KMC Comic Book Tiers

Originally posted by Validus
I didn't get nasty with you until you started that popularity contest bullshit. As I said before, I'm tired of you and the random Hulk fanboy who decides to poke his head out of his mother's basement coming in here and throwing lame insults. It's weak. It's tired. It's stupid. Period.

Mr. Sinister should be low herald.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Um, who did I insult? Not you. Not anyone. i said this tier thing was a popularity contest when it started. Is that something new to you? Calm your ass down. And stop taking me so seriously. If you didn't think FS or Sersi should be moved up fine. I do. Hell sersi can zap pretty much anyone into a toaster and Firestorm can take at least 4/10 with most of the top tiers. Hell sentry is up there and I fail to see the need for him there. Popularity.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Um, who did I insult? Not you. Not anyone. i said this tier thing was a popularity contest when it started. Is that something new to you? Calm your ass down. And stop taking me so seriously. If you didn't think FS or Sersi should be moved up fine. I do. Hell sersi can zap pretty much anyone into a toaster and Firestorm can take at least 4/10 with most of the top tiers. Hell sentry is up there and I fail to see the need for him there. Popularity.

I couldn't care less if you insulted me but since Digi and I more or less take responsibility for this topic, I kind of have the burden of reading every post in here and your popularity contest nonsense rings in my head. Mainly because you keep repeating it but also because it doesn't even make sense.

Originally posted by Harry Fingerman
Popularity contest you say?

Wolverine for trans? Spider-Man is too high to be on this list.

Originally posted by Validus
How about Superman for low street level? There's a poll on this forum with him winning as the least liked character on KMC and this IS a popularity contest after all.

Plus, I retract my Wolverine statement, because I believe Wolverine came in second on that list.

Originally posted by Validus
First of all, you should know by now I hardly take you seriously.

I couldn't care less if you insulted me but since Digi and I more or less take responsibility for this topic, I kind of have the burden of reading every post in here and your popularity contest nonsense rings in my head. Mainly because you keep repeating it but also because it doesn't even make sense.

Then why in the hell is stardust above beta ray? Why is starhawk so low? Why is Infinity Man on the same tier as top tiers? When he's clearly shown to be superior? Why is Flash on the same tier as Wonder Woman? Captain atom on the same tier as Wonder Woman? She's knocked him out with one punch. Supergirl on the same tier with wonder woman? WTF. Lobo bitched her and WG and Miss Martian. How does major force vex kyle and Captain atom and yet end up so far below them? These are only a few of the things that perplex me. And sorry if you took offense. It wasn't directed towards you. It's more of a statement of generality. And for the record, Hulk is one lvl too low. ANd I hate him with a passion. ( just becuz of the hulk fanboys.) And Morg lower than surfer? Aren't they nearly evenly matched?

Why in the hell would Stardust be more popular than Beta Ray Bill?

That's as far as I could read into your statement...

Originally posted by Harry Fingerman
Why in the hell would Stardust be more popular than Beta Ray Bill?

That's as far as I could read into your statement...

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Who the hell knows. He sure as hell doesn't seem more powerful than the snout. maybe even. And him and firelord seemed to be around the same lvl when they held back that blast from the galactus eating machine do hicky.

Also, he's a lot more versatile than Beta, and about as powerful, and pretty much unbeatable.

Hard to compare, when they are side by side... and Firelord might be as powerful as him (eh, no), but Hulk is stronger than Thor, and look where he is, and it's fo a reason.

Originally posted by Harry Fingerman
Maybe it's because he isn't... duh!

Also, he's a lot more versatile than Beta, and about as powerful, and pretty much unbeatable.

Hard to compare, when they are side by side... and Firelord might be as powerful as him (eh, no), but Hulk is stronger than Thor, and look where he is, and it's fo a reason.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Then why in the hell is stardust above beta ray?

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Why is starhawk so low? Why is Infinity Man on the same tier as top tiers?

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Why is Flash on the same tier as Wonder Woman?

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Captain atom on the same tier as Wonder Woman? She's knocked him out with one punch.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Supergirl on the same tier with wonder woman? WTF. Lobo bitched her and WG and Miss Martian.

