Son Goku vs Dark Schneider (Bastard)!!

Started by carver920 pages

Originally posted by BloodRain
Wha? Who said a PL10 Goku couldn't dodge a bullet? The point was that increasing their speed based on their PL doesnt work with that being an example. As in PL100 isnt twice as fast as PL50 if we only go by numbers. Chichi wasnt much above the other fodder in the 23rd budokai.

Actually I was refering to the manga, in the same way you decide that it took a second to blast the moon im using that to show how his charged beam was slower. In other words you can get a speed without a time reference.

Check the scans of the Chun vs Krillin match. He launches himself back to the arena with the kamehameha, he'd be launched as fast as the beam itself yet we have people able to keep track of him. Obviously cant be lightspeed if they can keep up.

20 times with every breath isnt impressive and his arms look like a blur.. a common thing for super speed punches. "Hyperboles are exaggerations to create emphasis or effect." Like Naruto's Ameterasu flames being hotter than the Sun but not able to burn someone if a sheet of cloth is in the way. Or theres Vegeta's attack being called Big Bang attack which causes an explosion, doesnt mean he's actually creating a big bang. It, like Tiens, is only a name to emphasise the moves power/speed.

Cept we know that Raditz speed < Saiyan Goku's who is Mach17. Thus the beam was naturally below this speed too. Youve even admited to Saiyan Goku not being able to fly at FTL speeds. Dont jump back on that because it'll lead to their reactions being under FTL too.

Theres only one (very questionable) thing that even hints to FTL with currently six characters that denounce FTL speeds.
With the characters movements (eg Saiyan Goku) not being close to SoL we're assured that the beams arent SoL for being not much faster than these characters.(eg Raditz)
With the beams not being SoL it takes away any hope of the Z fighters reacting to light speed moves.
I can see why youre going back on what you said a moment ago; "even though Goku was unable to fly around at light during the beginning of the Saiyan Saga"

I simply asked you to name someone with a weaker PL being faster than someone with a higher PL. That is the only way to help your argument. With an increase in PL comes an increase in speed, durablity, and power which has been shown throughout DBZ history. I already mentioned numerous of references to this and you have yet to counter it.

Then I asked you to show me a human in DBZ seeing a Z fighters attack and you throw off a young Krillin who wasn't even experieced with the kamehameha as an argument to aid you. Again, you are pulling straws.

I give you the Tien argument but if Akira placed in the story that Tien is punching at light, why ignore it?

I guess you don't get the meaning of reflexes. Goku AND Raditz reflexes is above light and this was proven when Raditz dodged a FTL attack from Piccolo that was faster than his random attack that hit the moon. If something happened in "a panel" it either happened in a second or instantly... a single panel is nothing but seconds which is all it took for Piccolo blast to hit the moon. As soon as he shot the moon lit up.

You might have something that discredits DBZ characters not being able to fly at light (even though you haven't proved it yet) but you don't have anything proving that their reflexes is below "c". Vegeta has shown that he can see/react/outpace light speed attacks. Goku as a child has outpaced light speed attacks... Raditz has dodged light speed attacks. It has been shown that with more power comes more speed with your attacks and movement. Then we have Burta moving so fast that time itself stopped (they were doing this in DB also).

Why is it so difficult for you to accept their speed?

Also, I'm still waiting on something proving that humans can react to DBZ attacks.

Originally posted by Karagiannis
heyy i know hisistasu11 ive had subbed to his youtube account....goku wins how many proffs do you want??

That guy is simply another delusional Goku fanboy like yourself. I've seen his posts on Anime Vice and viewing them literally makes your senses ache with how stupid and one-sided they are. Quit kissing his ass and debate using your own points or stop posting entirely.

Originally posted by carver9
I simply asked you to name someone with a weaker PL being faster than someone with a higher PL. That is the only way to help your argument. With an increase in PL comes an increase in speed, durablity, and power which has been shown throughout DBZ history. I already mentioned numerous of references to this and you have yet to counter it.

