Originally posted by Scoobless
C'mon, the guy weighs around 165lbs, most characters are strong enough to knock him off his feet, if they could land a decent punch ... doesn't mean they are going to hurt him much
Didn't mean to say it hurt him. In fact, I don't believe I ever mentioned that Spidey was hurt, just that he WAS hit.
You referred to the action in the scan as "a scene ... where Cap may or may not have landed a punch."
Which I can't agree with - he definitely landed a punch - I've never seen Spidey dodge something like that, 😉.
Did it hurt him? Thats where speculation comes in. Maybe, maybe not, but he was hit nonethless.
I'm gonna agree with MetalMan on this one, Spidey will probably win 7/10 (unless I see some more impressive Ultimate Captain America feats - so far, he's MUCH stronger, but not nearly as skilled). About the same win rate I give 616 Cap. The strength and skill differences balance each other out, in my opinion.