Pre-retcon Amalgam Brothers discussion

Instead of spreading it across all vs boards, lets keep it in one place, here.

I am going by the fact that they were stated to be supreme, the two staffs fighting about which were the best.
Thats why the nominated heroes (the brothers choosed a couple of heroes to fight for all reality) and let them fight.
In the end they agreed to be equal "You have done well"

And also going by the fact that they were supreme.

So it's either:

Blue Brother > Presence
Red Brother > The-One-Above-All

or

Blue Brother = Presence
Red Brtoher = The-One-Abve-All

Originally posted by Thanos_THOTU
Instead of spreading it across all vs boards, lets keep it in one place, here.

I am going by the fact that they were stated to be supreme, the two staffs fighting about which were the best.
Thats why the nominated heroes (the brothers choosed a couple of heroes to fight for all reality) and let them fight.
In the end they agreed to be equal "You have done well"

And also going by the fact that they were supreme.

So it's either:

Blue Brother > Presence
Red Brother > The-One-Above-All

or

Blue Brother = Presence
Red Brtoher = The-One-Abve-All

Interesting

I think that idea stunk, personally. 😬

The Brothers weren't omnipotent, because they had trouble fighting each other, they weren't omniscient (or else they would already know the outcome of every fight before they set it up), etc.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
The Brothers weren't omnipotent, because they had trouble fighting each other, they weren't omniscient (or else they would already know the outcome of every fight before they set it up), etc.

Originally posted by Thanos_THOTU
Instead of spreading it across all vs boards, lets keep it in one place, here.

I am going by the fact that they were stated to be supreme, the two staffs fighting about which were the best.
Thats why the nominated heroes (the brothers choosed a couple of heroes to fight for all reality) and let them fight.
In the end they agreed to be equal "You have done well"

And also going by the fact that they were supreme.

So it's either:

Blue Brother > Presence
Red Brother > The-One-Above-All

or

Blue Brother = Presence
Red Brtoher = The-One-Abve-All

But no, awesome logic I must say.

Originally posted by Thanos_THOTU
That was the problem, it was a paradox, two omnipotent beings fighting eachother, no one could win nor lose.
Omniscient, no, since the realities just connected there were many things that they didnt know about.

No, the fact that neither of them were capable of defeating the other, means that neither of them were omnipotent.

Originally posted by WorldWarHulk
Funny... because based on your logic, LT and Spectre can fuse two people who made them, and made their every powers.

But no, awesome logic I must say.

I didn't. ❌

There has been certain people saying the Brothers were "owned".

The fact is, they were not.

The Brothers never resisted being merged by Spectre and LT, and once they were merged, the Brothers never attempted to separate themselves.

This event was far from ownage, and wouldn't lead me to think Spectre or LT were in any way more powerful then the Brothers.

The fact of the matter is, LT and Spectre were AWED by the power of the Brothers.

"Power is unleashed that none have ever witnessed....."
"And The Spectre and The Living Tribunal are Awed":

As for this thread, do I believe the Bros were meant to be supreme? ✅

Originally posted by Endless Mike
No, the fact that neither of them were capable of defeating the other, means that neither of them were omnipotent.

What happens when two truly Omnipotent beings fight each other?

Exactly.

They stalemate. 🙂

Dang Galant you beat me to it, however there is one scan you missed.

Spectre (Logos) and the Living Tribunal couldent affect the Brothers. Even though they tried to get their attention, they were beneath their notecing.

Originally posted by Galan007
Again, once the Brothers were merged, did you see them trying to separate themselves?

I didn't. ❌

There has been certain people saying the Brothers were "owned".

The fact is, they were not.

The Brothers never resisted being merged by Spectre and LT, and once they were merged, the Brothers never attempted to separate themselves.

This event was far from ownage, and wouldn't lead me to think Spectre or LT were in any way more powerful then the Brothers.

The fact of the matter is, LT and Spectre were AWED by the power of the Brothers.

