NJO Luke vs. DE Sidious

I was just thinking, what if it had been NJO Luke, a more powerful version of Luke, against DE Sidious? Granted, Luke won, but winning by channeling the entire lightside of the Force isn't exactly winning by one's own merit, is it? So now it's DE Sidious vs. NJO Luke. All-out fight; anything goes. Takes place in the Sith Academy on Korriban.

Luke is the most powerful Force user and Jedi in existence. He kills Sidious.

By NJO, Luke has already surpassed every other force user ever. He wins.

Luke wins; he's a better lightsaber duelist, he's stronger with the force, and DE Sidious' true strengths mostly lie in sith rituals.

Sidious is very powerful, but Luke has surpassed him by NJO.

NJO Luke will win, with some trouble, though, but by NJO Luke could beat anybody except Darth Nihilus (I'm not going to debate this, though, so don't start - it'd be a waste of your time).

NJO Luke would. LotF Luke is really starting to scare me, though. Stupid author inconsistencies.

New thread, LOTF Luke vs. Wicket W. Warrick! Due to inconsistencies, Wicket is victorious!

...

But yeah, as said by Darthsith19, NJO Luke can crush quite a few people.

LOTF Luke had trouble with Lumiya for god's sakes. I thought he reaches his peak in either DN or LOTF>

He did. For the last time, that was just a poorly written bit and only because Lumiya got in a lucky shot when Luke was highly distracted

So where does he reach his peak.. DN or LOTF?

Using Sidious as an example, he hadn't reached anywhere near his peak when he was Luke's age, so I'm guessing Luke hasn't reached his peak yet. Though, when considering that Luke has been in constant war pretty much ever since he became a jedi, whereas Sidious was a closet sith lord for most of the time, Luke would most likely reach his peak a bit earlier. I'd still say that we've yet to see Luke reach his peak, it should only be a matter of time.

Luke hasn't reached his peak as of LOTF. He's still going to get stronger.

I'd have to say that Sidious wins this one. Luke may be slightly better in lightsaber combat, but Sidious is a good bit better with the force.

What the hell? How is Palpatine better with the Force?

When has Luke ever done anything more than Sidious?

Probably around the times he can decimate an army of Vong and tear the engines out of a Star Destroyer casually?

It's been forty years since Luke fought Palpatine. They were only close then because they were respective avatars of respective sides, but on their natural abilities, Luke's surpassed Palpatine.
He's-pretty easily- the strongest being in Star Wars.

Seriously glentract you're going to have to stop this anti Luke nonsense. Stop hanging out on EOD as those guys know nothing. I've read all the feats Luke has done and it easily surpasses Sidious. By NJO he already is more powerful, and if these inconsistencies didn't occur, he'd be a force god by LOTF..

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Probably around the times he can decimate an army of Vong

After re-examining TUF I'm not convinced that Luke killed an army of Vong. He managed to get to the top of the ship, but how many Vong did he kill to get there? It's been speculated that he killed thousands, but I am no longer so sure that it was really such a large number.

Also, Sidious killed approximately 600 stormtroopers with a single blast of Force Lightning a fairly large amount of time prior to ROTJ. By DE he is FAR more powerful and could easily kill several times that number with a single blast.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
and tear the engines out of a Star Destroyer casually?

1. When did Luke do this?

2. Sidious decimated an entire fleet of Republic ships with his Force Storm. I think it's safe to say that doind so required more power than tearing the engines out of a Star Destroyer.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
It's been forty years since Luke fought Palpatine. They were only close then because they were respective avatars of respective sides, but on their natural abilities, Luke's surpassed Palpatine.
He's-pretty easily- the strongest being in Star Wars.

Once Luke starts doing things that are more impressive than what Sidious has done, I'll believe you. But until then, he's not the strongest.

Oh wow, because you don't believe it, then he's not the strongest. Once again Glentract, Luke represents Anakin at full potential, so I'm sorry to say that he IS the strongest, and his feats during the Vong War and the DN crisis and the Swarm War surpass anything Sidious did.. So try again.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Oh wow, because you don't believe it, then he's not the strongest. Once again Glentract, Luke represents Anakin at full potential, so I'm sorry to say that he IS the strongest, and his feats during the Vong War and the DN crisis and the Swarm War surpass anything Sidious did.. So try again.

You can just STFU. You NEVER make any arguments of your own and only serve to spam. You're not worth my time.