KMC Comic Book Tiers

Seems like we're voting on too many things at once. Unless someone can make sense of it, we should try to simplify it and focus on 1-2 at a time.

And remember, if opinion seems mixed, we either leave the person where they are or keep them in the lower of the two that are being debated. If you can't get a solid majority, let it go.

...

And I've been talking with the guys over at herochat some. A couple things I think we should consider:
- Moving Circe down from trans.
- Creating placements for multiple incarnations of Doomsday, since he's not always at the same level.

Doomsday point: 👆

Does anyone agree with Nova for High Herald?

I read Nova #7. All he did was fly into a wormhole.

Originally posted by Validus
I read Nova #7. All he did was fly into a wormhole.

I mean, it's cool he withstood the force of that much gravity and all... But does that one feat make Nova high-herald worthy?

Nah. ermm

Sersi to Mid Herald so far is 3 (Y), 0 (N).

Can we move her?

Dr. Manhattan to Trans: 2 (Y), 0 (N)

Mr. Sinister to Low Herald: 1 (Y), 1 (N)

Originally posted by SnazzySmurph
Sersi to Mid Herald so far is 3 (Y), 0 (N).

Can we move her?

Dr. Manhattan to Trans: 2 (Y), 0 (N)

Mr. Sinister to Low Herald: 1 (Y), 1 (N)

Onimar Synn is already Trans level.

LOL @ Firelord being High Herald. Just no.

I'd like to hear the argument for putting Hulk at mid.

Mid Herald?

No, just no. 😐

In the same tier as Beta Ray, the Flashes, a few Green Lanterns, Black Adam, Captain Marvel, Zod, Quasar, Wonder Woman, Doomsday, the Fallen One, Firestorm....

I know it's not about direct comparisons - but if the Hulk was mid-herald, everyone I just named has a decent shot at top.

Originally posted by llagrok
They both cut through the x-men like butter. Only Sinister has mentioned many times that Apocalypse is above him.

There's a reason while Sinister fled after he had tried to affect Apocalypse with that virus that he healed over.

Sinister has telepathy stated to be comparable to the likes of Emma Frost, Prof X, Jean Grey and Exodus.

He can't be defeated physically.

He uses his powers much more intelligently than Apocalypse.

He's got teleportation, class 10 telekinesis, flight, energy blasts, super strength, and is a super genius. He's humiliated the X-Men tons of times.

He deserves to be a Low Herald, though only bottom of the ladder.

Originally posted by Hyperion 07
Mid Herald?

No, just no. 😐

Originally posted by Soljer
In the same tier as Beta Ray, the Flashes, a few Green Lanterns, Black Adam, Captain Marvel, Zod, Quasar, Wonder Woman, Doomsday, the Fallen One, Firestorm....

I know it's not about direct comparisons - but if the Hulk was mid-herald, everyone I just named has a decent shot at top.

Not my argument. Someone bought it up last night and said they had a basis for it.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Not my argument. Someone bought it up last night and said they had a basis for it.

'He's teh stronger 'den dem!'

With Hulk's current showings, I would agree for Mid Herald.

Originally posted by Soljer
'He's teh stronger 'den dem!'

Validus usually has slightly more coherent arguments than that.

He's quite powerful, but no moreso than Savage had potential to become. His increased intelligence is a boon, but being totally one-dimensional limits him in ways that a bit of strategy cannot overcome.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Validus usually has slightly more coherent arguments than that.

Vally? Nuh uh! 😛. More seriously, though, I'm totally open to listening to an argument - I just can't imagine it being incredibly convincing.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Validus usually has slightly more coherent arguments than that.

herbcry

Originally posted by Soljer
He's quite powerful, but no moreso than Savage had potential to become. His increased intelligence is a boon, but being totally one-dimensional limits him in ways that a bit of strategy cannot overcome.

Granted... but it seems his physiology, healing factor, and strength potential make up for some of that.

Despite some of the PIS in World War Hulk (BB, Strange, etc.), I think Hulk's feats put him at bottom-of-the-ladder Mid Herald.

Whats so PIS about the BB thing? He just become strong enough to withstand the scream.

We know his anger changes all the time.