KMC Comic Book Tiers

Originally posted by Digi
Regardless of the BH/Raoul discussion, Omega Red discussion is being officially closed. There's quite a few 'against' and only one 'for.' BH is entitled to his opinion, and has provided his reasoning, but the matter is closed as far as this thread goes.

I think intelligence and prep-related power should be regarded in the "total power" criteria of the thread. That's what I've always thought in regards to Adam, and others like him. Adam Warlock is in High Herald for similar reasons, since his raw power showings don't equal some others in the category.

Hey. uhuh

don't lump me in to this...

Originally posted by The Nuul
Victor Mancha is a android those so called "spores/pheromones" wont work on it...... 😆

facepalm

I've got some feats in the runaways respect thread

*points to sig*

Haven't uploaded v3 yet tho.

Cool thanks..

Originally posted by tjcoady
Battlehammer, I like you, but you need to get over your ridiculous Wolverine-crush. There's a whole world of comics out there to read.

I mean, you know pheromones can't do anything to Victor Mancha, if you've read anything with him in it before (seeing as how he's a machine...) or you're just making things up to boost up a Wolverine enemy because of a fanboy love for him. Stop it. You're better than that.

LOL It has utterly nothing to do with me liking wolverine. There no the same character there not even close to similar.

Never read anything about him before I was just gving nuul a hard time.

Fanboy love? How does boosting omega red help me at all? Red utterly stomps logan everytime they fight. Logan really stands zero chances of beating red. Only reason Logan ever a match for red is when red not using death factor and he toying with wolveirne to test his abilties asside form that he normall just beats the hell out of Logan.

so please dont assume I am doing this out of some love for wolverine, becuase it has nothing to do with wolverine at all.

on a side note I like colossus better then omega red, I just Know from my knwoledge of both characters colossus is inferior and has shown to be.

Originally posted by The Nuul
Victor Mancha is a android those so called "spores/pheromones" wont work on it...... 😆

facepalm

they work on lady death strike who is android as well........

Originally posted by Digi
Regardless of the BH/Raoul discussion, Omega Red discussion is being officially closed. There's quite a few 'against' and only one 'for.' BH is entitled to his opinion, and has provided his reasoning, but the matter is closed as far as this thread goes

yea and I seem to be the only who actually provided a valid reason for my opinion.......

Originally posted by Battlehammer
they work on lady death strike who is android as well........

she's a cyborg. there's a difference.

Yup, cyborgs are part human, so you can have sex with them w/o feeling guilty.

Originally posted by Raoul
she's a cyborg. there's a difference.

oh yea true, got mixed up there.

Originally posted by Mindset
Yup, cyborgs are part human, so you can have sex with them w/o feeling guilty.

bingo.

wait. you'd feel guilty boinking an android?

It's like having sex with a soulless husk aka Paris Hilton.

Originally posted by Mindset
It's like having sex with a soulless husk aka Paris Hilton.

i'd feel pity for them not having a soul... but guilty?

Originally posted by Digi
I think intelligence and prep-related power should be regarded in the "total power" criteria of the thread. That's what I've always thought in regards to Adam, and others like him. Adam Warlock is in High Herald for similar reasons, since his raw power showings don't equal some others in the category.

And this is why universe spanning/earth conquering/time abstract stopping Kang should be in low herald. 😉

Originally posted by Digi

I think intelligence and prep-related power should be regarded in the "total power" criteria of the thread. That's what I've always thought in regards to Adam, and others like him. Adam Warlock is in High Herald for similar reasons, since his raw power showings don't equal some others in the category.

Then shouldn't Batman be somewhere in the meta tier? Or even Robin? I mean both characters show tremendous amounts of intelligence and ingenuity that allows them to school people on higher tiers,and if intelligence is factored as overall power,then they should be ranked higher.

If we're gonna apply that logic,you'd have to move a shitload of characters up,or move Adam down.Either way,he's too high.

The last page's conclusion is that Raoul sexes everything that moves and has the basic structures for such an act.

Also..I don't think taking intelligence/prep time into account when making the tiers is such a good ideea.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Also..I don't think taking intelligence/prep time into account when making the tiers is such a good ideea.

Agreed.

Originally posted by Philosophía
The last page's conclusion is that Raoul sexes everything that moves and has the basic structures for such an act.

Also..I don't think taking intelligence/prep time into account when making the tiers is such a good ideea.

it also has to resemble a female. like that chick from andromeda. hologram/robot or not, she was fine...

See, it's easy to find examples that seem to poke holes in what I was saying (Batman, Kang, etc.). But here's my point. Batman's a high street. We know this. But he has prep-god skills that occasionally can make him much greater. So if Batman was, say, straddling two tiers, I'd heartily recommend the higher one because of this fact. And if maybe Blob was straddling two tiers, I'd recommend the lower because he's never going to bring anything more to the table. This isn't the case with Bats, but it comes into play with characters like Adam Warlock and Adam Strange, whose intelligence and tactical genius is an intrinsic part of their character.

So I'm just saying that it shouldn't be ignored. We shouldn't base everything off of prep powers, because not every situation includes prep. Thus, prep skills alone don't make up their "total power." But it should be considered. How much so? I don't know. Like I said, I try to use it as a tiebreaker when there's a discrepancy. But there's no exact criteria for the list, because doing so would make it impossible.

Tactical genius is a factor now? f*ck.

maybe we should have better guide lines for tiers.

I mean it seems like we just make it up depending from character to character which seems wrong.

Maybe we should have a sort of point system