May have asked that but finding that answer wont help either of us in this debate. The original point is that linear PL scaling (eg PL150 is 1.5x faster than PL100) doesn't work. Will a higher PL be superior to a lower on? In nearly all cases yes. Can you increase the speed etc by how much the PL increases by? No.

Originally posted by carver9
Then I asked you to show me a human in DBZ seeing a Z fighters attack and you throw off a young Krillin who wasn't even experieced with the kamehameha as an argument to aid you. Again, you are pulling straws.

The people, not Krillin. Did ya even read what I wrote? Gah nevermind I'll post the scan at the bottom.

Originally posted by carver9
I give you the Tien argument but if Akira placed in the story that Tien is punching at light, why ignore it?

Because hyperbole is a logical fallacy. Not sure about the sub but in the dub(where its call High-speed velocity attack) he says he did 25-30+ punches during the whole attack. Thats not lightspeed. If it was 20 attacks per breath then it still wouldn't be lightspeed. And that... wait a second, this isnt even in the manga mmm coy, very coy.

Originally posted by carver9
I guess you don't get the meaning of reflexes. Goku AND Raditz reflexes is above light and this was proven when Raditz dodged a FTL attack from Piccolo that was faster than his random attack that hit the moon. If something happened in "a panel" it either happened in a second or instantly... a single panel is nothing but seconds which is all it took for Piccolo blast to hit the moon. As soon as he shot the moon lit up.

Can you prove a panel=a second? If so I can just as easily say that it took several panels for the attack to reach Raditz so has to be slower. What you're not getting is that by having Raditz, who we've confirmed as being low hypersonic, out-speed a Kamehameha it shows that the beams are not really SoL. The beams not being SoL means their reflexes aren't FTL.

Originally posted by carver9
You might have something that discredits DBZ characters not being able to fly at light (even though you haven't proved it yet) but you don't have anything proving that their reflexes is below "c". Vegeta has shown that he can see/react/outpace light speed attacks. Goku as a child has outpaced light speed attacks... Raditz has dodged light speed attacks. It has been shown that with more power comes more speed with your attacks and movement. Then we have Burta moving so fast that time itself stopped (they were doing this in DB also).

How is getting their speed from their full speed movements not proving it? Proved Saiyan Goku is Ma17 [during the fight he's around Mach 25-30 by some other calc], Namek Krillin is Ma20, Base Freeza is Ma60+ and Buu SSJ1 Gotenks is <Ma1000.
The reason why their reflexes aren't FTL is because their beams aren't FTL. As said if they cant fly at FTL then the beams cant be FTL either as there not much faster than the characters movements, and also as shown(below) the beams can be seen by normal humans so they're obviously not SoL/FTL.

Note: Burta moving at a speed where everything appears slow is one of the basic ways to show super-speed, not necessarily FTL unless theres a reason to say so. For instance like this Mach 15+ scene.

Originally posted by carver9
Why is it so difficult for you to accept their speed?

Because logic is telling me that 1 faulty instance should not be held above or denounce 6 solid instances. Could ask you why you're choosing to ignore all the speeds that confirm below light speeds (thus the chain that says the beams aren't and nor are their reflexes) in favour of a single instance that contradicts all other showings of beam speeds.

Originally posted by carver9
Also, I'm still waiting on something proving that humans can react to DBZ attacks.

Excluding the guy at the front all the people behind him are reacting to the beams.
''While they were playing around with those damn light ball tricks...''
Two people watching Roshi Kamehameha launch himself back to the area. During this he'd be going as fast as the beam itself.
Several people looking directly at the beam.

