KMC Comic Book Tiers

Originally posted by Newjak
I still say DM should be mid-herald at best.

😛

We may remove him altogether. The recently-mentioned appearance minimum may not be a totally bad idea, in order to avoid such controversies.

I'm for counting a certain number of feats, it helps to evade new hyped ill defined characters and to classify better.

However, fights between two ill defined hyped and new characters are not useful to be counted as feats -looking at A-bomb and Red Hulk-.

Originally posted by Bentley
I'm for counting a certain number of feats

not really.

Omega red should be moved higher

If you ask me he is where he should be.

Why are there two Vance Astro in the list?

.........how is he were he should be? every one in his level would get stomp by him. Hell red would stomp most every one two level above him..........

The dude has vast superhuman strength, reflexes, durability, agility, speed, has tenticles, has range attacks, has lethal pheramones, A detah factor and one of the greatest healing factors in comics...........

He is one of the big fishes of his class, and it is normal that people can hang against guys in a few tiers over them -heck, Wolverine has defeated people two tiers above him too-. None of those things guarantee to get into a higher class.

Where would you put him anyways?

Originally posted by Bentley
He is one of the big fishes of his class, and it is normal that people can hang against guys in a few tiers over them -heck, Wolverine has defeated people two tiers above him too-. None of those things guarantee to get into a higher class.

Where would you put him anyways?

He at the very least the tier above his if not two tiers above.

The dude has been strong enough to restrain class 100's..........durable enough to take a boozoka with no ill effect.......heals fast enough that piercing attacks heal instantly........fast enough to delfect bullets....and chase down cars......that not even closes to his bets abilties

Originally posted by Battlehammer
The dude has been strong enough to restrain class 100's..........durable enough to take a boozoka with no ill effect.......heals fast enough that piercing attacks heal instantly........fast enough to delfect bullets....and chase down cars......that not even closes to his bets abilties

Well, Gambit deflects bullets, Wolverine has a healing factor and Deathstroke has weird feats. I however, hardly see Omega Red compete in a tier that has Powergirl and Kang on it (though Kang should totally not be there, but the vote kind of died a few pages ago).

I can conceive Omega Red in mid meta level, but I would like to hear what others think about it, as my knowledge of the character and the ranking itself is limited.

Originally posted by Bentley
Well, Gambit deflects bullets, Wolverine has a healing factor and Deathstroke has weird feats. I however, hardly see Omega Red compete in a tier that has Powergirl and Kang on it (though Kang should totally not be there, but the vote kind of died a few pages ago).

I can conceive Omega Red in mid meta level, but I would like to hear what others think about it, as my knowledge of the character and the ranking itself is limited.

true gamibt can do this, but gambit down not also have the ability to run faster then a car, restrain colossus, take a boozaka to no effect, heal untold amounts of damage instantly, kill pritty much any one close to him within seconds by realses pheramones, or the ability to drain other life force, or having unbreakable tenticles, and almost limitless stamina

Mid sounds right for Red. High would be silly. Most of those feats listed aren't anywhere near high-end feats for high metas, or even mid-level feats for the good ones.

I'll vote for a bump to mid, though, and make that the official motion.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Mid sounds right for Red. High would be silly. Most of those feats listed aren't anywhere near high-end feats for high metas, or even mid-level feats for the good ones.

I'll vote for a bump to mid, though, and make that the official motion.

What about Hulk's son Skaar?

I vote for Mid too, since no one is putting him down and he genuinely seems about most people in his rank.

If not just to keep the thread moving...

I think Skaar has not enough feats to enter in the fray.

(Does anyone else thinks that there should be some added rules related to feats to enter someone here, I mean, at least the basic rule of "the character must've been defeated"😉

Omega Red for Mid.

I vote for Bentley's idea.

Villians should have a different standard for their tiers. They won't ahve enough showings or appearances. And unless they are comsic forces like Galactus, They won't be rending any galaxies. I'd say their win loss stalemate record should be the standard.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Villians should have a different standard for their tiers. They won't ahve enough showings or appearances. And unless they are comsic forces like Galactus, They won't be rending any galaxies. I'd say their win loss stalemate record should be the standard.

Fight records aren't bad, but I still would propose the "having lost" clause, otherwise it gets tricky. Also, it should depend if they have some mad skills too, as it seems that prep abilities -and others- should be considered into the character for the tier.
Would you consider putting Forge or Elixir in just by battle feats?

Originally posted by Bentley
Fight records aren't bad, but I still would propose the "having lost" clause, otherwise it gets tricky. Also, it should depend if they have some mad skills too, as it seems that prep abilities -and others- should be considered into the character for the tier.
Would you consider putting Forge or Elixir in just by battle feats?

By that logic, we should also have a seperate list for every b or c-list hero who doesn't get as much facetime as Ironman and Superman, and we shouldn't start judging characters by their feats, because they get less face time.

Villains stay on this list.