Originally posted by Blur
That makes no sense.So what actually happens is wrong, but what some off beat writer who wrote the handbook is right?
Have you no common sense???
no, perhaps the handbooks came first, and then the novels were written based on those characters in the handbooks...isn't that srank's point?
Originally posted by Battlehammer
your completely wrong first off a great axe can not be wielded one handed.......first mistake. second sheild was missing.Those to mistakes alone prove that it a bunch of crap.
there completely sepperate. There worse then hand books and are not even close to factaul evidence.
you should know better then to use things such as hand books as reasonable evidence were they clearly cotrodict the books.
😕
...
He is a dwarf... he can wield a greataxe one handed if he wants to and it is treated as a hand axe in the D&D rules.
The information in the campaign books are nearly spot on.
Originally posted by masterbruce
battlethimble, perhaps the novels are wrong and the handbooks are correct. 😉
your an idiot.
have you ever even read a forgotten realm book?
What srank is talking about are games. D&D to be more accurate.
D&D came first, but not the characters were discussing.
The characters are from books called forgotten realms. They became popular so DND made MPC designs for them. However these designs are not accurate in the least nor did they ask the authors oppion on the matter.
Originally posted by Blur
That makes no sense.So what actually happens is wrong, but what some off beat writer who wrote the handbook is right?
Have you no common sense???
The Forgotten Realms campaign books are written by Ed Greenwood (or at least the one in question here), the guy who created the Forgotten Realms Campaign setting and has written the majority of the books that take place in it. Salvatore is just playing in Ed's sandbox.
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
😕
...He is a dwarf... he can wield a greataxe one handed if he wants to and it is treated as a hand axe in the D&D rules.
The information in the campaign books are nearly spot on.
No there not spot on there actaully extremely in accurate nor does the authors have an say in the matter.
there worse then hand books and are worthless evidence.
go off books feats not some D&D crap that means nothing it simply a game.
Originally posted by Battlehammer
your an idiot.have you ever even read a forgotten realm book?
What srank is talking about are games. D&D to be more accurate.
D&D came first, but not the characters were discussing.
The characters are from books called forgotten realms. They became popular so DND made MPC designs for them. However these designs are not accurate in the least nor did they ask the authors oppion on the matter.
1. no, I'm not an idiot.
2. yes, I've read some of the Icewind Dale books and am familiar with Wulfgur and Drizst.
3. so did Salvatore create the characters?
Originally posted by srankmissingnin
The only mistake Battlehammer can find is that Bruenor's shield was left out of his list of possessions... so... you be the judge.
Originally posted by masterbruce
1. no, I'm not an idiot.2. yes, I've read some of the Icewind Dale books and am familiar with Wulfgur and Drizst.
3. so did Salvatore create the characters?
your full of shit.............
whats the books name that you read and what happen in it?
..............is that 3rd question a real question.............
Originally posted by Battlehammer
your full of shit.............whats the books name that you read and what happen in it?
..............is that 3rd question a real question.............
1. battlethimble, please keep this discussion civil
2. I don't remember, but I think it was Servant of the Shard, the book aobut Drizzt. And I forget the book about Wulfgar's title, but I did read it.
3. yes it was a serious question. Who created these characters?
Originally posted by Battlehammer
also who forgetts what happen in books they read..........come on now masterbruce your lying is gettign out of hand jsut admitt you never read the books since you flat out proved it with your posts
you are really getting annoying. if I wanted to, I could've easily googled the plot of the books and posted it. I read those books, and I don't really care if you believe me or not. and alot of people forget what they read.
Originally posted by masterbruce
you are really getting annoying. if I wanted to, I could've easily googled the plot of the books and posted it. I read those books, and I don't really care if you believe me or not. and alot of people forget what they read.
you don't read the books your full of it.
also when we going to the battle zone? you think thing wins now so lets do it.