Originally posted by Esomark
That guy is simply another delusional Goku fanboy like yourself. I've seen his posts on Anime Vice and viewing them literally makes your senses ache with how stupid and one-sided they are. Quit kissing his ass and debate using your own points or stop posting entirely.

it is bad that ive subbed and add him as friend on youtube?

bloodrain your the stupidest person on earth i dont beleive that someone with such a low iq exists its so funny XD btw burter is faster that cap ginyu but weaker.if he was slower then why he would claim to be faster?goku sent cooler to the sun with a kamehameha in 1 minute while in sol it would take 8 minutes.and its was not time skipping cuz cooler was thinking all way.

Kara-dear, Daddy and Mommy are talking here, go play with your toys and keep quiet. Or go here instead. They seem to be at your 'intellect' so you might feel more at home. 🙂

Unless you start using proper sentences so we can understand you and stop using GT and movie's aka non-canon media, I think you should stop posting. We haven't the time to deal with another ignoramus here.

Now, do you have anything relevant to add to this conversation or can we safely ignore whatever you say?

in am not from england so i might have some mistakes in my setences.i just said that you are so stupid that i dont beleive you exist.your iq is lower than amoeba.an example of a weaker pl being faster that a higer pl is burter and captain ginyu.(i have to repeat things twice for you do understand?)

I'll give you that. You did notice that the conversation about the weaker/speed PL is over, right? And that the original topic was never about a higher PL being faster to begin with, right? And how it was about PL scaling and not PL in general like what you're saying, right? But I'm sure someone as smart as you already knew that, right?

The person who doesn't get how much bigger a galaxy is to a planet should not be say who is or isn't smart. No offence kid, but so far you have yet to contribute anything.

....................i know the size of a galaxy but its obvious that there are many db characters that can bust a galaxy.knowing the size of a galaxy has nothing to do with sb smartness but with his astronomy knowledge

Originally posted by BloodRain
May have asked that but finding that answer wont help either of us in this debate. The original point is that linear PL scaling (eg PL150 is 1.5x faster than PL100) doesn't work. Will a higher PL be superior to a lower on? In nearly all cases yes. Can you increase the speed etc by how much the PL increases by? No.

The people, not Krillin. Did ya even read what I wrote? Gah nevermind I'll post the scan at the bottom.

Because hyperbole is a logical fallacy. Not sure about the sub but in the dub(where its call High-speed velocity attack) he says he did 25-30+ punches during the whole attack. Thats not lightspeed. If it was 20 attacks per breath then it still wouldn't be lightspeed. And that... wait a second, this isnt even in the manga mmm coy, very coy.

Can you prove a panel=a second? If so I can just as easily say that it took several panels for the attack to reach Raditz so has to be slower. What you're not getting is that by having Raditz, who we've confirmed as being low hypersonic, out-speed a Kamehameha it shows that the beams are not really SoL. The beams not being SoL means their reflexes aren't FTL.

How is getting their speed from their full speed movements not proving it? Proved Saiyan Goku is Ma17 [during the fight he's around Mach 25-30 by some other calc], Namek Krillin is Ma20, Base Freeza is Ma60+ and Buu SSJ1 Gotenks is <Ma1000.
The reason why their reflexes aren't FTL is because their beams aren't FTL. As said if they cant fly at FTL then the beams cant be FTL either as there not much faster than the characters movements, and also as shown(below) the beams can be seen by normal humans so they're obviously not SoL/FTL.

Note: Burta moving at a speed where everything appears slow is one of the basic ways to show super-speed, not necessarily FTL unless theres a reason to say so. For instance like this Mach 15+ scene.

Because logic is telling me that 1 faulty instance should not be held above or denounce 6 solid instances. Could ask you why you're choosing to ignore all the speeds that confirm below light speeds (thus the chain that says the beams aren't and nor are their reflexes) in favour of a single instance that contradicts all other showings of beam speeds.

Excluding the guy at the front all the people behind him are reacting to the beams.
''While they were playing around with those damn light ball tricks...''
Two people watching Roshi Kamehameha launch himself back to the area. During this he'd be going as fast as the beam itself.
Several people looking directly at the beam.

