Maul vs. Handmaiden: Maul wins because we really don't know anything canon about Handmaiden, seeing as the female path is the canon one.
Now, on to the whole "Revan vs. Maul or Obi-Wan" thing. It's already been argued to death, but I just feel like repeating a few things myself. The simple fact of the matter is that we don't know much about Revan's hand-to-hand abilities. I'm not saying that he wasn't a decent saber duelist, or that he wasn't powerful in the Force (This is for a certain someone who seems to get "Revan sucks like nobody's business" whenever someone says that he isn't the greatest thing since sliced bread).
The only thing we have regarding Revan's hand-to-hand abilities is a vague statement in TNEC saying that he defeated Mandalore the Ultimate in said combat. However, it doesn't go into any detail, IIRC. There's no mention of how difficult it was, no mention of how the fight was actually won, and it doesn't exclude the possibility that Revan used the Force. Unfortunately, that alone isn't enough to put him above Obi-Wan or Maul. Obi-Wan fought someone who was very skilled (Jango Fett), and who had technology far above the level available to Mandalore the Ultimate (And that's a simple fact. Technology, from a blaster to a warship, vastly improved from KOTOR to AotC). He also went head to head with Anakin, who was insanely strong in terms of raw physical strength. Maul is also depicted as inhumanly powerful in physical ability, seeing as he was pushed so far in Sidious' ridiculously strenuous training that there was literally no possible way for him to improve any more. When fighting against two very physically able Jedi on Naboo, he displayed very above-average levels of agility and speed, even while wielding the double-bladed saber...Which, to put it bluntly, is rather clunky and unwieldy (Exar Kun's version was fine, but the hilt was much smaller than the more modern versions).
Frankly, both of them have shown more ability in hand-to-hand combat than Revan.
Thats not sayign much considering that 90% of the Sith are weaker then the average PT padawan
Actually, it still kind of does say a lot. If he's the "greatest martial arts weapon the Sith ever had", then that applies to all Sith, from the weakest of the bunch to Dark Empire Sidious. Even if 90% of the Sith are that weak, the statement still applies to the 10% that are above most of the PT Masters.
Originally posted by BlaxicanHydra
Thats not sayign much considering that 90% of the Sith are weaker then the average PT padawan 😐
Erm...what? You think Ragnos, Sadow, Nadd, Exar, Ulic, Revan, Malak, Bane, Traya, Sion, Nihilus, Simus, Hord, Lumiya, Vader, Dooku, ect would lose to an average PT Jedi? Most PT Jedi Masters weren't as skilled as Obi-wan was as in his last days as an apprentice. Obi-wan isn't representive of the majority.
Originally posted by BlaxicanHydra
Thats not sayign much considering that 90% of the Sith are weaker then the average PT padawan 😐
Than tell me why and how than? We know Maul is the greatest weapon the Sith have ever had. What powers and/or abilities does this handmaiden have in which she is capable of beating The Sith's greatest weapon.
Erm...what? You think Ragnos, Sadow, Nadd, Exar, Ulic, Revan, Malak, Bane, Traya, Sion, Nihilus, Simus, Hord, Lumiya, Vader, Dooku, ect would lose to an average PT Jedi? Most PT Jedi Masters weren't as skilled as Obi-wan was as in his last days as an apprentice. Obi-wan isn't representive of the majority.
He may have been talking about Dark Side users in general, I suppose. I think that they're similar to the Jedi in that regard. There are plenty of highly skilled people in their ranks, and several truly exceptional people, but a large portion of the regular Dark Side flunkies (The regular Dark Jedi encountered in KOTOR, for instance) are probably on or below the level of a lot of the unexceptional PT Jedi.
But that depends on whether he was talking about DS users in general, or the actual Sith Lords.
Side note, VinCon: Revan defeated Mandalore in melee combat as well as Yusanis, the echani duelling champion. Considering that Revan is thought to have Battle Precognition (And yes, I am making conjecture here, not gospel) and he can defeat these champions is no small feat in melee. Echani trained mercenaries have been known to outfight jedi (See Medstar duology), and Yusanis being the prime example of echani duelling capability should say alot (Hell, he even uses a double-bladed weapon- Yusanis' duelling foil). Obviously the game designers wanted us to know that Revan in melee combat is at least in the top tier, if not the best of his era. Couple that with the fact that he beat Malak at a severe disadvantage (Canon LS ending means that Revan couldn't Force drain the bodies while Malak could) and we have even more to give to him.
But I'm getting way off track...
Final verdict? Maul beats the ever-loving shit out of this little girl. True, she's echani and yes, she's pretty good. But Maul is the more experienced duellist, and he has a very good handle on lightsaber combat (Being an advanced Juyo practitioner).