KMC Comic Book Tiers

What are you voting?

Originally posted by King Kandy
What are you voting?

I hadn't really thought about whether or not I was going to vote. As there's still discussion, the matter isn't over for either side, and I may not vote at all. I voted for Zemo's move. That's it.

Now. Hopefully we can get back to regular discussion, if there is more to be had. If someone could post updated vote counts for Zemo and genis, it would be appreciated.

Genis to trans:

For: Naija boy, kgkg, Enyalus, King Kandy, Nihilist

Against: Kris Blaze, iceman24567, batdude123

Discussion seems to have slowed. I'll look over everything in the coming days and see if anything needs changing.

I was also about to start Doom for Low herald discussion. But I see he's there already (silly me).

The Flash (Wally West), Beta Ray Bill, Gladiator, Captain Marvel, Black Adam, Orion should all be High Herald level in my opinion.

I forward Stryfe to be Low Herald.

He simply does not wield Cable or X-Man level of power.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
The Flash (Wally West), Beta Ray Bill, Gladiator, Captain Marvel, Black Adam, Orion should all be High Herald level in my opinion.

Disagree on all counts. Except maybe BA. But probably not even that. Sorry.

I could back Wally and maybe Orion, but bar that, not sure.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
The Flash (Wally West), Beta Ray Bill, Gladiator, Captain Marvel, Black Adam, Orion should all be High Herald level in my opinion.

They can compete with the high guys in a fight to a certain extent, but they lack their multitude of high end feats. Something that would only come from having your own series for a long time.

I would only back Wally and/or Barry.

Originally posted by id369
I forward Stryfe to be Low Herald.

He simply does not wield Cable or X-Man level of power.

Umm, isn't Stryfe basically just Cable without the techno-organic virus?

Originally posted by Bad Ash231
Umm, isn't Stryfe basically just Cable without the techno-organic virus?

Originally posted by id369
Yes Stryfe is Cable with out the T.O. Only significantly weaker.

Why is that?

Originally posted by Digi
Disagree on all counts. Except maybe BA. But probably not even that. Sorry.

Well, I believe Wally West should be a Top Tier. He has the showings to back that up in my opinion.

I would have thought Beta Ray Bill, Captain Marvel, Orion and others would have qualified for that position. Clearly they don't have the number of feats such as Superman or Thor, but I would have thought the ones they did, supported that.

srug

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
They can compete with the high guys in a fight to a certain extent, but they lack their multitude of high end feats. Something that would only come from having your own series for a long time.

I would only back Wally and/or Barry.

Understood.

Originally posted by Raoul
I could back Wally and maybe Orion, but bar that, not sure.

So, how many votes do you need for, to make the change? I can think of a few people who would back it up.....

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Understood.

So, how many votes do you need for, to make the change? I can think of a few people who would back it up.....

just a decent majority after a certain period of time, i think...

So is that:

Wally to High:

For: Me, Kris, Rage

Against: Digi

?

That would be it so far.

I'm for Wally

Originally posted by Bad Ash231
Why is that?

Anyhow, Stryfe for Low Herald.

Respect thread can be found here.
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f98/t483653.html

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
The Flash (Wally West), Beta Ray Bill, Gladiator, Captain Marvel, Black Adam, Orion should all be High Herald level in my opinion.

so against all of them

Against all except BA