Originally posted by EvilAngel
What do you mean it's silly? I'm just reminding you of the word origin. It is made from those two words, the word means "Not one". I don't understand why that is silly."None of them work"
Is the same as
"Not one of them work"As i said before, you can't say
"One of them work, one of them don't"
It doesn't make sense and is wrong.
"One of them works, one of them doesn't"
Is correct.
The language has rules, they are just infinitely more complex than other languages.
I don't grasp the relevence for the alternate meanings of the word. In a sentence when the word none means "Not One" there is only one way to use it. I never mentioned the other definitions. Let's use them in our example just incase that is what you meant
"Not any of them works"
"Nothing works"
so it's
"None of them works"
Understand?
...it's "not any of them work". Not works.
I mean would you say "Do any of them works?", no, you wouldn't.
Neither are the rules of English that complex compared to other language really.
Either way, I don't feel like bothering much more, the fact is that both is perfectly fine to say and grammatically correct.