The Midnighter vs. Wolverine

Started by Starscream M77 pages

deadline, what is this vendetta that battlehammer is accusing you of?

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
I know, lol. He will lowball the shit out of wolverine, bring up the phantom bone crap and then take Midnighter at his absolute best lol.
oh god, you didn't just bring up the occipital bone argument again 😬

Originally posted by Deadline
Of course you would you guys think you're right about everything. 😬

Anyway this is getting out of hand.


Nope, we just think we know more then you, which is right. becuase I mean haft the shit you debate about, you have no idea about the character aside from at best the respect thread. This is becuase instead of going to a debate, becuase you wish to debate the characters, you go into a debate in order to attack certain posters in a sad attempt to discredit them becuase they routinely owned you so badly that you are still pissed about it. Dude it been like 2 fing years grow up.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
No, I analyze facts and use deductive reasoning, unlike you who makes huge leaps of logic to support your opinion with very little in terms of concrete evidence. So while you say "Blade was shot, he must have a healing factor!" I say "Blade's never been shown to heal on panel and that evidence you brought up similarly exists for other characters who are established as not having healing factors. It isn't conclusive." See the difference? I could make an arguement that Wolverine is a telepath with empathic abilities with more credibility than the Blade has a healing factor arguement.

See how you're dodging the question? Yea you are serious.

Originally posted by Deadline

Bruv I can see a normal human being ble to push another person at least 1 ft through water using both their arms or both there legs. I can't say for sure because im not underwater if this is true you're argument is nonsense.

Originally posted by Starscream M
oh god, you didn't just bring up the occipital bone argument again 😬

by bring up, you mean state what another posters arguement will be? then yes.

Originally posted by Starscream M
deadline, what is this vendetta that battlehammer is accusing you of?

There is none. Its just certain people talk nonsense and I call them out, they call that a vendetta.

Dum dum is right...

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
he was being sarcastic, and making fun of you
🤣 😆 drylaugh
more often then not the arguments arent even being debated on the character but his flawed argument and lack of knowledge which he tries to divert by lowballing feats or making controversial comments knowing it will irritated ppl and force them to explain them rather then let his opinion seem to have legitimacy.

Midnighter doesnt have any feats that are not replicatable with other meta's being from DC or Marvel and yet ppl assume that his feats are better then others which is okay in a forum debate..

the problem is that some poster use nothing but respect threads rather then constant on average showings and only see the best of the character..

by this logic we can make Rhino look like a 100+ brick that could give hulk a run for his money and smack around SS but we know that isnt true and simply being disingenuous...

its okay to use Respect threads but we also have to recognize when we are not an authority on a character and cannot defend them and just let it go and tip our hat to the other poster who is more knowledgeable on both characters and acknowledge his argument and knowledge carrying more weight then ones own. its the mark of a good sportsmanship/debater.

Midnighter is just lacking in durabilty and damage soak for this fight. He can't win.

Originally posted by Deadline
Bruv I can see a normal human being ble to push another person at least 1 ft through water using both their arms or both there legs. I can't say for sure because im not underwater if this is true you're argument is nonsense.

The pushie would go as far as the pusher's arms, unless the act of pushing caused them lose balance and they tried to right themselves by swimming backwards.

Originally posted by Deadline
There is none. Its just certain people talk nonsense and I call them out, they call that a vendetta.

By certain people you mean jinzin and srank every chance you get.

and by calling people out on nonsenses, you mean you throwing out red herrings and attacking parts of there post while bringing little or no evidence and then getting thoroughly owned by them.......then yes

good post, king castle.

Originally posted by 753
Midnighter is just lacking in durabilty and damage soak for this fight. He can't win.
what if we gave him black tarantula's durability or patriot lvl skin?

Originally posted by King Castle
Dum dum is right... 🤣 😆 drylaugh
more often then not the arguments arent even being debated on the character but his flawed argument and lack of knowledge which he tries to divert by lowballing feats or making controversial comments knowing it will irritated ppl and force them to explain them rather then let his opinion seem to have legitimacy.

Midnighter doesnt have any feats that are not replicatable with other meta's being from DC or Marvel and yet ppl assume that his feats are better then others which is okay in a forum debate..

the problem is that some poster use nothing but respect threads rather then constant on average showings and only see the best of the character..

by this logic we can make Rhino look like a 100+ brick that could give hulk a run for his money and smack around SS but we know that isnt true and simply being disingenuous...

its okay to use Respect threads but we also have to recognize when we are not an authority on a character and cannot defend them and just let it go and tip our hat to the other poster who is more knowledgeable on both characters and acknowledge his argument and knowledge carrying more weight then ones own. its the mark of a good sportsmanship/debater.


and I did not even have to pm you lol

cosigned

There are instances (or instance at least) where Midnighter has appeared to be bullet proof (and more where he hasn't... but whatever), so his durability is seemingly higher than Wolverine's but not enough to matter.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
There are instances (or instance at least) where Midnighter has appeared to be bullet proof (and more where he hasn't... but whatever), so his durability is seemingly higher than Wolverine's but not enough to matter.

I always chalked that up to the fact he were armor.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
I always chalked that up to the fact he were armor.

He wasn't in the instance I am referring too, just a t-shirt.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
There are instances (or instance at least) where Midnighter has appeared to be bullet proof (and more where he hasn't... but whatever), so his durability is seemingly higher than Wolverine's but not enough to matter.
and kicking that tank shell is actually a crazy durability feet if you think about it

spiderman's leg would've shattered if he tried the same

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
He wasn't in the instance I am referring too, just a t-shirt.

oh ok then thats different.

Originally posted by Starscream M
and kicking that tank shell is actually a crazy durability feet if you think about it

spiderman's leg would've shattered if he tried the same


it was pis.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
No, I analyze facts and use deductive reasoning, unlike you who makes huge leaps of logic to support your opinion with very little in terms of concrete evidence. So while you say "Blade was shot, he must have a healing factor!" I say "Blade's never been shown to heal on panel and that evidence you brought up similarly exists for other characters who are established as not having healing factors. It isn't conclusive." See the difference? I could make an arguement that Wolverine is a telepath with empathic abilities with more credibility than the Blade has a healing factor arguement.
wolverine is telepathic with empathic abilities... 😐

i know you aint being sarcastic with that comment when talkin about logan... 😒 durverine