Thor vs Hulk- who's more durable?

Started by Soujaboy4 pages

And Asgardian Destroyer, Mangog, Kurse, etc.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Thor's higher showings > Hulk's higher showings

And Bran provided some scans for you that proved that Thor was standing in the sun.

And add Zeus to the list of people Thor's taken shots from. Hela, and Surtur to.


They really aren't. Hulk's highest durability feat exceeds Thor's and his lowest durability feats also exceed Thor.

I've seen Atum fight before. Like I said, you can see Thor enter the Sun and he states himself that he's in a sphere of some sort inside the Sun. The writer had to come up with some way for Thor to speak in the center of a star.

Originally posted by Accel
They really aren't. Hulk's highest durability feat exceeds Thor's and his lowest durability feats also exceed Thor.

I've seen Atum fight before. Like I said, you can see Thor enter the Sun and he states himself that he's in a sphere of some sort inside the Sun. The writer had to come up with some way for Thor to speak in the center of a star.

Post your over exaggerated universe destroying feat again. 🙂

Originally posted by Accel
Thor didn't stand directly inside the sun. It was a magical sphere inside the sun, which was stated by Thor himself when he arrived to fight Atum.
Is that why fire from the sun was going around Thor?

He never said magical. Plus, do you think he could be talking about the sun, as in sphere?

Also...

Originally posted by Accel
I also don;t recall him taking hits from Thanos any better than Hulk has
Didn't Hulk get KOed by a shot from Thanos? Other than that, I don't know what you are talking about.

To be honest, I don't know who is more durible. This is not one of those threads in which you can instantly pick a winner.
Yes, Thor has some good feats (taking shots from Arishem), but Hulk also has those (that blast that ripped apart the cosmos, although that could be pis...).
Hmm... don't know...

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Post your over exaggerated universe destroying feat again. 🙂

How is it over-exaggerated if it's shown and stated on panel to rip apart a universe?

Originally posted by bigbran
Is that why fire from the sun was going around Thor?

He never said magical. Plus, do you think he could be talking about the sun, as in sphere?

He didn't say it was magical, but he did state he was in a sphere within the sun. I would assume something like that would be magical, because, well, what else would it be?
Originally posted by bigbran
Didn't Hulk get KOed by a shot from Thanos? Other than that, I don't know what you are talking about.

Not that I recall. He's mainly famous for being kncoked around by Thanos.

Originally posted by Accel
How is it over-exaggerated if it's shown and stated on panel to rip apart a universe?

Sure, so can you post it so we can judge for ourselves.

Originally posted by Accel
He didn't say it was magical, but he did state he was in a sphere within the sun. I would assume something like that would be magical, because, well, what else would it be?
First off, Atum's power is the sun. Why would he need to keep a sphere there to protect himself?
Also, Thor was drawing power from the sun.

He also says just a sphere, he could have meant the sun as a whole.

Originally posted by Accel
Not that I recall. He's mainly famous for being kncoked around by Thanos.

The times you are thinking of, was when Thanos grabbed him and Thing, and was going to ram their heads together, and when he just slapped Drax and Hulk back, right? Not exactly taking shots...

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Sure, so can you post it so we can judge for ourselves.

There's no need to do so. Almost every one here acknowledges that that's what happened. They just know to keep in mind that it's a high end feat and nothing more.

Originally posted by bigbran
First off, Atum's power is the sun. Why would he need to keep a sphere there to protect himself?
Also, Thor was drawing power from the sun.

He also says just a sphere, he could have meant the sun as a whole.


He mentions a sphere within the Sun's core (heart). Clearly, he's talking about two separate spheres.
Originally posted by bigbran



Ah yes, I forgot about that moment. Looking at it now, it looks like that may be the Hulk personality who's currently on Planet Hulk.

Any way, you can see there, he's conscious. He's badly hurt, but consioud nonetheless.

Originally posted by bigbran
The times you are thinking of, was when Thanos grabbed him and Thing, and was going to ram their heads together, and when he just slapped Drax and Hulk back, right? Not exactly taking shots...

They're about as much as the "shots" that Thor took from Ego.

Originally posted by Accel
There's no need to do so. Almost every one here acknowledges that that's what happened. They just know to keep in mind that it's a high end feat and nothing more.

Actually most have no idea and have never seen it. If they did fanboys in every Hulk thread would be screaming Hulk has universal lv durability.

I can see it now...

"Superman can't hurt Hulk, because hulk has survived universe destroying blast without a scratch".

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Actually most have no idea and have never seen it. If they did fanboys in every Hulk thread would be screaming Hulk has universal lv durability.

I can see it now...

