Darth Sion vs Darth Vader

Both of them are at full power. Battle is at Geonosis arena. Who wins?
Vader is the OT vader.

1.Lightsabers only
2.Force only
3.All out

it all depends on if Vader can break his will, although I'm not sure Sion's skill is up to par.

sion all the way, even without his uber ability, and i doubt vader would break his will, hes got no mental advantage over sion

Yeah, i don't think sion would be intimidated with vader at all so...

Originally posted by IOU
sion all the way, even without his uber ability, and i doubt vader would break his will, hes got no mental advantage over sion

So you think Sion can win even without his "uber ability". I think you don't need to kill Sion to beat him if Vader could cut off Sion's limbs like his hands than he can win the first one. In force powers I would give the edge to Sion due to his ability. In all out fight if Vader could do what I said in a lightsaber duel then he has a good chance but it wont be easy. Without his ability Sion would loose all three.

there's no point in putting Sion in any battle setting, cause his fanboys just say, "oh he's immortal, no one can beat him," and anytime you try to say that someone can break his will, they deny it. So whats the point? Vader's better in every aspect, Sion just keeps coming back...it would get old quick.

FROM HERE ON SION CAN DIE

Any strong force user can just cut sion with a saber then use the force to seperate the dismembered body part. For example, his head

Originally posted by Manslayer
Any strong force user can just cut sion with a saber then use the force to seperate the dismembered body part. For example, his head

Sion can keep his body intact through sheer hatred and power of the Dark Side of the Force. His body does not disintegrates unless he willingly gives up.

Exile actually had to convince Sion to gve up his hatred and anger. There was no other way to defeat him.

EDIT:

Here is a hint: Darth Vader (OT) knows the art of Dun Moch.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
there's no point in putting Sion in any battle setting, cause his fanboys just say, "oh he's immortal, no one can beat him," and anytime you try to say that someone can break his will, they deny it. So whats the point? Vader's better in every aspect, Sion just keeps coming back...it would get old quick.

And you were right

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
The problem is that this is not so easy as it sounds.

Sion can keep his body intact through sheer hatred and power of the Dark Side of the Force. His body does not disintegrates unless he willingly gives up.

Exile actually had to convince Sion to gve up his hatred and anger. There was no other way to defeat him.

EDIT:

Here is a hint: Darth Vader (OT) knows the art of Dun Moch.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
The problem is that this is not so easy as it sounds.

Sion can keep his body intact through sheer hatred and power of the Dark Side of the Force. His body does not disintegrates unless he willingly gives up.

Exile actually had to convince Sion to gve up his hatred and anger. There was no other way to defeat him.

EDIT:

Here is a hint: Darth Vader (OT) knows the art of Dun Moch.

Note that there is no proof what so ever that Sion is good with a lightsaber.Vader will at the very least defeat him. Vader>>Sion with a saber combat and what other force powers does he have beside the ridiculous ability to survive. As moonslayer said you cut off his head or hands it will do him no good in being alive since he will not be able to fightback.

And then what, he stays there for his entire life holding Sions body apart with the Force. Don't get me wrong, Vaders Force mastery is way above Sions as are his skills with a saber, but if he cant be killed in normal combat, he will just wait that Vader becomes tired and then finish him of. And the Exile also defeated him in a saber match numerous times and he always came back. Like Nobaris said in one post, he want always give up his life in every scenario, it all depends if Vader knows about Sions history and how much, if he knows that Traya is his weakness, he could convince him to do it, the Sith from ions time operated from shadows, they didn't fought a Galaxy scale war like Revan and Malak, so for the Universe they weren't that important, especially because the Jedi, Don't share everything with public, but then again Vader had access to countless Sith and Jedi Holocrans stored in the Jedi temple, like i said it all depends, of how much Vader knows about Sion.

Wait sion can regenerate his body part's or use the force to bring himself together? Or am I misinterpreting what you said?

Well he did it with the Exile, she striked him down numerous times in their duel and he always came back and the fight was a saber duel, so she had to cut something off. And the doctor on the harbinger said that Sions body was fractured and then pulled back together, thats what his immortality do, he pules himself back to one piece. Unless i am wrong.

Couldn't she have simply stabbed him, I really wish it could be more specific on these things.(kotor books please!) As far as the doctor part I will replay the begining later.But it is pretty that without the power vader would though. Is there any guide that has more information on Sion?

Not that i know and yes, without immortality Vader would own Sion, thats all he has.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
The problem is that this is not so easy as it sounds.

Sion can keep his body intact through sheer hatred and power of the Dark Side of the Force. His body does not disintegrates unless he willingly gives up.

Exile actually had to convince Sion to gve up his hatred and anger. There was no other way to defeat him.

EDIT:

Here is a hint: Darth Vader (OT) knows the art of Dun Moch.

Yes, I agree. Without his inmortality, Sion has nothing against Vader. He has not proven anything special with the saber, or at least nothing compared to Vaders feats.

Sions ability only works on places with dark side nexus' he said that with korriban running through him he was immortal, on a place like geonosis that won't work. Anyways even with it Vader would crush him like a messed up looking bug

Originally posted by ESB -1138
And you were right

I am not a Sion fanboy.