Second, she's beaten Martian Manhunter, John Stewart, Flash. Escaped Raven's soul self. Has light speed travel. One shotted Solomon Grundy who had just defeated the entire JSA. Dislocated Superboy's jaw with one blow who is in the Low Herald bracket (for now). Beat Blackrock right after Blackrock had just gotten the better of Superman. I could go on.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
How does major force vex kyle and Captain atom and yet end up so far below them?

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
And for the record, Hulk is one lvl too low. ANd I hate him with a passion. ( just becuz of the hulk fanboys.) And Morg lower than surfer? Aren't they nearly evenly matched?

Actually, I agree Hulk should be Mid Herald and was planning on bringing that up pretty soon.

Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
I'd wager Firestorm, Quasar, Captain Atom, or anyone like that could beat the shit out of stardust. Absorbtion for the win. Hell a good gl can do it. Kilowog certainly could. Where is Kil on this list? I just think the list is a lil shakey is all. I certainly don't see Supergirl on the same lvl as Wonder Woman and Lobo. And Flash beats wonder woman all day every day. Flash is Top lvl for sure.

Anyway, if you think Stardust is more popular then Beta, then you're on crack, or raisins, or something.

Kilowog isn't popular, so he's a level behind high-herald. Neither is Black Adam, neither is Captain Marvel... but Spartan 3.0 on the other hand...

The problem is, you hype Diana up so much, it's ridonkules. No one cares anymore, no one cares.

Originally posted by Validus
Because Stardust was clearly more powerful than Bill during their fight. Beta Ray Bill was never able to actually him damage at all once Stardust revealed his true form.

Because nobody has brought it up for vote yet.

1. Each tier is pretty wide in what it encompasses.
2. List includes PIS/CIS.

Captain Atom has more than one showing to his name. He's also beaten Firestorm who you want to be High Herald.

First of all, Lobo did no such thing. Quit exaggerating.

Second, she's beaten Martian Manhunter, John Stewart, Flash. Escaped Raven's soul self. Has light speed travel. One shotted Solomon Grundy who had just defeated the entire JSA. Dislocated Superboy's jaw with one blow who is in the Low Herald bracket (for now). Beat Blackrock right after Blackrock had just gotten the better of Superman. I could go on.

Captain Atom has beaten Force with a touch more than once. Kyle has beaten Force easily on more than one occasion once he took of the kid gloves. He is not on their level at all.

Surfer is more versatile than Morg. Far more. He beat him once he stopped holding back. I guess it's arguable though.

Actually, I agree Hulk should be Mid Herald and was planning on bringing that up pretty soon.

Originally posted by Harry Fingerman
Just because he's an energy being, doesn't mean he's going to get absorbed.

Hell, he himself has absorbed his entire race.

Anyway, if you think Stardust is more popular then Beta, then you're on crack, or raisins, or something.

Kilowog isn't popular, so he's a level behind high-herald. Neither is Black Adam, neither is Captain Marvel... but Spartan 3.0 on the other hand...

The problem is, you hype Diana up so much, it's ridonkules. No one cares anymore, no one cares.

So, what, Lobo's not popular?

**** Diana. She isn't my main concern. She can stay where she is until the JLA writer who likes her, and gail give her worthy feats. Which are coming. And I can see Kil Taking 5/10 against stardust. Didn't kil absorb his race too? And they were matter before hand right? Transmutation and absorbtion. 🙄

I agree with Hulk moving up one.

I think Dr. Manhattan should be Transcendant. I wouldn't put him on par with other skyfathers, he's got tons of CIS, and makes no use of any precognition he has.

Meh

I do think Kilowog should be up there with Hal and Kyle for that matter.

Originally posted by Validus
Meh

I do think Kilowog should be up there with Hal and Kyle for that matter.

And Kil was giving as good as he took with What's his face from the corps. Who kills like 10 lanterns a whop. The other ugly face. can't think of his name. He needs to be on the list too.

It's hard to rank Sin Corps members as they have so few showings. The GLC is cutting through them like butter now that they can kill.

I nominate Synn For trans lvl.
Infinity Man for trans
Mary Marvel for high Herald lvl
Wog for high herald lvl
Mogo for trans lvl wihtout the ?
Morg for high Herald
Firelord for high Herald
Orion for High herald lvl
and Hulk for Mid.

OH and Starhawk seems to me to be as powerful as any other top tier or more so. But I dont' own all of his showings. But he does need to be bumped at least one tier up.