I have given you instances where a PL increase equal speed increase. Hell, the sloghtest difference in PL was a huge gap in speed... example; Piccolo having a PL of 300 and Goku having a PL of 350 and he was blitzing the hell out of Picollo their entire fight. Another example... Goku taking 170 day to cross snake with a PL near a 1000 but him increasing to 5000 crossing snake way in 28 hours. Goku having a PL of 5000 and Nappa having a PL of 4000 and he couldn't lay a hand on Goku. These small difference in PL made a huge gap in speed and you are simply and clearly ignoring this because you don't like it.

I ask again, with Goku having a PL of 1000 the first trip on snake way and traveling 170 days his first trip and his second trip he made it across snake way in 28 hrs with just a small increase in power, how fast would Goku cross snake way with a PL of 180k? How fast would he cross it with a PL of 150 million? If Krillin and Roshi can do an entire martial art tourny in less than 1/5 of a second, hos fast do you think Frieza and Goku could perform those same moves? They didn't just throw a punch in 1/5 of a second, they performed an entire fighting routine in that short time period. Common sense buddy. Remember, Goku by the end of DB was SIGNIFICANTLY more faster than Roshi and Krillin... Super Saiyan Goku speed vs Roshi during the tourny... well, let's put it like this, I feel comfortable saying that a super saiyan Goku could possibly hit Roshi a thousand times before he realized he was in a fight... possibly more.

Again, your caculations have nothing to do with a Z fighters reflexes and the speed that you are coming up with is wrong as well.

Ok, I am going to single out every last one of your scans.

You show a guy looking at ROSHI while he is gliding through the air with his kamehameha blast... not what I am asking for. I never said that they couldn't see Roshi while he is shooting a blast. Show me them looking at the "blast".

Then you put up Buu "human extinction" blast.lol... do you know that this blast killed every human on the face of the planet in a short time span. Those blast was obvious light speed blast. Hell, they were curving and actually hit every human in the heart. That was clear light speed. It circled the world from one spot and killed every human (minus Hercule) within a short span WHILE aiming for the heart. That didn't help your argument.

Then you put up a scan of people looking, not at the blast but at the spot Tien Master got shot off from. Do you not understand what I am asking for? Show me a human seeing a DBZ blast... its just that simple. Of course they would look in the spot he got "shot from", where were you expecting them to look?

Then you show Hercule looking at an explosion. I just give up on you.

Piccolo shot a light speed blast at the moon... I see no reason for him to shoot a more powerful blast at Raditz at slow motion or slower than his casual blast... doesn't make sense. Raditz side stepped a FTL attack and Piccolo was shocked because it was his fastest most powerful attack that he had. Goku then holds Raditz (because even though Piccolo has FTL moon busting attacks, it will not touch Raditz since, well, he dodged his fastest attack already.

For all intended purposes, this thread should've been closed by now. I mean, what the hell is being debated now: DBZ being FTL?

I'm pretty sure that they aren't and even if they were, it doesn't show really well. I mean considering how everyone has gradually improved and the inconsistencies that are in DBZ, they should've been ripping of the "Speedforce" during the Buu saga.

Another thing I'll mention is that verses like One Piece and Shaman King have people with actually FTL reaction yet are inferior to the DBZ verse. So even if DBZ is FTL(they arn't) I don't see how it holds water to some of their other feats at all.

what about when kid gohan wasnt able to see nappa fighting tien?

Originally posted by carver9
I have given you instances where a PL increase equal speed increase. Hell, the sloghtest difference in PL was a huge gap in speed... example; Piccolo having a PL of 300 and Goku having a PL of 350 and he was blitzing the hell out of Picollo their entire fight. Another example... Goku taking 170 day to cross snake with a PL near a 1000 but him increasing to 5000 crossing snake way in 28 hours. Goku having a PL of 5000 and Nappa having a PL of 4000 and he couldn't lay a hand on Goku. These small difference in PL made a huge gap in speed and you are simply and clearly ignoring this because you don't like it.

