most overrated character

Originally posted by Melcórë
Uh....how is Bane overrated? I've never heard anybody say any ridiculous statements about him; the eradication of the Brotherhood of Darkness and the Army of Light wasn't luck, it was masterstroke. He also gained greater insight into the ways of the Force through his studies and his actions. Am I overrating him by saying that?

I don't think Bane, Nilhius and Revan are overated because we don't know...there are just as many people willing to say they did many things as there are dening it.

however, i don't think Bane knew everything about the force and i don't thing Revan was anything as good as someone like Vader. but it's ridiculous to say that Nilihus was a bad swordsman or that any of these were weak.

simply because i don't think your right, ...if someone talked to you and you and told me their opinion it doesn't make it right...If i said it's right it doesn't make it right...and just cus 2 people say it's right (if you remember your rights and wrongs) it doesn't make someone else wrong.

formula: right + right (not =) wrong

i'm only telling you this because on the expanded univere forum all they do is say things and have people agree with them but it's not true...i just don't get why you guys fight when there is no answer....

Originally posted by Manslayer
Well bane is powerful to be honest but what i dislike is the "bane is more powerful than the entire BOD" when the BOD are utter weaklings and people try to use that to dispute he is greater than vader, sidious and the movie stars

Alright, I see what you mean.

Still, I don't see the point in trying to compare people's ability/affinity with the Force, because I've seen far too many real-world examples of people toppled by those "weaker" than them to question the possibility that it could happen to anyone.

Originally posted by Darth Sparrow
I don't think Bane, Nilhius and Revan are overated because we don't know...there are just as many people willing to say they did many things as there are dening it.

however, i don't think Bane knew everything about the force and i don't thing Revan was anything as good as someone like Vader. but it's ridiculous to say that Nilihus was a bad swordsman or that any of these were weak.

simply because i don't think your right, ...if someone talked to you and you and told me their opinion it doesn't make it right...If i said it's right it doesn't make it right...and just cus 2 people say it's right (if you remember your rights and wrongs) it doesn't make someone else wrong.

formula: right + right (not =) wrong

i'm only telling you this because on the expanded univere forum all they do is say things and have people agree with them but it's not true...i just don't get why you guys fight when there is no answer....

Certainly Bane didn't know everything there is to know about the Force; he simply understood the facets of it which applied to himself more than his peers. 😛

Originally posted by Darth Sparrow
I don't think Bane, Nilhius and Revan are overated because we don't know...there are just as many people willing to say they did many things as there are dening it.

Maul= most overrated character ever.

^how do you figure?

Because he can apparently solo TPM Jedi Council and is will somehow "Give Rots Obi-Wan a run for his money" simply because he beat Anoon. Anoon's no slouch but c'mon.. aiside from that his best feat is defeating Qui-gon and being bested by Padawan Kenobi in lightsaber combat.

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
Because he can apparently solo TPM Jedi Council and is will somehow "Give Rots Obi-Wan a run for his money" simply because he beat Anoon. Anoon's no slouch but c'mon.. aiside from that his best feat is defeating Qui-gon and being bested by Padawan Kenobi in lightsaber combat.

Maul gives ROTS Obi Wan a run for his money. The only reason he even loses to Obi Wan in the first place is arrogance. Maul was actually the superior duelist in TPM. Second, ROTS Obi Wan has become a completely different fighter, more powerful but also less offensive minded.

And as far as the council goes, with the exception of Mace and Yoda, Maul probably has the beating of the TPM council.

Revan can be pretty overrated. Not by really people on this forum, but on other sites, he is greatly overrated.

Originally posted by Violent2Dope
Revan can be pretty overrated. Not by really people on this forum, but on other sites, he is greatly overrated.

Originally posted by Darth Hord
That is probably thing the aggravates me the most is the kotor fanbiys who say revan is god. 😠

Most overrated person is Obi-Wan Kenobi.

Yeah, the guy who killed Darth Maul and General Grevious, defeated Anakin Skywalker, Durge, and A'sharad Hett in one on one combat is so overrated. 🙄

Originally posted by Violent2Dope
Revan can be pretty overrated. Not by really people on this forum, but on other sites, he is greatly overrated.

Bullshit, of what I seen, Revan is underrated.

HANDS DOWN DE EMPEROR PALPATINE!

Originally posted by Darth Scythe
Yeah, the guy who killed Darth Maul and General Grevious, defeated Anakin Skywalker, Durge, and A'sharad Hett in one on one combat is so overrated. 🙄

And didn't Anakin kill Durge?

Anakin killed durge but im sure kenobi defeated him in a duel.

And as far as revan goes i can understand how he can be both overrated and underrated. He can be over by fanboys who say he is god and he can defeat anyone or virtually anyone (cep. sids. and luke) But I do think he can be underrated at times and in particular his saber skills because even though they are an unknown it is very doubtful he could win against a powerful opponent like malak without using his saber. (Have u ever seen more than a few all out duels when a lightsaber is not used at all between a jedi and sith?)

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
Yea...he got lucky with Maul and Anakin, and he's lucky there just happened to be a blaster there with GG and he's lucky that GG didn't just pull him apart instead of throwing him.

And didn't Anakin kill Durge?

Notice I said defeated, not killed.

But 3 wins being chalked up to luck? I guess he got lucky he had his lightsaber to cut off Hett's arm too huh.

Originally posted by ThoraxeRMG
Bullshit, of what I seen, Revan is underrated.

Originally posted by Violent2Dope
When people are claiming you TK skyscrapers,you know you are being overrated.

what kind of moron said that?