infinity gauntlet vs crisis on infinite earths

Started by Erik-Lensherr21 pages

No, you can't debate it.

The UN destroyed and remade the multiverse.

Oh really ? 😉

Originally posted by Avlon
He had access to all his power...he cut off his senses.

Huge difference.

this is thanos not giving the heroes a chance as he could have done. read this and know that thanos was being kind to give thor and his friends a chance.

[/IMG]

Originally posted by Galan007
Biased?

I've stated nothing but facts.

AM was > The Monitor > a punch from Supergirl.... To say otherwise is ridiculous, imo.

I'm not disregarding the instance where Supergirl punched AM, I'm simply commenting of one of the many inconsistencies of COIE.

So G who do you think would win assuming we don't include TOAA in the mix?

Originally posted by Air Legend
So G who do you think would win assuming we don't include TOAA in the mix?
Discounting TOAA/Presence/LT/Spectre.

I'd go with COIE.

Originally posted by Galan007
Discounting TOAA/Presence/LT/Spectre.

I'd go with COIE.

Actually Presence never got involved, only his wrath if you must. So discounting TOAA, and including LT and Spectre who do you think wins?

Originally posted by Erik-Lensherr
Oh really ? 😉

Well, that kinda spits in the face of the story.

Or can you explain to be how a multiversal being is stopped by a universal destruction? Or how the havoc he's reeked on all the universes is undone by destroying and remaking just one?

Yeah...fail.

Originally posted by Air Legend
Actually Presence never got involved, only his wrath if you must. So discounting TOAA, and including LT and Spectre who do you think wins?
My only problem with that is LT never got involved when Thanos had the IG.

Originally posted by Nikkolas
Well, that kinda spits in the face of the story.

Or can you explain to be how a multiversal being is stopped by a universal destruction? Or how the havoc he's reeked on all the universes is undone by destroying and remaking just one?

Yeah...fail.

I belive this is called denial .

Originally posted by Galan007
My only problem with that is LT never got involved when Thanos had the IG.

Oh...well let me go back to the previous statement.

Originally posted by Galan007
Discounting TOAA/Presence/LT/Spectre.

I'd go with COIE.

Common' G. You made a respect the IG thread. Now respect it! 313

I belive this is called denial .

I believe that is called BS.

I don't take sources that contradict the story into account.

Originally posted by Air Legend
Common' G. You made a respect the IG thread. Now respect it! 313
You're right.

And I never saw Thanos do more with the IG then overcome one Universe.

On the otherhand,

I saw AM lay waste to an infinite amount of Universes, [well all but 5 of them at least].

I don't think I'm being illogical here. 🙂

Originally posted by Priest
he didn't have access to the IG as a whole.Thanos just used the power gem to boost his own abilities, not just strength..
......
remember when Thanos was gonna fight the abstracts, he
"willed himself to full power" after he fought earths heroes.

It's on panel right there...all he cut off was sensory input.

He retained his "limitless" power.

Originally posted by Galan007
You're right.

And I never saw Thanos do more with the IG then overcome one Universe.

On the otherhand,

I saw AM lay waste to an infinite amount of Universes, [well all but 5 of them at least].

I don't think I'm being illogical here. 🙂

Well I never saw Thanos lose, why'll I saw AM get killed by a punch from Superman (I know that sounds like quanchi but that's the truth).

Now without TOAA in the mix, I don't think going with IG is being illogical either. 🙂

Originally posted by Air Legend
Well I never saw Thanos lose, why'll I saw AM get killed by a punch from Superman (I know that sounds like quanchi but that's the truth).
For one, that was AM before he absorbed the AMU..

And secondly, the punch didn't kill AM [he reformed like 2 pages after that instance].

Bringing the Supergirl punch in a serious debate is, meh.

Originally posted by Galan007
For one, that was AM before he absorbed the AMU..

And secondly, the punch didn't kill AM [he reformed like 2 pages after that instance].

Bringing the Supergirl punch in a serious debate is ridiculous.

I said Superman...

Originally posted by Air Legend
I said Superman...
I know.

I was just finishing up my point on Supergirl, because saying "Superman killed AM", without acknowledging everything else that transpired, which made AM incredibly weak before hand... Is even more ridiculous. ermm

Originally posted by Nikkolas
Well, that kinda spits in the face of the story.

Or can you explain to be how a multiversal being is stopped by a universal destruction? Or how the havoc he's reeked on all the universes is undone by destroying and remaking just one?

Yeah...fail.

If I remember correctly, it's because whatever Abraxas did in 616, mirrored itself among the realities as a sort of domino effect. Erasing Abraxas simply restored everything back.

I'd trust Mr. M to have some input on this.

Originally posted by Galan007
I know.

I was just finishing up my point on Supergirl, because saying "Superman killed AM", without acknowledging everything else that transpired, which made AM incredibly weak before hand... Is even more ridiculous. ermm

I know that AM went thorugh a lot. I read the book. The bulk of it was pretty boring. COIE is not as impressive as IG imo.

Originally posted by Galan007
You're right.

And I never saw Thanos do more with the IG then overcome one Universe.

On the otherhand,

I saw AM lay waste to an infinite amount of Universes, [well all but 5 of them at least].

I don't think I'm being illogical here. 🙂

You aren't. Especially considering that a dead Anti-monitor's corpse still had enough power rebuild the multiverse.

Originally posted by Air Legend
COIE is not as impressive as IG imo.
🙂