Motherbox + Apokalips Tech Superman V Silver Surfer

Started by darthgoober20 pages

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Waverider had nothing to do with it besides coming back with Supes. The motherbox adapted and took the neccesary action for victory.

Juntai already informed me. Like I said it's been a while since I read the arc.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
It's called a beatdown. Like what he would get by this threads rules. BP certainly remembered that it could be done. Because it doesn't vibe with you..it doesn't make it PIS. A lowly doombot is hardly a good example anyway.

I meant the guys at Marvel forgetting. It's kinda like the scan of SBP being immune to red sunlight proving his later weakening by red sunlight to be BS.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Those weren't similar situations. You're completely ignoring the fact that Superman's will is superimposing on Surfers powers and the fact that in your scans nothing was trying to prevent SS from coming or going and that he wasn't in battle. The fact that T-vo isn't just an astral plane but a reality warp also kills that whole argument.

Once again...SS is going nowhere...and you haven't shown any tangible way for SS to get out of T-vo.


Except that Sufer has a good track record against reality warpers as well. I'll have to PM Roldz for the scans though, as those are some of the few I don't have.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Yes a Motherbox CAN do that, but a GL ring CAN do the same thing. So in a no PIS environment if you're going to ASSUME that the Motherbox does all that despite the on panel evidence to the contrary, then it seems you'd do the same for a GL. I'm just wanting to get your stance on the issue before another Guy Gardener vs Superman thread is made, since it should really affect the odds.
The rings intelligence is not the same as Motherbox's intelligence. And it doesn't help the user in the same way, and doesn't require anything of the user to operate it.

these days the intelligence of the ring is back, but thus far, I've only seen it do specifically what is asked of it. It's not ACTIVELY working with the user to find a solution a given problem, that's up the Lantern.

They're diffent items in every sense of the word. Don't try to relate them. The simple fact is, the Motherbox works independantly, and can think, communicate, and act in cooperation with it's wielder. And it's viable in this thread.

I don't see the point of comparing the motherbox to a GL ring.

Originally posted by Juntai
The rings intelligence is not the same as Motherbox's intelligence. And it doesn't help the user in the same way, and doesn't require anything of the user to operate it.

these days the intelligence of the ring is back, but thus far, I've only seen it do specifically what is asked of it. It's not ACTIVELY working with the user to find a solution a given problem, that's up the Lantern.

They're diffent items in every sense of the word. Don't try to relate them. The simple fact is, the Motherbox works independantly, and can think, communicate, and act in cooperation with it's wielder. And it's viable in this thread.


And I have only seen Supes use the Motherbox in a few very specific ways, that's why I'm not going to credit him with the full range of Motherbox feats since it would mean that DD is an abstract level threat. After all, if Supes had the FULL range of Motherbox abilities when they fought then he would have been able to rewrite the Universe without DD in it unless DD was above that kind of thing(which would put him at abstract level in my mind).

Originally posted by darthgoober
And I have only seen Supes use the Motherbox in a few very specific ways, that's why I'm not going to credit him with the full range of Motherbox feats since it would mean that DD is an abstract level threat. After all, if Supes had the FULL range of Motherbox abilities when they fought then he would have been able to rewrite the Universe without DD in it unless DD was above that kind of thing(which would put him at abstract level in my mind).
You mean the Genesis box?
I wasn't considering Supes having that in this thread.

Originally posted by Superboy Prime
I don't see the point of comparing the motherbox to a GL ring.
Pretty much what I've been saying, but let him reach, it's funny.

Originally posted by Juntai
You mean the Genesis box?
I wasn't considering Supes having that in this thread.

Damn, you beat me to it. 😮

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Damn, you beat me to it. 😮
I got quick fingers.
😄

Originally posted by Juntai
Pretty much what I've been saying, but let him reach, it's funny.

Yes, yes it is....

🙂

Originally posted by leonidas
😕

the midnight sun battle shows little. he was a martial artist who tagged ss loads of times. the hulk swinging and missing? meh. third scan has always amused me -- he's talking to himself saying he has only a nano-second. 😂 but that's more thought processing speed. i used that scan in a tournament. 🙂 i have no idea how the morg battle translates to combat-speed. nor the ravenous battle. nor the lunatic battle. i guess he moved out of the way of wonderman, who is hardly a speedster . . . the skrull one is all right i suppose -- i mean he dodged and attacked but it was hardly spidey/supermanesque . . . vs thor (where he was amped by loki) and the abomination i don't see any way at all that they support your cause. the legacy example (which i'd forgotten) is prolly your best one, but you missed the single best example of his speed in a battle. 😬

And yet, Surfer evaded him, and knocked him out.

The Hulk was like a foot away from Surfer, and if we judge by art, his fist should have went through Surfer.

He has to react as well as think... 😉

In the Morg one, he was far away, using superspeed, punched him using speed, and then rammed his board into his head.

In the Ravenous one, without his board, he hit him from the front, and then hit him from the back... 😖hifty:
How did he get behind him, other than reflexes?

Without his board, he dodged everything Lunatic threw at him...

