KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by B.A485 pages
B.A Restricted

Mid meta someone said about a page or 2 ago.

Soljer Beware my Power
Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
I thought Captain America has Superstrength and such.

He has arguable low-end Superstrength. Class 1 or 2 - but that's certainly not enough to justify a low-meta placement.

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted

Originally posted by pr1983
oh, then:

Ravenous to low. For: 5 (llag, TP, Digi, Val, Qual) Against: 5 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash, boo)
Kurse to high herald. For: 3 (Mighty, ill, lord) Against: 1 (Qual)
Sentry to Mid herald. For: 8 (Trick, Soljer, Red, Qual, ill, lordboo, dube, Pr1983) Against: 10 (Bran, Val, Nvr, Strength, Mano, Battle, Priest, V, Skeets, Smurf)
Starman to Low herald. For: 2 (Skeets, Val) Against: 0
Dr. light (Kimiyo) to Low Herald. For: 2 (Pr1983, Bran) Against: 1 (llagrok)

---
Wonder Woman to low herald. For: 8 (Skeets, Bran, Val, Strength, Soljer, Priest, Stacks, llag) Against: 4 (Spauld, Nvr, Trick, Pr1983)
Martian Manhunter to low Herald. For: 6 (Skeets, Bran, Spauld, Soljer, Val, Ass) Against: 3 (Strength, Trick, llag)

Flash I (Jay Garrick) to Low Herald. For: [b]2 (Val, Pr1983) Against: 0

Classic Supes? [/B]

I am so against WW being moved to low herald. And a special hearing should be made for this. Cuz I can present a very good argument that she is far from low herald and it's prolly due to spite that she is being moved. At least on some of my "enemies". 😛

Soljer Beware my Power

Oh, and Soljer's definitely for Jay to low herald.

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted
Originally posted by Soljer
He has arguable low-end Superstrength. Class 1 or 2 - but that's certainly not enough to justify a low-meta placement.

I'd say Low Meta.

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted
Originally posted by Soljer
Oh, and Soljer's definitely for Jay to low herald.

now how in the hell would jay get low herald and him and wonder woman are like the same speed?

Val Senior Member

Ravenous to low. For: 5 (llag, TP, Digi, Val, Qual) Against: 5 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash, boo)
Kurse to high herald. For: 3 (Mighty, ill, lord) Against: 1 (Qual)
Sentry to Mid herald. For: 8 (Trick, Soljer, Red, Qual, ill, lordboo, dube, Pr1983) Against: 10 (Bran, Val, Nvr, Strength, Mano, Battle, Priest, V, Skeets, Smurf)
Starman to Low herald. For: 2 (Skeets, Val) Against: 0
Dr. light (Kimiyo) to Low Herald. For: 2 (Pr1983, Bran) Against: 1 (llagrok)

---
Wonder Woman to low herald. For: 8 (Skeets, Bran, Val, Strength, Soljer, Priest, Stacks, llag) Against: 4 (Spauld, Nvr, Trick, Pr1983)
Martian Manhunter to low Herald. For: 6 (Skeets, Bran, Spauld, Soljer, Val, Ass) Against: 3 (Strength, Trick, llag)

Flash I (Jay Garrick) to Low Herald. For: 3 (Val, Pr1983, Soljer) Against: 0

pr1983 Hey Yo!
Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
I am so against WW being moved to low herald. And a special hearing should be made for this. Cuz I can present a very good argument that she is far from low herald and it's prolly due to spite that she is being moved. At least on some of my "enemies". 😛

nvr, no offense, but your argument for ww would probably end up having her bumped down... 😬

Soljer Beware my Power

Captain America to low meta ( 😆 😂 😆 😂 ): For: 2 (Alfheim, Nvr) Against: 3 llag, Soljer, BA

Val Senior Member
Originally posted by Soljer
Captain America to low meta ( 😆 😂 😆 😂 ): For: 2 (Alfheim, Nvr) Against: 4 llag, Soljer, BA, Val
B.A Restricted

Um Superman for mid meta to get it actually started. remember who said it.

pr1983 Hey Yo!

