Scathan Vs. Thanos with the Infinity Gaunlet

Started by Rorschach6 pages

Scathan Vs. Thanos with the Infinity Gaunlet

So, I'm thinking that Scathan wins this?

Scathan never wins this

I dont see how a celestial can be stronger then eternity...

scathan wins here.

Re: Scathan Vs. Thanos with the Infinity Gaunlet

Originally posted by Rorschach
So, I'm thinking that Scathan wins this?

Scathan the Approver FTW

Marvel really confuses me sometimes,how is a aspect of eternity supposed to be stronger then eternity...

Originally posted by vlaaad12345
I dont see how a celestial can be stronger then eternity...

In GOTG, Scathan helped contain Protege. Protege was said to be the most powerful being(Earth-691). He's an ant compared to Scathan. Not Eternity, Galactus, Hawkgod, and Beyonder did anything against the godlike Protege

Originally posted by vlaaad12345
Marvel really confuses me sometimes,how is a aspect of eternity supposed to be stronger then eternity...
comics contradict each other all the time.

It isn't and Eternity was beaten by The Gauntlet if anyone cares to remember. Thanos would beat the hell out of Scathan and the rest of the Celestials. here we go again......... sigh!

Originally posted by guy222
In GOTG, Scathan helped contain Protege. Protege was said to be the most powerful being(Earth-691). He's an ant compared to Scathan. Not Eternity, Galactus, Hawkgod, and Beyonder did anything against the godlike Protege

GOTG?

Guardians Of The Galaxy

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
It isn't and Eternity was beaten by The Gauntlet if anyone cares to remember. Thanos would beat the hell out of Scathan and the rest of the Celestials. here we go again......... sigh!
scathan is around lt level and above eternity. read the guardians of the galaxy.

Originally posted by guy222
In GOTG, Scathan helped contain Protege. Protege was said to be the most powerful being(Earth-691). He's an ant compared to Scathan. Not Eternity, Galactus, Hawkgod, and Beyonder did anything against the godlike Protege
scathan is more than eternity. ur right guy he is uber uber uber.

The infinity Gauntlet is more than Eternity as well Quanchi. And how can a being that is assumed to be made by Eternity, be greater than Eternity? This would make Eternity a moron would it not? Look whatever, Thanos will beat him like he did the others in The Infinity Gauntlet, or do you believe that Scathan could defeat... here we go again.... Eternity, Chaos, Order, Mephisto, Galactus, Many Celestials, Death, Kronos, the Stranger, Epoch... etc...etc... I already know the answer, and it is NO. The Beyonder said that Scathan is "ONE of the greatest Celestials", he never said that he was the Greatest Celestial.

Thanos IG FTW 10/10 times.

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
The infinity Gauntlet is more than Eternity as well Quanchi. And how can a being that is assumed to be made by Eternity, be greater than Eternity? This would make Eternity a moron would it not? Look whatever, Thanos will beat him like he did the others in The Infinity Gauntlet, or do you believe that Scathan could defeat... here we go again.... Eternity, Chaos, Order, Mephisto, Galactus, Many Celestials, Death, Kronos, the Stranger... eyc...etc... I already know the answer, and it is NO. The Beyonder said that Scathan is "ONE of the greatest Celestials", he never said that he was the Greatest Celestial.

Thanos IG FTW 10/10 times.

the ig was neevr at lts level. scathan was. he defeated the multiversal threat like nothing.

lt and scathan>ig

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
The infinity Gauntlet is more than Eternity as well Quanchi. And how can a being that is assumed to be made by Eternity, be greater than Eternity? This would make Eternity a moron would it not? Look whatever, Thanos will beat him like he did the others in The Infinity Gauntlet, or do you believe that Scathan could defeat... here we go again.... Chaos, Order, Mephisto, Galactus, Many Celestials, Death, Kronos, the Stranger... eyc...etc... I already know the answer, and it is NO. The Beyonder said that Scathan is "ONE of the greatest Celestials", he never said that he was the Greatest Celestial.

Thanos IG FTW 10/10 times.

If Scathan operates on Living Tribunal lvl. He's above the IG

Tiamut is the greatest Celestial(Earth-616)

Originally posted by guy222
If Scathan operates on Living Tribunal lvl. He's above the IG

Tiamut is the greatest Celestial(Earth-616)

i agree and fully believe that scathan is above the ig.

Thanos with the IG would spank Scathan. Seriously, There's only 3 things greater than the IG, and Scathan isn't one of them.

here you go, the 3 things/beings more powerful than the IG is:
1. TOAA
2. THOTU
3. LT

Show me the feats not the heresay, prove to me that Scathan can beat Thanos with the Infinty Gauntlet, prove to me that he can beat the guys that Thanos put down in less than 10 pages of a comic. Show me where it states that even the Living Tribunal was greater than Thanos with the IG, because Warlock did not fight him for his own reasons, it never stated on panel that LT was greater he said that he represented forces that dwarf even Warlocks might, and asked Warlock if he wanted to pursue the destruction of reality, Warlock not being that type of character conceeded to LT because if he pursued it he would be no different thn the mad Titan that he tried to stop in the first place. Prove it all please, because Thanos in the Infinity arcs did not say anything about Scathan, as a matter of fact he took down a few Celestials. Heres a question for your logic. If you were at war with a dominant force would you send your weakest soldiers to face the enemy or your top guns? Where the hell was Scathan at? Prove it.

Originally posted by Bol Gath
Thanos with the IG would spank Scathan. Seriously, There's only 3 things greater than the IG, and Scathan isn't one of them.

here you go, the 3 things/beings more powerful than the IG is:
1. TOAA
2. THOTU
3. LT

heres how i rate things.

1thanos with the heart
2lt/scathan(dont know who is tougher really)
3ig

i dont rate TOAA becuz it isnt an actual character but symbolizes the writers themselves.