what about kurse? should be mid-herald with that type of weakness. seriously, is he really a bigger threat than juggernaut?
i'm for taking strange visitor OFF the list.
i'm undecided on HE. he has . . . weird showings. i guess i could really see him as either. strong cases could be made BOTH ways. if we go historically, he's likely trans. more recent says prolly high herald. so . . . dontgetit
Originally posted by Enyalus
I'll look.EDIT: Okay, well, here's one of their fights...
To me it looks like Thor has an advantage until he drops his guard over concern for the citizens.
Do you remember if they fought during the Black Galaxy Saga? I don't have it on my computer for scannage and stuffs.
nah, pretty sure they didn't fight at all in that arc. HE was too busy having a hard-on for the celestials to want to fight thor. 😄
Originally posted by leonidas
what about kurse? should be mid-herald with that type of weakness. seriously, is he really a bigger threat than juggernaut?
I think Kurse is fine where he is. Alan Scott's weakness is freakin' wood, and he's high herald.
Originally posted by Enyalus
Thor has bitched Juggernaut. Kurse has bitched Thor.I think Kurse is fine where he is. Alan Scott's weakness is freakin' wood, and he's high herald.
yeah, i think THAT should be considered as well. seriously--wood?? that's pretty rare and hard to come by . . . 😐
meh. i don't think any 1-dimensional being like kurse (can't even friggin FLY!) should ever be HH. he gets utterly pwn'd by most in that tier via simple matter manip or 10/10 bfr (too 1-dimensional to counter). hell, he shouldn't even be able to HIT most in that tier in a forum setting.
Originally posted by EnyalusHm that looks like a win for H.E not Thor. Thor did drop his guard but so did H.E the deference was that H.E was able to one shot him. Also Thor was facing right at him that better than getting attack from behind like what Thor did.
I'll look.EDIT: Okay, well, here's one of their fights...
To me it looks like Thor has an advantage until he drops his guard over concern for the citizens.
Do you remember if they fought during the Black Galaxy Saga? I don't have it on my computer for scannage and stuffs.
either way I don't see how this is an "easy win for Thor" like you said before
Originally posted by kgkg
Hm that looks like a win for H.E not Thor. Thor did drop his guard but so did H.E the deference was that H.E was able to one shot him. Also Thor was facing right at him that better than getting attack from behind like what Thor did.
I think I had another fight in mind when I said 'easy win', but I can't find it, so I'll bite the bullet on this one.
Originally posted by leonidas
yeah, i think THAT should be considered as well. seriously--wood?? that's pretty rare and hard to come by . . . 😐meh. i don't think any 1-dimensional being like kurse (can't even friggin FLY!) should ever be HH. he gets utterly pwn'd by most in that tier via simple matter manip or 10/10 bfr (too 1-dimensional to counter). hell, he shouldn't even be able to HIT most in that tier in a forum setting.
To be fair, Alan's versatility with the ring allows him to overcome his wood weakness more so than Kurse's strengths allow him to overcome his lack of mobility. Which is to say, he can't overcome it in many situations, whereas Alan can by being quick and/or creative.
That said, only Sentinel is up for a vote, and he doesn't have a wood weakness. Don't want the two confused.
I stand with Mr. Terrific here:
http://img214.imageshack.us/img214/7364/alan17potentiallyqz2.jpg
Against. He has the Starheart. Its composed of all wild magic of the universe. The man wrote the book on willpower, let him be.
Originally posted by Blair Wind
I stand with Mr. Terrific here:
http://img214.imageshack.us/img214/7364/alan17potentiallyqz2.jpg
Your late I already posted that....geez
Oh and I suggest the Master of the World should have his own category.