Ravenous to low. For: 5 (llag, TP, Digi, Val, Qual) Against: 5 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash, boo)
Kurse to high herald. For: 3 (Mighty, ill, lord) Against: 1 (Qual)
Sentry to Mid herald. For: 8 (Trick, Soljer, Red, Qual, ill, lordboo, dube, Pr1983) Against: 10 (Bran, Val, Nvr, Strength, Mano, Battle, Priest, V, Skeets, Smurf)
Starman to Low herald. For: 2 (Skeets, Val) Against: 0
Dr. light (Kimiyo) to Low Herald. For: 2 (Pr1983, Bran) Against: 1 (llagrok)

---
Wonder Woman to low herald. For: 8 (Skeets, Bran, Val, Strength, Soljer, Priest, Stacks, llag) Against: 4 (Spauld, Nvr, Trick, Pr1983)
Martian Manhunter to low Herald. For: 6 (Skeets, Bran, Spauld, Soljer, Val, Ass) Against: 3 (Strength, Trick, llag)

Flash I (Jay Garrick) to Low Herald. For: 3 (Val, Pr1983, Soljer) Against: 0

Captain America to low meta. For: 2 (Alfheim, Nvr) Against: 5 (llag, Soljer, BA, Val, Pr1983)

Classic Superman to mid meta. For: 1 (B.A) Against: 0

B.A Restricted

Originally posted by B.A
Um Superman for mid meta to get it actually started. remember who said it.
😖hifty:

Erik-Lensherr "The devil made me do it"

Against Wonder Woman to low herald
For Sentry to Mid Herald
Against Martiah Manhunter to low herald
For Flash I to low Herald
Against Captain America to low Meta

Against Classic Superman to be on the list at all.

Val Senior Member

Originally posted by Erik-Lensherr
Against Classic Superman to be on the list at all.

Lulz.

Seriously, I kind of agree.

JasonK4 Restricted
Originally posted by Soljer
Captain America to low meta ( 😆 😂 😆 😂 ): For: 2 (Alfheim, Nvr) Against: 5 llag, Soljer, BA, Val and Jason.
Ouallada Senior Member

Originally posted by pr1983
Ravenous to low. For: 5 (llag, TP, Digi, Val, Qual) Against: 5 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash, boo)
Kurse to high herald. For: 3 (Mighty, ill, lord) Against: 1 (Qual)
Sentry to Mid herald. For: 8 (Trick, Soljer, Red, Qual, ill, lordboo, dube, Pr1983) Against: 10 (Bran, Val, Nvr, Strength, Mano, Battle, Priest, V, Skeets, Smurf)
Starman to Low herald. For: 2 (Skeets, Val) Against: 0
Dr. light (Kimiyo) to Low Herald. For: 2 (Pr1983, Bran, Ouallada ) Against: 1 (llagrok)

---
Wonder Woman to low herald. For: 8 (Skeets, Bran, Val, Strength, Soljer, Priest, Stacks, llag) Against: 4 (Spauld, Nvr, Trick, Pr1983)
Martian Manhunter to low Herald. For: 6 (Skeets, Bran, Spauld, Soljer, Val, Ass) Against: 3 (Strength, Trick, llag)

Flash I (Jay Garrick) to Low Herald. For: 3 (Val, Pr1983, Soljer, Ouallada) Against: 0

Captain America to low meta. For: 2 (Alfheim, Nvr) Against: 5 (llag, Soljer, BA, Val, Pr1983, Ouallada)

Classic Superman to mid meta. For: 1 (B.A) Against: 0

Classic Superman refers to which version? When he first came out? Silver age? Just precrisis?

pr1983 Hey Yo!

