Kinneary
Ex scientia tridens
Originally posted by Capt_Fantastic
That's not an answer. That's a one sided perspective.
Would you prefer if I change my diction to 'intense alienation of the moderate public'?
Capt_Fantastic
So you're fine with gays and their devient behavior, as long as they keep to themselves and hide in cramped clubs in alleys or keep their picnics on the same level of display as you'd expect to find at a church luncheon.
Once again, you're reading my posts and extracting preconcieved notion from them. Not once have I ever said or insinuated that. I believe what I said was they need to raise awareness, not march around in lewd outfits.
Capt
You just don't like gays. They're an affront to your masculine self-image. Your opinion of homosexuals are fed by these public displays of non-traditional masculinity and unconventional lifestyle.
No, I don't just not like gays. I really don't care, honestly. Let them be gay. I'm still failing to realize how you're equating the fact that I don't agree with pride parades into I hate gays. I hate pride parades.
Stop playing the hurt minority against the big, evil bigot.
Capt
And to address your last point, can you provide an example of any other kind of parade in which the term "pride" is always part of the title? Any other group with which that term is always applied?
When I say a pride parade, it refers to a parade in which the participants are showcasing aspects of themselves, or the group, in which they are proud of. For example, a military parade can be a pride parade. A gay parade can be a pride parade. The Thanksgiving parade cannot be a pride parade.
X
I have read the topic over the course of several days. It evolved from talking about a predominantly gay neighborhood to discussing the merits of gay pride parades, at which point I'm trying to figure out why there need be merits to any parade. My humblest and most utterly sincere apologies for not following your posts over the course of several days religiously.
You don't have to follow them religiously. Just read them before you start asking me questions.
X
Your viewpoint seems to keep shifting as to why the gay pride parade's are irksome, from it was fun but they disrupt traffic, to "socially deviant" behavior shouldn't be public, to I find all parades stupid but only dislike those which don't "celebrate achievements".
Perhaps complex thought is something alien to you. Let me draw you a nice and clear picture here.
I think all parades are stupid.
I think pride parades that celebrate things people have no control over is an especially idiotic reason to have a parade.
I think gay pride parades are hurtful to the gay community.
And the socially deviant behavior goes right in line with why they are hurtful to the gay community.
Never did I say they are fun but disrupt traffic.
X
Perhaps just perhaps they're celebrating the achievement of being able to live their lifestyle without fear of being arrested for it? Just a thought.
No one is going to arrest a gay person because they are gay.
X
Again you assume that the person of minority could not actually simply be equally qualified. Pshaw, that would be unheard of.
And again you're taking the fact that Affirmitive Action encourages hiring of minorities, whether they are equally qualified or not, and pushing that to the side to make me look I'm a bigot. Please, stop with the self righteousness.
X
It's relevant in that really a parade that basically affects you in no way whatsoever still bothers you and I'm curious as to why.
British people thinking Americans are stupid basically affects me in no way whatsoever, but still bothers me, too. Sorry. Sometimes people can be aggravated by simple acts and beliefs despite not being personally affected by them. It happens more often than you think.
Because they fall within your personal perceived realms of "normal" they are therefore not "socially deviant?" "I'm normal and they're not like me."
What are we talking about here? Mardi Gras? Music Videos? Gays? You lost me.
That was an ambiguous answer. The question is simple: is it the 'pride' part of 'gay pride parade.' As stated below, although apparently all parades are stupid, but you're not anti-parade as a rule.
I think all parades are stupid.
I think pride parades that celebrate things people have no control over is an especially idiotic reason to have a parade.
I think gay pride parades are hurtful to the gay community.
In which case if they dropped the "pride" tag and just held it as a Mardi Gras/Carnival event would you still vehemently dislike it? If so why?
From my understanding, and I'm not the authority by any means, did Mardi Gras start out as a Christian celebration, not a pride parade? If it were just a gay version of Mardi Gras, no, I would not have a problem with it.
I consider you a typical young straight white male, in a predominantly straight-male-dominated-white-majority society. Interpret that as you will.
Okay.
Only anti-pride parade if it's going to be a Mardi Gras; in which case would it be acceptable if they simply called it the Gay Parade and had a Mardi Gras style event?
If gays want to have a Mardi Gras style event, they can feel absolutely free to do so.
"The penalties under Article 125 are severe. Consensual sodomy is punishable by "[d]ishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for 5 years."[x] The criminal penalties for sodomy are in fact more severe than the punishment for negligent homicide, extortion, assault upon a child under 16 years, and aggravated assault other than with a loaded firearm.[xi]" ACLU; although I can't find what they reference [xi] as.
I did not find anything in the UCMJ about specifically assaulting a minor. I could be wrong, though. And, once again.
I still don't quite understand why some people in this topic enjoy attacking me because I'm in the military. Insinuating that I approve of everything in the UCMJ is, well, idiotic.
This is what I hate. As soon as a white guy doesn't agree with something gays or minorities do, he's automatically labled anti-whatever. I don't approve of their pride parades, so I'm a homophobe. Hell, Eis, a gay man, agrees with my view that homosexuality, something he can't control, isn't something to be proud of. It just is. My heterosexuality isn't something to be proud of. I shouldn't get parades just because I'm straight. If gays want to have gay versions of celebrations like Mardi Gras, they should feel free to.