Originally posted by Darth Hord
Revan as far as we know had no prior hand to hand fights or experience. and I'm pretty Maul has practice martial arts/unarmed combat. So he would at the very least give her a better that Revan would. Plus he is probably physically stronger than the Handmaiden. I think I'm gonna go with Maul.
In the TNEC, it is stated that Revan defeated Mandalore - The Ultimate in a hand to hand combat.
Now imagine that how strong Revan was.
Originally posted by mattatom
because hand to hand she can 0wn Reven
Do not forget that Revan also have killed some notable Echani warriors.
Yusanis (The most powerful and skilled Echani warrior ever known) also got his @ss handed to him by Revan in a single combat and was killed by him.
Although Handmaiden is a skilled warrior, but even she cannot defeat Revan. The reason is clear from the above points.
In the TNEC, it is stated that Revan defeated Mandalore - The Ultimate in a hand to hand combat.
I thought it was described as single combat not hand to hand?
Although Handmaiden is a skilled warrior, but even she cannot defeat Revan. The reason is clear from the above points.
That is great and all for Revan(even if he is my fav. character) but it does not pertain to the actual thread which is Handmaiden vs Maul.
Originally posted by Darth Hord
I thought it was described as single combat not hand to hand combat?
Originally posted by Darth Hord
That is great and all for Revan(even if he is my fav. character) but it does not pertain to the actual thread which is Handmaiden vs Maul.
Re: Handmaiden Vs Darth Maul
Originally posted by mattatom
In a different matter what actually happened to Handmaiden after KOTORII
She didn't canonically travel with the exile. She only travels with you if the exile is a male. If you play as female which is the canon gender than Mical joins your party instead. Nothing is really known what she did.
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
How?Revan has proven to be a very tough guy by beating a Mandalore in a hand to hand combat. Now unless Maul can match this kind of feat, I will not be convinced.
I'm not here to convince you. You have Revan so far up your ass it's literally ruined your vision. Obi-Wan Kenobi nearly defeated Jango Fett and went toe-to-toe with Anakin Skywalker in melee. It's arguable that he is above Revan.
Originally posted by Gideon
I'm not here to convince you. You have Revan so far up your ass it's literally ruined your vision.
And wish you good luck in trying to counter what is stated in the TNEC.
Originally posted by Gideon
Obi-Wan Kenobi nearly defeated Jango Fett and went toe-to-toe with Anakin Skywalker in melee. It's arguable that he is above Revan.
Against Jango Fett, Obi-Wan did fought well but he still failed to subdue him. Revan however fought against and subdued Mandalore: The Ultimate in the end. So there is some difference in these two cases.
In the case of Vader, Obi-Wan knew him very well. This fact helped him a lot in the fight and Vader was also emotionally disturbed.
So you cannot declare that Obi-Wan is better then Revan or even in his league.
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenDHe can since he was described as pushing his body and fighting skills to the limit. We see in the movies and comics that his agility is far greater than revans
How?Revan has proven to be a very tough guy by beating a Mandalore in a hand to hand combat. Now unless Maul can match this kind of feat, I will not be convinced.
Originally posted by Manslayer
He can since he was described as pushing his body and fighting skills to the limit.
Originally posted by Manslayer
We see in the movies and comics that his agility is far greater than revans
Revan gave a massive @ss beating to huge number of Sith and Droids on the Star Forge. This feat alone puts him above Maul.
I do not have Revan so far up my @ss that it would ruin my vision. I give him recognition where it is needed.
Keep telling yourself that. You might end up convincing yourself, but as for the rest of us: we're not fooled. Revan is a piss-ant of a character. A powerful Sith? Oh, most assuredly, but a weak character nonetheless.
I don't know which is worse: Revan fanboys or Ancient Sith fanboys. At least the Ancient Sith had defined characters.
And wish you good luck in trying to counter what is stated in the TNEC.
Oh, tNEC says that Revan is superior to Maul? Statement and page number, please.
No it is not.
Yes, it is.
Against Jango Fett, Obi-Wan did fought well but he still failed to subdue him. Revan however fought against and subdued Mandalore: The Ultimate in the end. So there is some difference in these two cases.
Jango only subdued Obi-Wan thanks to quick-thinking and - even more importantly - technology and equipment vastly superior to anything in Revan's time.
Hell, he couldn't even kill Obi-Wan with his damn ship.
In the case of Vader, Obi-Wan knew him very well. This fact helped him a lot in the fight and Vader was also emotionally disturbed.
That's great.
But that isn't going to help you in a melee fight, where Anakin didn't care so much for technique as opposed to downright frightening physical strength and power. Obi-Wan "knowing" Anakin meant shit.
So you cannot declare that Obi-Wan is better then Revan or even in his league.
In melee combat? I think I pretty much did.
Others can push their bodies and fighting skills to the limit as well.
You have some crappy reasoning skills. Maul is confirmed to have pushed his physical and Force-assisted abilities to the "utmost" to the point that he could never improve in that area, on Sidious's training regimen, which is outrageous to begin with.
Prove Revan equals that.
Revan gave a massive @ss beating to huge number of Sith and Droids on the Star Forge. This feat alone puts him above Maul.
...He did all of this without the Force or his lightsaber? I really do need to play KotoR again.
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenDDid revan? Nope Is revan good in h2h? Of course
Others can push their bodies and fighting skills to the limit as well.
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenDLightsaber and totally irrelevant as i was argueing hand to hand combat
Revan gave a massive @ss beating to huge number of Sith and Droids on the Star Forge. This feat alone puts him above Maul.