Originally posted by Dinalfos
This list will not include manga adaptations.1: Spiderman 2
2: Hulk
3: A History of Violence
4: V For Vendetta
5: Spiderman
6: Hell boy
7: X2
8: X-Men
9: Ghost World (Didn't say superhero movie, did you?)
10: Daredevil DCRunners up (no particular order): Batman Begins, 300, The Punisher 2005, X-men: TLS, Fantastic Four (Street), From Hell, Sin city.
Worst (I don't even want to order them):
Superman IV
Superman III
Electra
Cat Woman
Generation X
Shield
Super Girl
Superman the movie
Superman II
Batman Forever
Batman
Batman Returns
Captain America
Ghostrider
Spiderman 3
Fantastic Four (Corman)
My list is similiar to Dinalfos's.a lot of them havent even been mentioned I notice as either bad or good.
Best.
1.Superman 1 & 2.
2.Batman Begins
3.Dick Tracy
4.Conan The Barbarian
5.Road To perdition
6.Daredevil directors cut.
worst.
1.spider-man movies- obviously from my sig. 😄
2.Catwoman
3.Supergirl
4.Batman Returns
5.Batman and Robin.
rounding out in the horrible movies list but in no particular order are
Superman 3
Superman 4 quest for peace.
Superman Returns.
Batman 89
Batman Forever
steel
captain america
sheena
red sonja.
Fantastic Four
The Hulk.
Conan The destroyer.
Movies i list in the middle of the road as in not horrible but not great either-just so so, are
sin city
V for vendetta
300
The Punisher
Elektra
Hellboy
I don't like DC movies in general, actually, with Batman Begins as exception. That movie just kicked ass.
However, the only reason The Fantastic Four got in my top five was because of Jessica Alba. JESSICA ALBA ! 🙄
Top 5:
1. X-Men 2
2. Batman Begins
3. Spiderman 2
4. the 300
5. The Fantastic Four
Bottom 5:
1. Hulk
2. Batman Forever
3. Batman Returns
4. Batman (first one)
5. Superman Returns
Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
Bottom:X-Men/2/3 (Pick one).
Thats a first for me someone disliking all 3 X-men films i would've thought mostly the 3rd one since thats more hated on the internet
Suppose i better do the list
Top 5
1- The Dark Knight
2- Iron Man
3- The Incredible Hulk
4- Hellboy
5- Sin City
Bottom 5
1- Elektra
2- Batman and Robin
3- The Punisher (1989)
4- Superman 4
5- Batman (1966)
Top
1) The Dark Knight (easily, for so many reasons there is no need to elaborate on them)
2) V for Vendetta (another 'comic book' movie that did not even feel like one ....it was a great movie that just happened to be based on a comic)
3) Spiderman 1 (the reason why any great comic book movie in the future will be great ....inspiration from the first Spiderman movie, which broke the mould when it comes to how such movies are made)
4) Iron Man (very good vision, and it almost ...almost ....made the level where it stops being a great 'comic book' movie, and turn into a great movie that just happens to be based on comic books. However, it almost got there ....meaning it did not get there. It is, still, a great comic book movie)
5) Batman Begins (a seminal work, which only pales when compared to The Dark Knight. However, taken on its own it is a great movie, and more importantly in brought new life to the Batman movie genre, which had been turned by prior directors into a JOKE. No longer was Batman 'funny,' no longer did he have nipples, and no longer were his villains punks on skates. Batman was finally how he should have always been, and this movie brought about the fresh genesis).
I wanted to put 300 on the list ....REALLY wanted to, but to be honest with you I could not. It was a GREAT movie, and the action was perfect, but if you really think of it it was a direct version of the comic. It was not even an intepretation ....the comic was basically the still for the movie. Direct photocopy.
There is nothing wrong with that, and the movie was great (again ...it was great), but as a cinematic experience (and when compared to movies like the Dark Knight), it was like Chinese food ....very tasty, but not filling.
It was very linear, with no obtuse angles, and more of a movie that will pump you up.
Great movie, but to be honest it wasn't a V for Vendetta or a Dark Knight (both of which, even if largely based on comics ....V for Vendetta was quite close to the literary version ....were still INTEPRETATIONS and not moving photocopies of the comic).
But if there was a no. 6, that film would have been 300.
No need for the worst (although there are a number ....although I have to mention X-men 3 ....what they HECK were they smoking! While there are worse movies, I cannot believe how they mucked up a movie that should have been hard to muck up. You need to be gifted to muck things up that much!)