Wonder Man is still fast, I mean, he's reacted to Gladiator's blitzes.

The problem is, you'll never see him leaping around like Spider-Man, because that's not the way he fights.
Combat speed, doesn't necessarily mean Spider-Man/Superman style.

When he fought Thor, he was also weakened by the sonic shark, before those comics, so it balances out.
Also, he hammered Thor relentlessly throughout that whole fight.
With the Abom one, he beat on him and Abom couldn't react. Although that could be attributed to fighting skills.
But maybe both of those needed the whole fight to show it?

You see, I got rid of almost all my Surfer comics, so I'm forced to use others, of his showings, or the odd one that I put in imageshack before I got rid of them.

Anyway, are you talking about when he blitzed all the ships in Annihilation?
Because if you are, I was trying to keep it to single combat.

Originally posted by leonidas
i'm thinking we aren't seeing combat-speed in the same way . . . it's irrelevent anyway because i already said i believe he could match supes speed even in close quarter battle.
Not at all, I know.
As I said, it doesn't have to be Superman, or Spider-Man like, to show reflexes, and combat speed.

Of course, but still, people like to rag on his combat speed all the time.
And, like you said, you could only think of two, so I decided to put more than that, and just equal to twice as much of the things you said that Supes has probably used T-Vo.

Originally posted by leonidas
as for the last bit of your post -- i assume that was directed at me specifically? i assume you're alluding to the fact that i switched to t-vo as a way to beat ss? i had previously rattled off several ways the MB could amp superman to the point where he would beat ss. those on the ss's side didn't buy any of it, and were clearly not about to. even if i showed scans of each ability i listed, people refuse to think he could USE those abilities. i don't care enough to try and debate page after page against a brick wall so i brought up t-vo as one more option. he wouldn't need it imo, but it was and remains a viable option.
Meh, it's just T-Vo in specific, and you happened to bring it up, and at the same time, were questioning his speed.
I fail to see him using it in battle, that much on the boards, and especially against speedy opponents. I also thought it needed time to be used...

Not trying to completely rule that out here, but from the looks of your first post, it seems that this is Superman from the H/P saga, which happened many years before he got T-Vo...

I know why you brought it up, it's just that the whole T-Vo/Surfer speed comparison thing.

Originally posted by Juntai
You mean the Genesis box?
I wasn't considering Supes having that in this thread.

I think batdude said that the Genesis Box was just a variation on the Motherbox, so given the range of the Motherbox's abilities it should be able to make that change. After all, wouldn't it be primarily a matter of reprogramming?

Anyway like I already said, this fight comes down to whether Supes is assumed to have the full range of abilities that the Motherbox has shown over the years, or if Supes is bound by what he actually accomplished when he had it(which is the standard typically endorsed on KMC). We'll just have to wait on whether or not that's a thread specification.

If it's the former then Supes wins 10/10

If it's the latter they probably split the victory 5/10

Originally posted by darthgoober
I think batdude said that the Genesis Box was just a variation on the Motherbox, so given the range of the Motherbox's abilities it should be able to make that change. After all, wouldn't it be primarily a matter of reprogramming?

Anyway like I already said, this fight comes down to whether Supes is assumed to have the full range of abilities that the Motherbox has shown over the years, or if Supes is bound by what he actually accomplished when he had it(which is the standard typically endorsed on KMC). We'll just have to wait on whether or not that's a thread specification.

If it's the former then Supes wins 10/10

If it's the latter they probably split the victory 5/10

Now we're getting somewhere.
On a random note though, what type of chances do you give a bloodlusted Superman without any specific item or powerup against Surfer?

-10/10 dur

Originally posted by darthgoober
Juntai already informed me. Like I said it's been a while since I read the arc.

We noticed. 🙂 If you remembered it correctly..all this waste of E-space could have been saved!

Originally posted by darthgoober
I meant the guys at Marvel forgetting. It's kinda like the scan of SBP being immune to red sunlight proving his later weakening by red sunlight to be BS.

Not even close to the same and considering that even his master can be drained of energy... it's even sillier. Either that was retconned or it was just never serious...after all..it was just Surfers opinion...no different than him saying "I'm invincible" and thus already proven wrong by Black Panthers action.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Except that Sufer has a good track record against reality warpers as well. I'll have to PM Roldz for the scans though, as those are some of the few I don't have.

His record against these "reality warpers" still have little or nothing to do when he is affected himself AND reality with it. T-vo is a plot device power. This is why "Superman fans" don't really bring it up in arguments...otherwise we'd be spewing ridiculous scenarious like the Surfer fans all the time. 😉

If some of the stuff that came out of SS fans keyboards was even remotely possible in battle...SS would be pwning Thanos any day of the week.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind

His record against these "reality warpers" still have little or nothing to do when he is affected himself AND reality with it. T-vo is a plot device power. This is why "Superman fans" don't really bring it up in arguments...otherwise we'd be spewing ridiculous scenarious like the Surfer fans all the time. 😉

If some of the stuff that came out of SS fans keyboards was even remotely possible in battle...SS would be pwning Thanos any day of the week.

