Batdude's Tourney Discussion Thread

Started by batdude123144 pages
batdude123 Fellow Tu Quoqumber
Originally posted by rotiart
I thought we said that Dr. Fate and Dr. Strange level of magicians were out?

Reread what I posted.

darthgoober Senior Member

Ok, what about Onslaught(the original Xavier/Magneto combination, no Nate or Franklin)? And if he's useable, will we be able to use Magneto's and Xaviers feats also, or just Onslaughts?

Badabing Gym rat

Re: Tourney Discussion Thread

Originally posted by batdude123
IT’S TOURNEY TIME AGAIN!!!!!!!!!!!! YAY!!!
Here are the judges so far (I need more if people are interested):

1. UniOmni
2. leonidas
3. rotiart
4. Newjak
5. Badabing
6. King Mungi (maybe)
7. srankmissingnin

Sign-ups are going to be December 1, and the first draft is going to be on December 10.


Impressive Batdude. It looks like go have all the bases covered. 😎

I know the tourny isn't for a while yet but the people who are entering can start the ass kissing of the judges now. 😛

batdude123 Fellow Tu Quoqumber
Originally posted by darthgoober
Ok, what about Onslaught(the original Xavier/Magneto combination, no Nate or Franklin)? And if he's useable, will we be able to use Magneto's and Xaviers feats also, or just Onslaughts?

Anybody have any opinions on the Xavier/Magneto version of Onslaught being okay for this tourney?

Badabing Gym rat

Originally posted by batdude123
Anybody have any opinions on the Xavier/Magneto version of Onslaught being okay for this tourney?

As long as nobody uses the Hulk to smash him! 😱 😆

bigbran Dead

Originally posted by batdude123
Anybody have any opinions on the Xavier/Magneto version of Onslaught being okay for this tourney?
He should be ok.

batdude123 Fellow Tu Quoqumber

I really don't have any problems with it.

darthgoober Senior Member

A question on GL's, or their feats going to apply ONLY to themselves? Many people think of Kyle's and Hal's feats as interchangable, so will they be restricted to things that only they've personaly done, even though the rings grant pretty much identicle powers?

batdude123 Fellow Tu Quoqumber
Originally posted by darthgoober
A question on GL's, or their feats going to apply ONLY to themselves? Many people think of Kyle's and Hal's feats as interchangable, so will they be restricted to things that only they've personaly done, even though the rings grant pretty much identicle powers?

I'm not going to dismiss that idea, but it's up to the judges whether or not they want to count those particular scans for the decisions they make.

SpunkySmurph tu quoqumber

Just out of curiosity, what are the points of 'death' or defeat for robots (or such things) that can't technically 'die' or become 'unconcious'?

leonidas MWHAHAHAHA!
Originally posted by batdude123
I'm not going to dismiss that idea, but it's up to the judges whether or not they want to count those particular scans for the decisions they make.

if i'm judging, i will only be counting gl feats accomplished by THAT gl . . . ie -- the feats will NOT be interchangeable.

gl's powers may be the same, but their minds are very differnt and what occurs to one may not occur to the other . . .

and of course only powers they have CONSCIOUSLY displayed will be valid in my matches. 😉

SpunkySmurph tu quoqumber
Originally posted by SpunkySmurph
Just out of curiosity, what are the points of 'death' or defeat for robots (or such things) that can't technically 'die' or become 'unconcious'?

Let me clarify.

Again, this is all curiosity-

Nimrod's conciousness, for instance, can supposedly exist seperate from his actual body. Beyond that, he can regenerate.

And he is not the only one.

So what is the limit for such beings?

Validus Senior Member

GL feats need to be examined on a case by case example. I don't think blanket statements are fair in their regard.

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by leonidas
if i'm judging, i will only be counting gl feats accomplished by THAT gl . . . ie -- the feats will NOT be interchangeable.

gl's powers may be the same, but their minds are very differnt and what occurs to one may not occur to the other . . .

and of course only powers they have CONSCIOUSLY displayed will be valid in my matches. 😉


And how much credit will you be lending to Pre Crisis GL feats(since the current versions never ACTUALLY preformed them)?

Validus Senior Member

Originally posted by darthgoober
And how much credit will you be lending to Pre Crisis GL feats(since the current versions never ACTUALLY preformed them)?

Except they really did.

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Validus
Except they really did.

But not the CURRENT versions. They thought of it(and had the ability to pull it off) in another life so to speak. Just because they thought of it THEN, doesn't mean that they'll think of it NOW, because the current versions have never faced the circumstances which cause them to think of the feats in the first place. I'm not really objecting, I'm just trying to discern what will be exepted by everyone.

batdude123 Fellow Tu Quoqumber

Pre-Crisis Superman...

yay? 👆

or

nay? 👇

Tassadar Executor

Originally posted by batdude123
Pre-Crisis Superman...

yay? 👆

or

nay? 👇

👇

batdude123 Fellow Tu Quoqumber
Originally posted by Tassadar
👇

I'm only going to put him down if Validus personally admits Pre-Crisis Superman>Hal Jordan. 😈

Devil Lance DL

Originally posted by batdude123
Pre-Crisis Superman...

yay? 👆

or

nay? 👇


👆 😗