"Superman can't hurt Hulk, because hulk has survived universe destroying blast without a scratch".


DevilHulk is a prime example of that.

Any way, you would just have to learn to ignore those who iuse that kind of logic. If it's any thing members of KMC should have learned in recent times, it's that you can't debate logically with fanboys of that caliber.

Originally posted by Accel
He mentions a sphere within the Sun's core (heart). Clearly, he's talking about two separate spheres.
"It pulses in rhythm with the sun's blazing heart"? Maybe the sun is pulsing in rhythm with it's heart?
Everything about that thing just doesn't add up.
Also, there was no noticible sphere. The only sphere he could have been talking about was the sun, plus Thor isn't the most understandable at times.

But still, I will go back to Thor taking power from the sun to pelt Atum with.

Originally posted by Accel
Ah yes, I forgot about that moment. Looking at it now, it looks like that may be the Hulk personality who's currently on Planet Hulk.
I thought it was Savage...

Originally posted by Accel
Any way, you can see there, he's conscious. He's badly hurt, but consioud nonetheless.
Still, that is the only shot he took from Thanos, and it wasn't even that big (not knocking Hulk), just saying that Thanos could have put him down (same as he put Thor down, to even it out).

Originally posted by Accel
They're about as much as the "shots" that Thor took from Ego.
Notice how I didn't say anything about that. Wait... Ego hit Thor?

Originally posted by Accel
DevilHulk is a prime example of that.

Any way, you would just have to learn to ignore those who iuse that kind of logic. If it's any thing members of KMC should have learned in recent times, it's that you can't debate logically with fanboys of that caliber.

Can you lead me to the scan then?

Originally posted by bigbran
"It pulses in rhythm with the sun's blazing heart"? Maybe the sun is pulsing in rhythm with it's heart?
Everything about that thing just doesn't add up.
Also, there was no noticible sphere. The only sphere he could have been talking about was the sun, plus Thor isn't the most understandable at times.

But still, I will go back to Thor taking power from the sun to pelt Atum with.


I take the Sun thing as a bit more ambiguous than most. We see Thor in the sun, but acting like he may as well be in a field of flowers.

So I interpret his statement when he enters that he's in a sphere of some sort as the writer explaining how he does that.

Originally posted by bigbran
I thought it was Savage...

Still, that is the only shot he took from Thanos, and it wasn't even that big (not knocking Hulk), just saying that Thanos could have put him down (same as he put Thor down, to even it out).


From what little I recall of that story, that version of the Hulk didn't seem to have the personality that Savage Hulk is known for. Really, he seemed to talk rather normally and arrogantly, much like the current uincarnation.

Thanos could have put either one of them down. Really, I don't see these guys (or any one top-tier really) as capable of taking attacks from any one Sky-Father level and simply shrugging them off, regardless of how many times they may do it in comics.

Originally posted by bigbran
Notice how I didn't say anything about that. Wait... Ego hit Thor?

Ego sent his anit-bodies to take Thor out when he was in his system.

That statement was really more of a reference to Souja's list of the people Thor's fought and taken shots from.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Can you lead me to the scan then?

I can't. For some reason, the scans don't seem to be working when I check them out at the respect thread.

Something going on at Image Shack, I guess.

EDIT: Well any who, here are the links. Who knows, maybe they're just not working for me or something.
http://img142.exs.cx/img142/8388/darkcosmos23zl.th.jpg
http://img140.exs.cx/img140/6100/darkcosmos30sy.th.jpg

Thor is more durable.

The Hulk's durability plus his healing factor, though, greatly outweigh Thor's durability advantage.

Originally posted by Accel
I take the Sun thing as a bit more ambiguous than most. We see Thor in the sun, but acting like he may as well be in a field of flowers.

So I interpret his statement when he enters that he's in a sphere of some sort as the writer explaining how he does that.

So, how do you interpret the part in which he absorbs the sun's power to use against Atum?

Also, Surfer flies through suns and feels good about them...

Originally posted by bigbran
So, how do you interpret the part in which he absorbs the sun's power to use against Atum?

Also, Surfer flies through suns and feels good about them...


I interpret that as Thor using a magical hammer that can do almost any thing, really. Wouldn't surprise me at all if Thor was standing in Earth and somehow absorbed the Sun's power.

As far as durability is concerned, I would put Surfer above both Thor and Hulk. I don't see Thor or Hulk regularly passing into black holes like Surfer does, so he's not the best example to use.

wait just to clarify this, does thor have mjolnir in this "durability test"

cause if he does then it's no doubt that he wins, also he fought the destroyer many times, once or twice with loki in it and lets not forget the fact that he took a few hits from surtur way back in thor #351

nice sig by the way