Darth Bane vs. Darth Revan

The post you quoted is from two years ago.

oh nvm
i'm feeling really tired and dumb recently..
like with the force storms thing i thought i knew that it could destroy things cuz i read the time chronology book thingy.. damn i'm getting forgetful

EDIT: and i really didn't quote whoever that guy was.. I guess what I said happened to be the same as the other guy xD

Originally posted by kotorfan
oh nvm
i'm feeling really tired and dumb recently..
like with the force storms thing i thought i knew that it could destroy things cuz i read the time chronology book thingy.. damn i'm getting forgetful

EDIT: and i really didn't quote whoever that guy was.. I guess what I said happened to be the same as the other guy xD

Originally posted by kotorfan
EDIT: and i really didn't quote whoever that guy was.. I guess what I said happened to be the same as the other guy xD

Dude.. Revan is an unknown basically so its kinda pointless to debate on this

Erm, you definitely quoted and responded to a 2 year old post by an inactive member.

Revan

I wish to pint out that although Bane is powerful, probably more so than Revan, Revan has 9 friedns who would be willing to help him, as well as the republic armada. Besides, Revan probably knows much more than he could have put in his flawed holocron. Finally if we disregard time, revan will have had much more practice than Bane; who recently lost his orbalisk armor whose apprentice would turn on him in the middle of the fight. Revan would win, but Bane would give him a fight to remember.

Originally posted by jhonon1
I wish to pint out that although Bane is powerful, probably more so than Revan, Revan has 9 friedns who would be willing to help him, as well as the republic armada.

as well as the republic armada

Besides, Revan probably knows much more than he could have put in his flawed holocron.

Finally if we disregard time, revan will have had much more practice than Bane

who recently lost his orbalisk armor whose apprentice would turn on him in the middle of the fight

Revan would win, but Bane would give him a fight to remember.

And to add to that, it's stated that "soon, all of Revan's knowledge would be his [Bane's]".

Which means absolutely nothing. There's nothing even close to suggesting Revan put ALL of his knowledge in the holocron. Revan's knowledge>>>>>>Bane's knowledge. Try again Noobaris

WTF?

WTF?

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Too bad this is one on one combat and his friends aren't powerful enough to challenge Bane.

No

Prove that the holocron is flawed. Bane not only had access to his Revan's holocron but Freedon Nadd's holocron and Belia Darzu's.

How are we suppose to "disregard time," Revan wasn't a sith a lord nowhere near as long as Bane. This reeks of fanboyism.

We have to use Bane with orbalisks because we don't know how he will fight since he lost them, and this is a one on one fight (as always, no Zannah's eventually betrayal wont play a role.

No.

Revans Holocron had a flawed crystal, it said so in the book, and it didn't work after the first time Bane used it. He then crushed it to dust.
Disregard time as in the thousand years between their ages Revan does not age and has all the time he needs to practice. And yes, some of his friends could match up to Bane. HK-47 was used to, succesfully, kill numerous jedi. Against all of Revans jedi friends Bane would be hard pressed. Then the finall few who don't have the force or exelent planning systems could just shoot at him, possibly distracting him at critical moments.
I agree with you about the parts of that this is one on one, and that bane had two other holocrons.

Originally posted by jhonon1
Revans Holocron had a flawed crystal, it said so in the book, and it didn't work after the first time Bane used it. He then crushed it to dust.
Disregard time as in the thousand years between their ages Revan does not age and has all the time he needs to practice. And yes, some of his friends could match up to Bane. HK-47 was used to, succesfully, kill numerous jedi. Against all of Revans jedi friends Bane would be hard pressed. Then the finall few who don't have the force or exelent planning systems could just shoot at him, possibly distracting him at critical moments.
I agree with you about the parts of that this is one on one, and that bane had two other holocrons.

I'm still waiting for someone to explain this to me:

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Which means absolutely nothing. There's nothing even close to suggesting Revan put ALL of his knowledge in the holocron. Revan's knowledge>>>>>>Bane's knowledge. Try again Noobaris

Darth Sexy was just demonstrating the valid reason why Revan is universally despised by everyone whose IQ surpasses single digits.

I liked his hair. And his literary potential. Liked.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
I liked his hair. And his literary potential. Liked.

Got old after a while?

Well when I came to the realization that Revan was intended to be perfect, his character got boring. So much so that I became more interested in Carth.

Originally posted by jhonon1
Revans Holocron had a flawed crystal, it said so in the book, and it didn't work after the first time Bane used it. He then crushed it to dust.

isregard time as in the thousand years between their ages Revan does not age and has all the time he needs to practice.

And yes, some of his friends could match up to Bane. HK-47 was used to, succesfully, kill numerous jedi

Against all of Revans jedi friends Bane would be hard pressed. Then the finall few who don't have the force or exelent planning systems could just shoot at him, possibly distracting him at critical moments.

I agree with you about the parts of that this is one on one, and that bane had two other holocrons.

This is one on one, friends don't factor into this and most if not all would them would hinder Revan in the fight.

Bane takes all three.

The image flickered and jumped, and then the tiny replica of Darth Revan bowed its head, drawing its hood up to hide its features once more. "My time here is ended. Take what I have taught you and use it well."

And then Revan was gone. The glow emanating from the Holocron faded away to nothing. Bane retrieved the small crystal pyramid from the floor, but it was cold and lifeless in his hands. He felt no trace of the Force inside it.

The artifact was of no more use to him. As Revan had taught him, it must therefore be discarded. He let it drop to the floor. Then, very slowly and deliberately, he crushed it with the power of the Force until only dust remained.

This is the Revan holocron scene. As far as I can tell, there is no more applicable portion of the book to this argument. It looks to me like Revan fully converted Bane (to his philosophy) and then tested him; Bane had to crush the holocron- it was how he showed (even if only symbolically) that he wasn't part of the Brotherhood.