Darth Bane vs. Darth Revan

Started by Darth Luna13 pages

If Revan gets his party members Bane gets the
nearest moon.

QED

Originally posted by Gideon
Darth Sexy was just demonstrating the valid reason why Revan is universally despised by everyone whose IQ surpasses single digits.

You wish

Originally posted by Gideon
Darth Sexy was just demonstrating the valid reason why Revan is universally despised by everyone whose IQ surpasses single digits.

You sure do loath Revan.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Well when I came to the realization that Revan was intended to be perfect, his character got boring. So much so that I became more interested in Carth.

No.. Just no. Carth was a ****ing pu**y. He complained about everything. Ugh. I hate him.

You could've just become more interested in Bastila or HK.

Originally posted by Cpt. Valerian
No.. Just no. Carth was a ****ing pu**y. He complained about everything. Ugh. I hate him.

You could've just become more interested in Bastila or HK.

I did, but the 10th time through the game I'd maxed out my interest in them, Carth was all that was left.

Whats up with all the Carth hate here ? Yeah, he may have been whiney on the level of even Anakin but at least he had a pretty decent and believeable storyline.

His story wasn't the case, it was his middle-aged, lost my family, can't trust anyone--but maybe I can trust you after all, angst. Got annoying.

Like, seriously. ****ing whiner.

Do I smell Carth hate!?!?!?

Yeah, they're bathing in that smell.

I still know almost nothing about Revan's abilities but after reading Rule of Two I would probably take Bane regardless. BTW, is it true that they are currently making KOTOR 3?

Originally posted by TheEskimo
I still know almost nothing about Revan's abilities but after reading Rule of Two I would probably take Bane regardless. BTW, is it true that they are currently making KOTOR 3?

Not exactly, it is an mmo taking place 300 years after the kotor games.

Who cares anyway? It's not like the KotOR games or any western RPGs for that matter are actually good. Second rate games.

Does anyone else smell prejudice?

There seem to be a lot of smells here ... and none of them is me.

Originally posted by Publius II
I'm still waiting for someone to explain this to me:

This is intending to show that Revan's knowledge is many, many times greator than Bane's. Do to Revan's Jedi training I do beleive that this is true.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
This is the Revan holocron scene. As far as I can tell, there is no more applicable portion of the book to this argument. It looks to me like Revan fully converted Bane (to his philosophy) and then tested him; Bane had to crush the holocron- it was how he showed (even if only symbolically) that he wasn't part of the Brotherhood.

This is a great thought, definitly beliveable, but I think that Revan was in some way pressed for time. That combined with the fact that he did not have the other holocrons to tell him how to make one properly would cause the crystal to fail. Still I admit, this could have been Revans intention.

Originally posted by Darth Luna
If Revan gets his party members Bane gets the
nearest moon.

QED


Another exelent thought, but what good would the moon do if it would also kill Bane. And to the others who stated something along the lines " If Revan gets his party than bane gets..." That is amendable, Revan would have the Republic right on his tail if Bane gets the Brotherhood, and his party who he trained with extensivly would not slow him down much (if at all). Please reply with any other thought on what Bane gets, that goes for everyone.

Originally posted by jhonon1
This is intending to show that Revan's knowledge is many, many times greator than Bane's. Do to Revan's Jedi training I do beleive that this is true.

Revan left the order when he was a young jedi knight then he had a under a years training during the events of kotor that isn't too much. Bane had access to Revan's holocron,Freedon Nadd's holocron (who himself learned under Naga Sadow and was said to have rediscovered Adas's holocron) and Belia Darzu's holocron. Knowledge will not be the deciding factor.

This is a great thought, definitly beliveable, but I think that Revan was in some way pressed for time.

Speculation only.

Another exelent thought, but what good would the moon do if it would also kill Bane.Another exelent thought, but what good would the moon do if it would also kill Bane. And to the others who stated something along the lines " If Revan gets his party than bane gets..." That is amendable, Revan would have the Republic right on his tail if Bane gets the Brotherhood, and his party who he trained with extensivly would not slow him down much (if at all). Please reply with any other thought on what Bane gets, that goes for everyone.

He is not being serious,the whole moon bit is a running joke here on kmc. Neither of them gets any outside help, this a one vs one fight.

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
[B]Revan left the order when he was a young jedi knight then he had a under a years training during the events of kotor that isn't too much. Bane had access to Revan's holocron,Freedon Nadd's holocron (who himself learned under Naga Sadow and was said to have rediscovered Adas's holocron) and Belia Darzu's holocron. Knowledge will not be the deciding factor.

If you are trying to favor Bane in this contest, you shouldn't be comparing force knowledge. While having Nadd's holocron does yield a great amount of information, Revan had the tombs of Korriban and the underground cities of Malachor V which were "full of holocrons". The knowledge goes in Revan's favor by a considerable amount.