3 on 3 - Who wins?

Started by Count Makashi7 pages

No, not because of Dooku, i just think, they are a little better.

If in general skills, team 2 is a little better.

That isn't cannon. And its 2 level 9 versus 2 level 9, if you are going by that measurement.

Yes, I was wrong...but I still think team 2 is better😛

Ok and think team 1 is better and lets not post, until we have more then just team 1 and team 2 is better. It has to be more. And i got to go, to sleep.

Let's see what other forumers think.😎

I'd give team two the edge.

Team one's best chance is:

Anakin fights Yoda
Mace fights Sidious
Dooku fights Kenobi

However, Yoda could probably disengage from Anakin if his team really needed help.

Originally posted by Gideon
Advent, you let them videotape us? 😮

Yes, yes indeed that was me. It worked perfectly.. being black and all, I blended in to the darkness...

Originally posted by jollyjim311
I'd give team two the edge.

Team one's best chance is:

Anakin fights Yoda
Mace fights Sidious
Dooku fights Kenobi

However, Yoda could probably disengage from Anakin if his team really needed help.

I agree that team 2 has a greater chance to win. It seems most people here think team 2 would wins too.

Originally posted by jollyjim311
I'd give team two the edge.

Team one's best chance is:

Anakin fights Yoda
Mace fights Sidious
Dooku fights Kenobi

However, Yoda could probably disengage from Anakin if his team really needed help.

The best chance the team 1 has is

Anakin versus Sidious
Mace versus Yoda
Dooku fights Kenobi

And how can Yoda disengage in your scenario and even if he does, it leaves anakin there, do you think he will just watch and do nothing.

Originally posted by Count Makashi
The best chance the team 1 has is

Anakin versus Sidious
Mace versus Yoda
Dooku fights Kenobi

Yes, this is their best chance, but I don't think they will fight like this...so team 2...

good logic

Why not mine? Mace has shown that he can beat Siduos in combat, and would be more efficient against him thanks to Vaapad. Anakin could hold off Yoda in a purely blade competition. Dooku would hold Kenobi out of the fight and eventually defeat him.

No i think mine is better, Mace holds of Yoda, when one of his teammates kills his opponent.

OK...both are the best chances...😛

No, their can be only one.

But I think Mace can take down Sidious quick...like in the movie...

Originally posted by jollyjim311
Why not mine? Mace has shown that he can beat Siduos in combat, and would be more efficient against him thanks to Vaapad. Anakin could hold off Yoda in a purely blade competition. Dooku would hold Kenobi out of the fight and eventually defeat him.

It's good, but i would put Anakin with Kenobi and Dooku with Yoda, as both have been proven to be able to contend with the other in saber combat.

Anakin vs Obiwan, Dooku vs Yoda, and Mace vs Sidious have all been seen in the movies.

Assuming we paired the duelists up via their respective foes, we would have:

Anakin vs. Obi-Wan
Dooku vs. Yoda
Mace vs. Sidious

This is, actually, a difficult fight. Assuming that Mace is equipped with his Shatterpoint ability (which sort've makes the fight unfair, as any dark side foe is immediately at a disadvantage), he will eventually conquer Palpatine in combat. However, this would neither be quick nor easy.

As for Yoda vs. Dooku, it is hypothetically possible that Yoda could comfortably beat Count Dooku in combat. The reason being: we have never seen Yoda go "full-out" on Dooku. Assuming, however, he is still in his conflicted state of mind, he will still win, but the fight will be much longer.

Then it comes down to Obi-Wan vs. Anakin, which is - in many ways - the hardest fight to evaluate. Anakin has the raw power, the strength, and the offensive form in his favor, but Obi-Wan is much more tactical, more experienced, and his defensive skills are impressive. If Anakin can think clearly, he will beat Obi-Wan in a comfortable amount of time. If not, Obi-Wan will defeat him.

My bet? Team One, I see, winning more. But it's not easy, and Dooku will be die.