originally posted by Scoobless
No it isn't.... if anything Midnighter is more willing to kill than Wolverine
No he's not. I dont think there is anyone more willing to kill people than Wolverine with the possible exception of Hitler or Stalin. Wolverine does not like to kill in general, but if he is in a fight and you attempt to use lethal force of any kind whatsoever he will kill you and not feel even slightly bad about it.

And when you say BLOODLUST in general I took that to mean if both fly off the handle and go nuts who can do it better and to a greater degree. And that undeniably goes to Wolverine.

Wolverine Wins

Midnighter is good but not that good

Originally posted by capt it up
really is it any were near wolverines level?

I would say he is above Wolverine's level and closer to Deathstroke's level

Originally posted by Grimm22
I would say he is above Wolverine's level and closer to Deathstroke's level

did you honestly just say that midnighter healign factor is better then logans lol. 😆 💃

also did you just say that deathstroke healign factor is better then logans 😆 😂

Originally posted by capt it up
did you honestly just say that midnighter healign factor is better then logans lol. 😆 💃

also did you just say that deathstroke healign factor is better then logans 😆 😂

Im not talking about healing factors 😐

Im talking about power

Originally posted by Grimm22
Im not talking about healing factors 😐

Im talking about power


power? then why the hell would you quote me talking about healing factors. you think that midnighter had a highe rpower level?

Midnighter. He'll stab his hand into Wolverine's chest and rip out his heart.

And Wolverine'll heal.

And Midnighter'll do it again.

And Wolverine'll heal.

And Midnighter'll do it again.

😛.

Seriously though, Midnighter has been able to impress Superman-types with his speed. When the Silver Surfer or the Runner is impressed with Wolverine's speed, we'll talk.

Till then? Midnighter is just predicting Logan's every move, and is getting there WAY before Logan does.

Originally posted by Soljer
Midnighter. He'll stab his hand into Wolverine's chest and rip out his heart.

And Wolverine'll heal.

And Midnighter'll do it again.

And Wolverine'll heal.

And Midnighter'll do it again.

😛.

Seriously though, Midnighter has been able to impress Superman-types with his speed. When the Silver Surfer or the Runner is impressed with Wolverine's speed, we'll talk.

Till then? Midnighter is just predicting Logan's every move, and is getting there WAY before Logan does.


who did he impress?

also logan has impressed gladeator before

Originally posted by capt it up
who did he impress?

also logan has impressed gladeator before

Are you talking about the fight that was supposd to last for days???

Originally posted by newjak86
Are you talking about the fight that was supposd to last for days???

nope im not .

Originally posted by capt it up
nope im not .
Ok then which one are you refering to???

Originally posted by newjak86
Ok then which one are you refering to???

when wolverine defeated more elite imperial guards then any force has ever done.