Still missing the point man. Im not saying a guy with a higher PL doesn't make them automatically faster, Im saying that their speed doesn't directly increase by the number their PL increases by. IE the original point of PL scaling not being directly linear.

Originally posted by carver9
I ask again, with Goku having a PL of 1000 the first trip on snake way and traveling 170 days his first trip and his second trip he made it across snake way in 28 hrs with just a small increase in power, how fast would Goku cross snake way with a PL of 180k? How fast would he cross it with a PL of 150 million? If Krillin and Roshi can do an entire martial art tourny in less than 1/5 of a second, hos fast do you think Frieza and Goku could perform those same moves? They didn't just throw a punch in 1/5 of a second, they performed an entire fighting routine in that short time period. Common sense buddy. Remember, Goku by the end of DB was SIGNIFICANTLY more faster than Roshi and Krillin... Super Saiyan Goku speed vs Roshi during the tourny... well, let's put it like this, I feel comfortable saying that a super saiyan Goku could possibly hit Roshi a thousand times before he realized he was in a fight... possibly more.

Lets see, random guessing by PL scaling or actual feats we we see happening... think the latter holds more water, ney?

Originally posted by carver9
Again, your caculations have nothing to do with a Z fighters reflexes and the speed that you are coming up with is wrong as well.

Why must you miss the point again? Yeesh, point-by-point time;
• DBZ guys cant move SoL. [Proven]
• DBZ beams are only somewhat faster than what DBZ guys can move. [This we know]
= DBZ beams not being FTL. [By a logical conclusion of the two things we know]

• You say they have FTL reactions by reacting to their FTL beams. [Urm... Filler brackets! ò-ó]
• ..but we know the beams aren't FTL for being a little faster than their movements. [Again something we know]
= DBZ guys not having FTL reactions. [The end logical conclusion based of what we know]

Or another way; For them to have FTL reactions the beams must be FTL, for the beams to be FTL the characters must be SoL. But because the characters cant move at SoL the beams don't move FTL, thus their reactions dont have to be FTL to react to them.

In other words their movement speed calcs relate to the beams speed which is needed for their reactions. [Think that covered it]

Originally posted by carver9
Ok, I am going to single out every last one of your scans.

Im ready for it coach!

Originally posted by carver9
You show a guy looking at ROSHI while he is gliding through the air with his kamehameha blast... not what I am asking for. I never said that they couldn't see Roshi while he is shooting a blast. Show me them looking at the "blast".

Yeeaah, thing is Roshi was moving as fast as the Kamehameha, as that was what was launching him. So for a person to see Roshi they are seeing something move at Kamehameha speeds.

Originally posted by carver9
Then you put up Buu "human extinction" blast.lol... do you know that this blast killed every human on the face of the planet in a short time span. Those blast was obvious light speed blast. Hell, they were curving and actually hit every human in the heart. That was clear light speed. It circled the world from one spot and killed every human (minus Hercule) within a short span WHILE aiming for the heart. That didn't help your argument.

Look at the scan. We clearly have (I count) 11 people reacting to the beams heading at them. So can every Earthling react to light speed beams now? Yup my argument still stands tall.

Actually Id like to know why you think this particular move is light-speed because it circled the earth in a moment. How many minutes or seconds do you think it took? (Pretending for a moment that the people didnt actually see them)

Originally posted by carver9
Then you put up a scan of people looking, not at the blast but at the spot Tien Master got shot off from. Do you not understand what I am asking for? Show me a human seeing a DBZ blast... its just that simple. Of course they would look in the spot he got "shot from", where were you expecting them to look?

...so people were able to see Shen disappear at FTL speeds the instant the move happened yet they take longer to react to all the other high-speed movements? I see.

Originally posted by carver9
Then you show Hercule looking at an explosion. I just give up on you.

