Captain America vs. Ultimate Captain America

Started by peregrinefalcon4 pages

Captain America vs. Ultimate Captain America

I think that Ultimate Captain America is stronger. He made the Hulk bleed. He's definitely 40 pounds heavier than the original version. Of course, as we all know, strength isn't everything. Original version certainly keeps his cool better. Your opinions?

i dont know a damn thing about any ultimate character. and frankly ill always root for the original becuz i hate remakes in movies and now they are reamiking comic book characters. has the world ran out of new fun ideas? i back the original whether or not he wins this.

Originally posted by peregrinefalcon
I think that Ultimate Captain America is stronger. He made the Hulk bleed. He's definitely 40 pounds heavier than the original version. Of course, as we all know, strength isn't everything. Original version certainly keeps his cool better. Your opinions?

616 cap is more skilled. 616 cap FTW.

Re: Captain America vs. Ultimate Captain America

Originally posted by peregrinefalcon
I think that Ultimate Captain America is stronger. He made the Hulk bleed. He's definitely 40 pounds heavier than the original version. Of course, as we all know, strength isn't everything. Original version certainly keeps his cool better. Your opinions?

616 Steve FTW

Originally posted by quanchi112
i dont know a damn thing about any ultimate character. and frankly ill always root for the original becuz i hate remakes in movies and now they are reamiking comic book characters. has the world ran out of new fun ideas? i back the original whether or not he wins this.
He is actually an awesome remake. 🙄

Its been done 616 Cap wins.

616 Cap wins. Faster, more skilled, insane shield skills.

Agreed.

616 Cap. He has better speedfeats and is generally portrayed more skilled, ignoring the fact that Ultimate Cap defeated Hulk H2H...

And 616 Caps shield would also mean a lot for his victory in this match.

616 Cap is more skilled and experienced

Ultimate Cap seems far more ruthless and aggressive.

I give 616 the edge because in a fight, his cool head and experience would allow him to exploit Ultimate's mistakes better.

But Ultimate cap uses guns!

Originally posted by JudgeXZXZ
ignoring the fact that Ultimate Cap defeated Hulk H2H...

Thats a myth he did not defeat him.

Bump.

Using guns is something special against 616 Cap? He has used guns as well in the past.

I dont think Ult Cap has had enough of a chance to show his H2H skills for that to be a factor. Hes beaten the crap out of a large number of folks while drugged and hung in against the Hulk for a bit, which I think says something. Also has anyone yet been able to get the better of him in H2H? 616 Cap has had like 40+ years of showings to draw on while Ult Cap has been a bit more limited for source material. On the other hand Ult Cap has been shown to be stronger and a lot more likely to cheat to win.
616 Cap = Peak Human, Ultimate Cap = meta human.
Im giving this one to the ultimate version.

I don't see how Ultimate Cap being metahuman can make him surpass the Cap who has several good showings against several metahumans.

If it were left at just physical prowess I'd agree, but Ult Cap hasnt been whooping on your standard street levelers either.

616 Cap has the edge on characters that are similar to U.Cap.

USAgent is was trained in military and is even stronger then U.Cap. And 616 Cap makes him look like a joke now a days.

Cap has had the upperhand on other similar characters like Protocide, the Anti Cap.

Plus 616 Cap has looked good also against Korvac, Thunderball, Wrecker, the 616 Hulk(who's superior to U.Hulk), Fenris, Giantman. Etc etc. Some of these have circumstances but so did U.Cap's fight with U.Hulk.

616 Cap just seems to have all the cards IMO. Even has strength feats that match U.Cap, despite U.Cap being ment to be stronger by the handbooks.

Originally posted by Daredevil1
616 Cap has the edge on characters that are similar to U.Cap.

USAgent is was trained in military and is even stronger then U.Cap. And 616 Cap makes him look like a joke now a days.

Cap has had the upperhand on other similar characters like Protocide, the Anti Cap.

Plus 616 Cap has looked good also against Korvac, Thunderball, Wrecker, the 616 Hulk(who's superior to U.Hulk), Fenris, Giantman. Etc etc. Some of these have circumstances but so did U.Cap's fight with U.Hulk.

616 Cap just seems to have all the cards IMO. Even has strength feats that match U.Cap, despite U.Cap being ment to be stronger by the handbooks.

Bullcrap that USAgent is stronger then Ult. Cap. The guy has braced against trees, gone toe-to-toe with Ult. Hulk, lept several stories out of jets and survived a double-fist pounding by Ult. Abomination. Ult. Cap is so underrated on these forums that it makes me sick sometimes.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Bullcrap that USAgent is stronger then Ult. Cap. The guy has braced against trees,

Why couldnt US Agent do that?

Originally posted by OneDumbG0

gone toe-to-toe with Ult. Hulk,

After dropping a tank on him and it could be argued that Ult Hulk is weaker than Savage Hulk, since I dont think dropping a tank on him would really do anything.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0

lept several stories out of jets

...what exactly do you mean? Hasnt 616 Cap done similar stuff out of a helicopter?

Originally posted by OneDumbG0

and survived a double-fist pounding by Ult. Abomination. Ult. Cap is so underrated on these forums that it makes me sick sometimes.

Well since Ult Hulk might be weaker we could say the same possibly for Ult Abom.