Thor vs Hulk- who's more durable?

*Nods to my last thread*

Leaving out bullets and sharp things, who's generally shown to take more punishment?

I would say Hulk is more durable. He has that crazy healing factor that is like instantaneous regeneration.

I dunno Thor has survived having the sh*t beaten out of him many times

Originally posted by Martian_mind
I dunno Thor has survived having the sh*t beaten out of him many times

they both have

I'm going with Hulk on this one

Thor

The one book where Hulk fights Thor and has Thor toss his Hammer away at the end of their battle Thor looks as If he is about to fall and Hulk looks a fresh as a daisy

Thor is the more durable.

Hulk's healing factor isn't part of durability. It makes him last a long time, through a lot of damage, sure, but its not durability.

Healing Factor means he's already taken the damage, and now he's recovering.

Durability means you dont have to recover from the damage...

I know profiles are not accurate but Hulk profile says Demi-Godlike Durability and Thor's says Metahuman Durability

Originally posted by Accel
*Nods to my last thread*

Leaving out bullets and sharp things, who's generally shown to take more punishment?

hulk

Thor

I'm going to throw in my opinion and say Hulk as well.

Very little about his damage soak has been attributed to his healing factor and his durability seems to be more consistent than Thor's.

Hulk

Originally posted by Accel
I'm going to throw in my opinion and say Hulk as well.

Very little about his damage soak has been attributed to his healing factor and his durability seems to be more consistent than Thor's.

Thor just simply takes more damage.

He took no damage what so ever from standing in the core of the sun, and he wasn't even phased when he took the blast that was the equivalent to an exploding Sun. He consistently has taken shots from Celestials, Galactus, Ego, Mangog, Thanos, Infinity Watch, etc.

Thor is simply more durable

I know Hulk has survived nukes on multiple occasions and recently the pressure and heat from the interior of a planet. Hasn't Thor survived a planet destroying blast?

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Thor just simply takes more damage.

He took no damage what so ever from standing in the core of the sun, and he wasn't even phased when he took the blast that was the equivalent to an exploding Sun. He consistently has taken shots from Celestials, Galactus, Ego, Mangog, Thanos, Infinity Watch, etc.

Thor is simply more durable

Originally posted by Badabing
I know Hulk has survived nukes on multiple occasions and recently the pressure and heat from the interior of a planet. Hasn't Thor survived a planet destroying blast?

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Thor just simply takes more damage.

He took no damage what so ever from standing in the core of the sun, and he wasn't even phased when he took the blast that was the equivalent to an exploding Sun. He consistently has taken shots from Celestials, Galactus, Ego, Mangog, Thanos, Infinity Watch, etc.

Thor is simply more durable

Any way, Hulk has taken shots from Thanos, the Celestial Order, Stranger, Warrior Madness Thor, the Destroyer armor, concentrated antimatter, and a blast the ripped apart a universe.

Ignoring higher showings, however, I just believe Hulk is shown as more durable on a regular basis.

Originally posted by Accel

Ignoring higher showings, however, I just believe Hulk is shown as more durable on a regular basis.

Nah.

Hulk is shown taking hits more on a regular basis.

Taking alot of hits does not = high durability.

Originally posted by Accel
Thor didn't stand directly inside the sun. It was a magical sphere inside the sun, which was stated by Thor himself when he arrived to fight Atum. I also don;t recall him taking hits from Thanos any better than Hulk has, nor do I recall any moments of him taking a direct blast from Galactus at all.

Any way, Hulk has taken shots from Thanos, the Celestial Order, Stranger, Warrior Madness Thor, the Destroyer armor, concentrated antimatter, and a blast the ripped apart a universe.

Ignoring higher showings, however, I just believe Hulk is shown as more durable on a regular basis.

Thor's higher showings > Hulk's higher showings

And Bran provided some scans for you that proved that Thor was standing in the sun.

And add Zeus to the list of people Thor's taken shots from. Hela, and Surtur to.

Originally posted by SpunkySmurph
Nah.

Hulk is shown taking hits more on a regular basis.

Taking alot of hits does not = high durability.