Why are you telling me what I posted? I know what I posted in fact, I was the one that posted them. Notice he said tricks plural, as in more than on instance. Eg Vegeta's blast.

Originally posted by carver9
Piccolo shot a light speed blast at the moon... I see no reason for him to shoot a more powerful blast at Raditz at slow motion or slower than his casual blast... doesn't make sense. Raditz side stepped a FTL attack and Piccolo was shocked because it was his fastest most powerful attack that he had. Goku then holds Raditz (because even though Piccolo has FTL moon busting attacks, it will not touch Raditz since, well, he dodged his fastest attack already.

''Logic is telling me that 1 faulty instance should not be held above or denounce 6 solid instances.''
''Can you prove a panel=a second? If so I can just as easily say that it took several panels for the attack to reach Raditz so has to be slower.''
Kinda skipped over proving that a panel = a second. FYI there isn't a way to simply say ''it is cos it is'' as that opens the gate for me to jump in saying how it took several 'panels' to reach Raditz. And by your logic that would make that attack take several seconds. (Slower than it actually is even by my standards)

As I said you're whole argument is balanced on Piccolo's one time move that A) Doesnt have a legitimate (IE not by panel numbers) time-frame for, and B) Would be contradicted by slower characters being able to out run (not talking about reacting to, talking about out running) the beams.

Originally posted by wakkawakkawakka
Another thing I'll mention is that verses like One Piece and Shaman King have people with actually FTL reaction yet are inferior to the DBZ verse.

Cept for King Hao that is. ahah

this is so stupid why you cant understand that goku will win :@ >🙁

😠

😒

Please stop triple posting.

No one in this thread, not even a great DBZ fan like carver, thinks that Goku can win this.

Karagiannas, please stop. Goku isn't winning, that is a fact that has been proven multiple times that you aren't understanding for some reason.

Show scans from the series like an actual debater to back up your claims. I don't have to understand that Goku wins since theirs proven and results showing how he loose.

It hurts to see a fan-favorite loose to a lame character I know but that's no reason to insult people. That borderline flaming you know.

BloodRain: Forgot to exclude Hao...my bad!

Originally posted by BloodRain
Still missing the point man. Im not saying a guy with a higher PL doesn't make them automatically faster, Im saying that their speed doesn't directly increase by the number their PL increases by. IE the original point of PL scaling not being directly linear.

Lets see, random guessing by PL scaling or actual feats we we see happening... think the latter holds more water, ney?

Why must you miss the point again? Yeesh, point-by-point time;
• DBZ guys cant move SoL. [Proven]
• DBZ beams are only somewhat faster than what DBZ guys can move. [This we know]
= DBZ beams not being FTL. [By a logical conclusion of the two things we know]

• You say they have FTL reactions by reacting to their FTL beams. [Urm... Filler brackets! ò-ó]
• ..but we know the beams aren't FTL for being a little faster than their movements. [Again something we know]
= DBZ guys not having FTL reactions. [The end logical conclusion based of what we know]

Or another way; For them to have FTL reactions the beams must be FTL, for the beams to be FTL the characters must be SoL. But because the characters cant move at SoL the beams don't move FTL, thus their reactions dont have to be FTL to react to them.

In other words their movement speed calcs relate to the beams speed which is needed for their reactions. [Think that covered it]

Im ready for it coach!

Yeeaah, thing is Roshi was moving as fast as the Kamehameha, as that was what was launching him. So for a person to see Roshi they are seeing something move at Kamehameha speeds.

Look at the scan. We clearly have (I count) 11 people reacting to the beams heading at them. So can every Earthling react to light speed beams now? Yup my argument still stands tall.

Actually Id like to know why you think this particular move is light-speed because it circled the earth in a moment. How many minutes or seconds do you think it took? (Pretending for a moment that the people didnt actually see them)

...so people were able to see Shen disappear at FTL speeds the instant the move happened yet they take longer to react to all the other high-speed movements? I see.

