Mace Windu crushing Grievous's Chest

Started by The big EH3 pages
The big EH is it there yet?

Originally posted by LordGrievous
Just as a jedi can deflect lightning without hate. And my other question is being ignored How badly was grievous damaged by the attack?
he wasn't damaged to badly, but it did give him that reaally bad cough, which he had before which but nowhere near as bad

Count Makashi Count Dookus number 1 fan

His lungs wore damaged(colapsed), i would say, that is pretty sewer damage.

MasterAshenVor Grey Jedi

OK I SHALL END THE GREVIOUS DISPUTE =) (The one i started o.o)

OK General G to satisfy your and my mind of all this grevious bashing GREVIOUS KILLED OVER 50 JEDI! *cheers* at least 10 had to be JEDI MASTERS ok....so General Grevious Kicks ass

As for Yoda it was deflection because like it was pointed out so finely befor IT TAKES ALOT OF ANGER TO GENERATE FORCE LIGHTING and YODA HAD NO HATE WATSOEVER. there we go..

Count Makashi Count Dookus number 1 fan

Yoda has to have a little hate, he is still a living individual, because of Sidious all the Jedi died, he had to hate him just a little.

Sorgo X Restricted
Originally posted by General G
That is two very different situations, the gun would shoot quite a bit faster than you would be able to throw it, and even still, the inention for you to throw a bullet back at somebody is with the intent of harm. When Yoda sent the lighting back, it was with the intent to harm or even kill Dooku/Sidious was it not? All because of their religion.

You're taking a figurative statement literally.

General G Canadian.

Originally posted by MasterAshenVor
OK I SHALL END THE GREVIOUS DISPUTE =) (The one i started o.o)

OK General G to satisfy your and my mind of all this grevious bashing GREVIOUS KILLED OVER 50 JEDI! *cheers* at least 10 had to be JEDI MASTERS ok....so General Grevious Kicks ass

Yeah! He kicks major ass! 🪩

Originally posted by Sorgo X
You're taking a figurative statement literally.

Sorry, I was just trying to make a point.

LordGrievous The Knight Slayer

Originally posted by The big EH
you're an idiot, thats just in the games, in the actually movies and books force push and force crush would be the same thing just applied differently

oh yeah insult me cause you can't answer the question how orginal.

General G Canadian.

Indeed.

A Dose Of Vraya Disciple of Inglip

Originally posted by Tangible God
No, Crush is just a stronger version of grip. If a Jedi grips a rock or crushes the rock, that doesn't make him Dark. Only if their intentions are malevolent does it make crush or grip Dark or evil.
Spoiler:
Isn't crush the power that you learn near the end of KOTOR 2

and if so its a power of its own while, according to Jedi academy, grip is a weaker version of choke.

Tangible God Lets all love Lain

Originally posted by A Dose Of Vraya
Spoiler:
Isn't crush the power that you learn near the end of KOTOR 2

and if so its a power of its own while, according to Jedi academy, grip is a weaker version of choke.
It's never been considered wise to base Character's abilities or Force Power's characteristics off of KOTOR Stats. They aren't set in stone rules, more like... guidelines.

Again, a powerful Force user is easily able to disintegrate a rock into dust, but that hardly qualifies as malevolent or evil. If the intention of the User was to harm, maim or kill someone, that's when Good and Evil are brought into debate.

While Mace using Crush on Grievous' chest was certainly intending to harm him, even kill him, it was also an act out of necessity. The Ends justified the Means in this case.

Same argument can be applied to any universally neutral ability. If Jedi never attacked, then the Dark Jedi who rebelled against them in the first place would have won, and never became the Sith. Sheer hypothesis, but the point is still valid.