Quoted for truth.

🙂

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
We noticed. 🙂 If you remembered it correctly..all this waste of E-space could have been saved!

Not even close to the same and considering that even his master can be drained of energy... it's even sillier. Either that was retconned or it was just never serious...after all..it was just Surfers opinion...no different than him saying "I'm invincible" and thus already proven wrong by Black Panthers action.

His record against these "reality warpers" still have little or nothing to do when he is affected himself AND reality with it. T-vo is a plot device power. This is why "Superman fans" don't really bring it up in arguments...otherwise we'd be spewing ridiculous scenarious like the Surfer fans all the time. 😉

If some of the stuff that came out of SS fans keyboards was even remotely possible in battle...SS would be pwning Thanos any day of the week.

u try very hard to downplay silver surfer but fail miserably at it. thanos would beat down superman also. hes that good but anyways back to the subject here.

do u see that superman needs a powerup to be able to legimately contend with the likes of the silver surfer. u dont see many keeper vs regular superman threads. the reason being is surfer is a heavy favorite so we must handicap it against the silver surfer. i feel the silver surfer overcomes the odds as i have read hunter and prey. superman was getting his ass kicked. without waverider he would have died. so it fails to impress me in the least.

Originally posted by quanchi112
u try very hard to downplay silver surfer but fail miserably at it. thanos would beat down superman also. hes that good but anyways back to the subject here.

You fail miserably in general. Though you being the current forum idiot has nothing to do with the subject.

Originally posted by quanchi112
do u see that superman needs a powerup to be able to legimately contend with the likes of the silver surfer. u dont see many keeper vs regular superman threads. the reason being is surfer is a heavy favorite so we must handicap it against the silver surfer. i feel the silver surfer overcomes the odds as i have read hunter and prey. superman was getting his ass kicked. without waverider he would have died. so it fails to impress me in the least.

Actually, the only thing Superman needs a powerup for is to deal with the rabid Marvel/Anime/Movie/etc fanboys always on his nuts.

HP Doomsday would whoop SS or Thanos without much of a sweat...and if you read the comic..you surely know that.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
You fail miserably in general. Though you being the current forum idiot has nothing to do with the subject.

Actually, the only thing Superman needs a powerup for is to deal with the rabid Marvel/Anime/Movie/etc fanboys always on his nuts.

HP Doomsday would whoop SS or Thanos without much of a sweat...and if you read the comic..you surely know that.

i love how ur award winning logic is saying how thanos or silver surfer would lose to doomsday. nope. it hasnt happened. i deal in facts. meaning that what has happened.

doomsday beat the hell out of ds after going through his planet. fact. superman amped up was still getting crushed and needed waverider to have a remote chance to beat him. fact. on supes own he would have died. he needed waverider. superman had the courage to fight him but he needed the mb becuz he knew he needed all the advantages he could take. so quit with ur ranting on who would lose and focus what has happened.

u are a superman fanboy it is obvious. ur biased. its cool.

Originally posted by quanchi112
i love how ur award winning logic is saying how thanos or silver surfer would lose to doomsday. nope. it hasnt happened. i deal in facts. meaning that what has happened.

Fact: Your logic is terrible. People have shown your boy Thanos get beat and I've seen sky high excuses from you ranging from funny to outright hilarious.

Originally posted by quanchi112
doomsday beat the hell out of ds after going through his planet. fact. superman amped up was still getting crushed and needed waverider to have a remote chance to beat him. fact. on supes own he would have died. he needed waverider. superman had the courage to fight him but he needed the mb becuz he knew he needed all the advantages he could take. so quit with ur ranting on who would lose and focus what has happened.

Thanos would be crushed by HP Doomsday, an amped Superman, DS, or Waverider. Take your pick.

Originally posted by quanchi112
u are a superman fanboy it is obvious. ur biased. its cool.

You do know sentences begin with capitals right? Anyway..it's obvious you are a Thanos and Marvel fanboy, and that's fine. Your lack of logic is a different story.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
[b]Fact: Your logic is terrible. People have shown your boy Thanos get beat and I've seen sky high excuses from you ranging from funny to outright hilarious.

Thanos would be crushed by HP Doomsday, an amped Superman, DS, or Waverider. Take your pick.

You do know sentences begin with capitals right? Anyway..it's obvious you are a Thanos and Marvel fanboy, and that's fine. Your lack of logic is a different story. [/B]

Just for you and just this time ok. First thing is first. Quit telling me that thanos would be crushed by doomsday,an amped superman,waverider, or darkseid. It isnt true. Thanos hangs in there with the likes of tyrant who is more powerful than all of the characters you have mentioned. Odin couldnt put the man down. Odin would laugh out loud at this motherbox wearing superman. Thanos also took thors best blows with the power gem and wasnt close to being down for the count. Again dont tell me how thanos would lose to these characters when it hasnt happened. But superman and waverider were getting there asses kicked by doomsday. That much is true. Darkseid was the given the mother of all curbstomps. Again does this ring a bell. Its from the story you keep referring to.

😉