Why are you telling me what I posted? I know what I posted in fact, I was the one that posted them. Notice he said tricks plural, as in more than on instance. Eg Vegeta's blast.

''Logic is telling me that 1 faulty instance should not be held above or denounce 6 solid instances.''
''Can you prove a panel=a second? If so I can just as easily say that it took several panels for the attack to reach Raditz so has to be slower.''
Kinda skipped over proving that a panel = a second. FYI there isn't a way to simply say ''it is cos it is'' as that opens the gate for me to jump in saying how it took several 'panels' to reach Raditz. And by your logic that would make that attack take several seconds. (Slower than it actually is even by my standards)

As I said you're whole argument is balanced on Piccolo's one time move that A) Doesnt have a legitimate (IE not by panel numbers) time-frame for, and B) Would be contradicted by slower characters being able to out run (not talking about reacting to, talking about out running) the beams.

Cept for King Hao that is. ahah

I never said that their speed increase by the number of their PL but what I am saying is that the smallest increase towards their PL makes a difference in speed. The thing you are failing to understand is, PL means a lot regarding feats. Super Saiyan Goku doesn't have to run snake way to prove that he can do it better than a Goku with a PL of 5000 because understanding PL is proof enough of this. Then you are completely ignoring what happened on panel and I keep having to repeat it. Goku had a PL of a 1000, it took him 170 days to cross snakeway. He then increase his PL to 5000 and it took him 28 hrs to cross snakeway... do you not see the difference in that or are you ignoring it. 28 hrs vs 170 days with just a small jump in power. That is proof enough that someone with a PL in the million could blow 28 hrs out of the water EASILY unless again, "you ignore PL" which was put into place for a reason.

Power level scaling IS feats. Who do you think is faster, super Saiyan Goku or Saiyan Saga Goku. Who do you think is stronger, Frieza or Piccolo during the Cell saga? Who do you think could generate more power, Frieza or King Piccolo? I pretty much can answer all of those questions for you and do you want to know why? Power levels is why. To ignore PL is to ignore DBz and we basically need to end this convo if that the case.

How about you tell ME how long it took the beam to hit the moon... its pretty obvious to me...

http://media.animevice.com/uploads/0/5512/303420-pik1_super.jpg

Piccolo beam against Raditz is faster because if it wasn't, he wouldn't have been so shocked at the idea of Raditz dodging it. Any beam after Piccolo beam were much faster since again, we have proof that with greater power comes greater speed with energy blasts.

Show me people looking at Shen disappear. They are clearly looking at the spot Shen was at while he was long gone.

Lol... Roshi propelling himself with his beam doesn't necessarily mean that he is going just that fast... that ridiculous. Cyclops has done the same thing with his blast but doesn't go anywhere near light speed while ding this and then you have to think of this, Z fighters, includng Roshi pretty much knows how to control their Ki energy. You failed with that scan.

I'm not seeing anyone perceiving or dodging buu attack.

Your scans failed and Hercule thought everything that DBZ characters did was a trick, him seeing an explosion doesn't change the speed of the beam that made the explosion.

Originally posted by carver9
I never said that their speed increase by the number of their PL but what I am saying is that the smallest increase towards their PL makes a difference in speed. The thing you are failing to understand is, PL means a lot regarding feats. Super Saiyan Goku doesn't have to run snake way to prove that he can do it better than a Goku with a PL of 5000 because understanding PL is proof enough of this. Then you are completely ignoring what happened on panel and I keep having to repeat it. Goku had a PL of a 1000, it took him 170 days to cross snakeway. He then increase his PL to 5000 and it took him 28 hrs to cross snakeway... do you not see the difference in that or are you ignoring it. 28 hrs vs 170 days with just a small jump in power. That is proof enough that someone with a PL in the million could blow 28 hrs out of the water EASILY unless again, "you ignore PL" which was put into place for a reason.