Ravenous to low. For: 5 (llag, TP, Digi, Val, Qual) Against: 5 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash, boo)
Kurse to high herald. For: 3 (Mighty, ill, lord) Against: 1 (Qual)
Sentry to Mid herald. For: 9 (Trick, Soljer, Red, Qual, ill, lordboo, dube, Pr1983, Erik-Lensherr) Against: 10 (Bran, Val, Nvr, Strength, Mano, Battle, Priest, V, Skeets, Smurf)
Starman to Low herald. For: 2 (Skeets, Val) Against: 0
Dr. light (Kimiyo) to Low Herald. For: 2 (Pr1983, Bran) Against: 1 (llagrok)

---
Wonder Woman to low herald. For: 8 (Skeets, Bran, Val, Strength, Soljer, Priest, Stacks, llag) Against: 5 (Spauld, Nvr, Trick, Pr1983, Erik-Lensherr)
Martian Manhunter to low Herald. For: 6 (Skeets, Bran, Spauld, Soljer, Val, Ass) Against: 4 (Strength, Trick, llag, Erik-Lensherr)

Flash I (Jay Garrick) to Low Herald. For: 4 (Val, Pr1983, Soljer, Erik-Lensherr) Against: 0

Captain America to low meta. For: 2 (Alfheim, Nvr) Against: 6 (llag, Soljer, BA, Val, Pr1983, Erik-Lensherr)

Superman is dumped, then...

Val Senior Member

You guys suck at adding yourself to the lists. 😛

Ravenous to low. For: 5 (llag, TP, Digi, Val, Oual) Against: 5 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash, boo)
Kurse to high herald. For: 3 (Mighty, ill, lord) Against: 1 (Oual)
Sentry to Mid herald. For: 9 (Trick, Soljer, Red, Oual, ill, lordboo, dube, Pr1983, Erik) Against: 10 (Bran, Val, Nvr, Strength, Mano, Battle, Priest, V, Skeets, Smurf)
Starman to Low herald. For: 2 (Skeets, Val) Against: 0
Dr. light (Kimiyo) to Low Herald. For: 4 (Pr1983, Bran, Ouallada, Val) Against: 1 (llagrok)

---
Wonder Woman to low herald. For: 8 (Skeets, Bran, Val, Strength, Soljer, Priest, Stacks, llag) Against: 5 (Spauld, Nvr, Trick, Pr1983, Erik)
Martian Manhunter to low Herald. For: 6 (Skeets, Bran, Spauld, Soljer, Val, Ass) Against: 4 (Strength, Trick, llag, Erik)

Flash I (Jay Garrick) to Low Herald. For: 5 (Val, Pr1983, Soljer, Ouallada, Erik) Against: 0

Captain America to low meta. For: 2 (Alfheim, Nvr) Against: 8 (llag, Soljer, BA, Val, Pr1983, Jason, Ouallada, Erik)

Classic Superman to mid meta. For: 1 (B.A) Against: 0

pr1983 Hey Yo!

Originally posted by Val
You guys suck at adding yourself to the lists. 😛

Ravenous to low. For: 5 (llag, TP, Digi, Val, Qual) Against: 5 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash, boo)
Kurse to high herald. For: 3 (Mighty, ill, lord) Against: 1 (Qual)
Sentry to Mid herald. For: 8 (Trick, Soljer, Red, Qual, ill, lordboo, dube, Pr1983) Against: 10 (Bran, Val, Nvr, Strength, Mano, Battle, Priest, V, Skeets, Smurf)
Starman to Low herald. For: 2 (Skeets, Val) Against: 0
Dr. light (Kimiyo) to Low Herald. For: 4 (Pr1983, Bran, Quallada, Val) Against: 1 (llagrok)

---
Wonder Woman to low herald. For: 8 (Skeets, Bran, Val, Strength, Soljer, Priest, Stacks, llag) Against: 4 (Spauld, Nvr, Trick, Pr1983)
Martian Manhunter to low Herald. For: 6 (Skeets, Bran, Spauld, Soljer, Val, Ass) Against: 3 (Strength, Trick, llag)

Flash I (Jay Garrick) to Low Herald. For: 4 (Val, Pr1983, Soljer, Quallada) Against: 0

Captain America to low meta. For: 2 (Alfheim, Nvr) Against: 8 (llag, Soljer, BA, Val, Pr1983, Jason, Quallada, Erik)

Classic Superman to mid meta. For: 1 (B.A) Against: 0

i tried *shrug*