Rethinking the PT - Alliance Speaks

Started by Alliance5 pages

Once as Anakin and once as Vader 13

When you say that, do you mean he faces him once when he is good and once when bad? Or once before the suit and once after?

I think Anakin is going to be portrayed as a very popular villian. I don't know, he doesn't come into the story until Episode II.

I think it makes more sense if he start bad and gets progressively worse. But I was referring to once out of the suit and once in.

Another I dea I have been toying around with is to write little short stories for each of the main Jedi, like the Clone Wars microseries. Anakin would probly feature in that too...

So Anaking starts off evil?

That would be good, it would give mroe of a back story to the Jedi, lets the reader know more.

Yeah, I felt the PT breezed through Anakin so quickly. We know more of Obi-Wan than Anakin in the PT, and Anakin's supposed to be the main guy here.

There were huge jumps in Anakin's character between each movie. HUGE. Lucas did not address these properly. I am going to.

Anakins starts more neutral I guess, but his character flaws will be seen as cracks immediately. He obviously then crumbles as the Clone Wars progess.

They did, they could have taken some senate stuff out and added some type of back story that the watcher could learn about the character.

Yeah, quite a few years worth of jumping, 22 I think. 😬

Battle scenes?

The Senate stuff is actually important to me. Politics will be in my version too.

OMG battles.

What I'm thinking:

Confirmed

E1:
Attack on the Cruiser (Kind of like the initial Cruiser destruction scene in TPM)
Manek vs Darth Maul (Parallels the Qui-Gon Darth Maul Duel)
Battle of Iridonia (Paralls the Battle of Naboo, ground battle, several lightsber battles dispersed throughout)

Speculative:
E2:
Manek vs. Shaak Ti (a short intro training battle)
Terrorist Attack in Monment square (parallels the Attack on the Naboo Cruiser)
Manek vs to-be-named Bounty Hunter (Parallels Kenobi vs Jango)
Geonosis Arena
Geonosis

Clone Wars:
Avia and Amp vs Asajj and Durgein the Battle of Kamino
Urossk and Six's squad vs Dooku in Battle of Orus IV
Manek, Anakin, Amp vs Grievous (and maybe antoher Sith) in a combo Space/Ground Battle (ala Munnilist)

E3:
Manek vs Aru (sith)
Battle of Cortida
Manek vs Grievous
Order 66- Amp vs Six, Manek vs Urossk, and Manek vs Vader

Originally posted by General G
So Anaking starts off evil?

That would be good, it would give mroe of a back story to the Jedi, lets the reader know more.

It would be bad for the story if Anakin started of evil, then what is the point in his redemption in ROTJ, if he was always evil, its better this way, that he was firs good, but later becomes evil and at the end, when he did so many terrible things, he does one great good act and redeems himself, its more emotional, you feel for him more this way.

Originally posted by Alliance
The Senate stuff is actually important to me. Politics will be in my version too.

OMG battles.

What I'm thinking:

Confirmed

E1:
Attack on the Cruiser (Kind of like the initial Cruiser destruction scene in TPM)
Manek vs Darth Maul (Parallels the Qui-Gon Darth Maul Duel)
Battle of Iridonia (Paralls the Battle of Naboo, ground battle, several lightsber battles dispersed throughout)

Speculative:
E2:
Manek vs. Shaak Ti (a short intro training battle)
Terrorist Attack in Monment square (parallels the Attack on the Naboo Cruiser)
Manek vs to-be-named Bounty Hunter (Parallels Kenobi vs Jango)
Geonosis Arena
Geonosis

Clone Wars:
Avia and Amp vs Asajj and Durgein the Battle of Kamino
Urossk and Six's squad vs Dooku in Battle of Orus IV
Manek, Anakin, Amp vs Grievous (and maybe antoher Sith) in a combo Space/Ground Battle (ala Munnilist)

E3:
Manek vs Aru (sith)
Battle of Cortida
Manek vs Grievous
Order 66- Amp vs Six, Manek vs Urossk, and Manek vs Vader

droolio

Originally posted by Count Makashi
It would be bad for the story if Anakin started of evil, then what is the point in his redemption in ROTJ, if he was always evil, its better this way, that he was firs good, but later becomes evil and at the end, when he did so many terrible things, he does one great good act and redeems himself, its more emotional, you feel for him more this way.

That is why I asked, it would have been odd and confusing.

Originally posted by Count Makashi
It would be bad for the story if Anakin started of evil, then what is the point in his redemption in ROTJ, if he was always evil, its better this way, that he was firs good, but later becomes evil and at the end, when he did so many terrible things, he does one great good act and redeems himself, its more emotional, you feel for him more this way.

I don't mean evil as in Vader evil, I simply mean that I won't portray him positively. He will be seen as a threat and a problem, even though he's not precisely evil yet.

However, one thing I'm torn about, I reall wanted to show the Temple invasion. However, that will probably not feature in Episode three cry

Nor will the Battle of Coruscant.

That may need to be re-arranged though.

Why wouldn't they be included?