Originally posted by Quiero Mota
Whether Hinduism truly is a monotheistic religion "in disguise" or a pagan one has been a subject of debate. Last week while on my lunch break, I was killing time at Hastings and I came across a world religion book that said that the idea that Hinduism is actually monotheistic and all their countless gods are all actually one, isn't a very old notion. It said that Hindus made it up to appeal to Mulsim invaders who killed anyone that worshipped more than one god.Are India's 150 million Muslims second-class citizens?
not really, the fact of a tracendental brahma which has no images and no likeness in the world is present in the vedas, you dont get any more authentic then that in hinduism. as for the second part, it depends. if you go to dehli and are a liberal muslim and dont live in any specific communal area then you probably will not be socially discriminated{although discrimination is still present in public systems}, but if you are a practicing muslim and dont live in a booming metropolis or even live in a slighltly shadier place you will definately be discriminated against, and if you are living in normal city/slums/suburb/villages{villages being where the majority of people live} then you willl be SEVERELY discriminated against. muslim children are discriminated against in school by faculty and grading etc{yes it might be hard to beleive but it is a fact} and even most people in the government sector, {i.e. qualified workers} are discriminated against in the work setting on acheivements etc, upto a point that even if you are a muslim in the indian embassy, you are discriminated against. the places where you really arentdiscriminated against are circles of super liberal people., hindu or otherwise in the fancier parts of developed cities like mumbai or if you are a muslim who is well recognised{i.e. movie stars etc, although it can be questioned whethere they even qualify for practicing muslims}.
so yea, in general india's 150 millions muslims are second class citizens, but thing are changing, non uniformly{geographically and chronologically} . its kind of the same as caste based prejudice is spread and changin in india, its still there in the majority, but in specific issues, and in specific places and points in time., it is much lesser or almost disappears.
anyhow, POINT being, india is a ****ed up country, and dont let overly glamorous media propaganda make you think otherwise.