Then it seems we've been talking about two different things. The whole time I was talking about the issues with linear PL scaling, not whatever youre talking about. 😕 Back to the plot, the method you used just then in right in theory buy doesnt yield results. All that says is someone with a higher PL is faster without telling us by how much. For instance PL200 Goku is 400x faster than a PL5 human while a PL500,000 Frieza is only around 5-10x faster than a PL14,000 Gohan. <-The difference between Goku and a humans PL is the same as the difference between Frieza's and Gohans, as we can see the speeds dont match up with the PL change.

Originally posted by carver9
Power level scaling IS feats. Who do you think is faster, super Saiyan Goku or Saiyan Saga Goku. Who do you think is stronger, Frieza or Piccolo during the Cell saga? Who do you think could generate more power, Frieza or King Piccolo? I pretty much can answer all of those questions for you and do you want to know why? Power levels is why. To ignore PL is to ignore DBz and we basically need to end this convo if that the case.

....yeah carver, what youre describing isnt PL scaling. Linear PL scaling is when you say, for example, PL100 Goku is Mach 10 so PL200 Goku must be Mach 20 as the power level double so must the speed. THATS PL scaling, not what you're doing.

Originally posted by carver9
How about you tell ME how long it took the beam to hit the moon... its pretty obvious to me...

http://media.animevice.com/uploads/0/5512/303420-pik1_super.jpg


The burden of proof is on you kind sir. If you claim its FTL and a second/instant then its up to you to prove it. And make it a good on as your whole argument rests on this.

Originally posted by carver9
Piccolo beam against Raditz is faster because if it wasn't, he wouldn't have been so shocked at the idea of Raditz dodging it. Any beam after Piccolo beam were much faster since again, we have proof that with greater power comes greater speed with energy blasts.

Which isnt FTL since you have to first prove that the moon feat, besides its inconsistency, happened in a second. Also it happened in several panels, so if 1 panel = 1 second... Lets just say you'll need to get that time-frame.

Originally posted by carver9
Show me people looking at Shen disappear. They are clearly looking at the spot Shen was at while he was long gone.

Missed the point. See why would anyone be as shocked as they are if to them he simply vanished if people have been doing that all day in the ring with no one being as surprised. Their reactions wouldnt even change if it was as fast as you think. Hang on a sec, Shen being launched was at the blasts speed but Roshi being launched isnt? Double standards.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol... Roshi propelling himself with his beam doesn't necessarily mean that he is going just that fast... that ridiculous. Cyclops has done the same thing with his blast but doesn't go anywhere near light speed while ding this and then you have to think of this, Z fighters, includng Roshi pretty much knows how to control their Ki energy. You failed with that scan.

Cyclops' beams arent FTL, they're energy launched from another dimension. Moving on, the Kamehameha is moving him as fast as the beam just like how anyone caught in the beam is launched at its speed. Meaning Roshi, like any other instance, was moving just as fast. You say fail alot without actually proving anything, might wanna work on that.

Originally posted by carver9
I'm not seeing anyone perceiving or dodging buu attack.

[Stupid photobucket freezing up >__>]

The only thing that fails is if you fail to notice. 9 circled people trying to get away from the beams, out of the 9 the 6 thick lined ones are blatantly reacting to the beams about to strike them. Theres also one green ringed one. No reason, its just green.

One more time from the top; why in your opinion are the beams FTL because they traveled the planet in.... some amount of time?

Originally posted by carver9
Your scans failed and Hercule thought everything that DBZ characters did was a trick, him seeing an explosion doesn't change the speed of the beam that made the explosion.

Satan said ''light ball tricks'' plural so not just the one struggle. The one Vegeta used would count in this.

------
TBH you're fighting an unwinnable argument. First its going to be near impossible for you to get a time-frame for Piccolo's blast, failing to do so destroys any chance of FTL arguments. Second is that this feat can't actually be SoL as its inconsistent to the rest of the series. So no matter how you look at it the base of your argument is gone.