"Power is unleashed that [b]none have ever witnessed....."
"And The Spectre and The Living Tribunal are Awed":

As for this thread, do I believe the Bros were meant to be supreme? ✅ [/B]

i agree. 🙂

Originally posted by guy222
Interesting

I will admit to this before this turns into an all out war between Marvel and DC. Post means Before. Pre Brothers were awesome. Post Brothers work for LT. Nuff said

Originally posted by Galan007
Question?

What happens when two truly Omnipotent beings fight each other?

Exactly.

They stalemate. 🙂

No, nothing happens, because it's impossible to have more than one truly omnipotent being. If it is stated that there are more than one, then at least one of them is not omnipotent.

Originally posted by Galan007
Again, once the Brothers were merged, did you see them trying to separate themselves?

I didn't. ❌

There has been certain people saying the Brothers were "owned".

The fact is, they were not.

The Brothers never resisted being merged by Spectre and LT, and once they were merged, the Brothers never attempted to separate themselves.

This event was far from ownage, and wouldn't lead me to think Spectre or LT were in any way more powerful then the Brothers.

The fact of the matter is, LT and Spectre were AWED by the power of the Brothers.

"Power is unleashed that [b]none have ever witnessed....."
"And The Spectre and The Living Tribunal are Awed":

As for this thread, do I believe the Bros were meant to be supreme? ✅ [/B]

You really think that Spectre and LT could fuse the Gods of their universes?

Also...
"The brothers are not happy about it."

It seems that Spectre and LT are actaully fighting against a force to do this...

Look, I don't give a shit if Spectre, or LT were mere pissants to the Brothers.
Fact is, they held them together, and I know for damn sure, Spectre, and LT together aren't doing that to the Gods of their respective universes.

So, unless Spectre, and LT could do that to Jeebus, or God, that kind of rules them out, of being God.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
No, nothing happens, because it's impossible to have more than one truly omnipotent being. If it is stated that there are more than one, then at least one of them is not omnipotent.

Every being is uniqe, since they consist of different atoms, they are different indivudual's and so forth. Now these beings were exactly the same, they were light, darkness, emotions, senses, all energy and matter the universes consisted of.

But the one can not kill the other without the other willing so, so it ended up in a stalemate.

If TOAA and Presence was above Amalglam brothers... they would interfere. WHich they didn't. They are intelligent beings, they wouldn't want to be fused together

Originally posted by WorldWarHulk
I never said anything about the other things.

You really think that Spectre and LT could fuse the Gods of their universes?

Also...
"The brothers are not happy about it."

It seems that Spectre and LT are actaully fighting against a force to do this...

Look, I don't give a shit if Spectre, or LT were mere pissants to the Brothers.
Fact is, they held them together, and I know for damn sure, Spectre, and LT together aren't doing that to the Gods of their respective universes.

So, unless Spectre, and LT could do that to Jeebus, or God, that kind of rules them out, of being God.

"The Brothers are setting the contest their own way...

And you're forgetting, they were supreme.

And even thoguh Spectre and the Living Tribunal fought they they were beneath their notecing. Less than flies.

This is just a view of mine not set in stone, but i like this thread and thought i would participate

I think they could be greater than TOAA and the Presence
Issue #2 marvel vs DC has some interesting info

i would say they are like the parents of TOAA and the Presence

i am at work and will try and put more input at times

Originally posted by WorldWarHulk
Look, I don't give a shit if Spectre, or LT were mere pissants to the Brothers.
Fact is, they held them together, and I know for damn sure, Spectre, and LT together aren't doing that to the Gods of their respective universes.

The Brothers never fought being merged in the first place. 😬

Just because the Bros weren't happy about it, does not mean they fought the merger.

Now if they had fought the merger and failed, (which they didn't), then I could see people trying to bring more light to the scans you posted.

However, those scans are really meaningless if we are trying to compare the Brothers to LT/Spectre.

Now the scan(s) I posted........ You know, the ones that say LT and Spectre were AWED by the power of the Brothers, is most certainly one worth mentioning. 🙂

Originally posted by Endless Mike
No, nothing happens, because it's impossible to have more than one truly omnipotent being. If it is stated that there are more than one, then at least one of them is not omnipotent.

Are you trying to say that one company (Marvel or DC), can have a truly omnipotent being, and the other company can not? 😐