Superman vs Silver surfer · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

darthgoober Senior Member

Let's see...

Surfer vs All Star= Surfer 6-7/10
Surfer vs Sundipped= Even split unless Supes sunbathed for a while
Surfer vs Pre Crisis= Supes 6/10

Phenomenol Restricted

LMAO!

Surfer can't handle ANY Superman in a physical confrontation!!

Only way Surfer could beat Supes is by draining him.

Violent2Dope Restricted

Originally posted by Sarutobi700
Thanos>SS=Hulk>>>>>>Darkseid>>>(infinite>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>😉>>>>Superman

*Raises hand*When the f*ck did Hulk start to become SS's equal, and when did DS get weaker than Hulk and Surfer?

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Phenomenol
LMAO!
Surfer can't handle ANY Superman in a physical confrontation!!
Only way Surfer could beat Supes is by draining him.

I didn't say anything about a physical confrontation, nor does the thread limit specify it as such.

Doctor-Alvis Post-Crisis Balki

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Darsied>supes>thanos>surfer>hulk
This is how my mind works

The transitive property doesn't work in comics most of the time when comparing characters as a whole unless their powersets are very similar if not identical.

Gecko4lif Senior Member

Originally posted by Doctor-Alvis
The transitive property doesn't work in comics most of the time when comparing characters as a whole unless their powersets are very similar if not identical.

Teach me your ways

Harry Fingerman Dead

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Im ashamed of you harry
You are dropping to phenom/quan level....

How could I be dropping?

Wouldn't I be 'going up to' Phenom/Quanchi's level?

Those guys are the real heroes. 🙂

vlaaad12345 Senior Member

Only superman who can maybe loose is sundipped supes,allstar is regular supes x3 or more he would destroy surfer,and pc supes....dont even see how people think surfer could get .000000000000000000001/10 against him.

Gecko4lif Senior Member

Originally posted by Harry Fingerman
How could I be dropping?
Wouldn't I be 'going up to' Phenom/Quanchi's level?
Those guys are the real heroes. 🙂

Well i suppose YOU are going up on the troll-o-meter

Give it another month or 2 and you might surpass them.

moonknight11 Senior Member

Originally posted by Doctor-Alvis
The transitive property doesn't work in comics most of the time when comparing characters as a whole unless their powersets are very similar if not identical.

Especially when its reasoning is so flawed. 🙂

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by vlaaad12345
Only superman who can maybe loose is sundipped supes,allstar is regular supes x3 or more he would destroy surfer,and pc supes....dont even see how people think surfer could get .000000000000000000001/10 against him.

As impressive as PC Supes was, he was also notoriously vulnerable to K-nite and red sun radiation(unlike current Supes who's built up a resistance to both), which is why Surfer is able to pull some wins against him IMO. Hell, Surfer could actually create gold k-nite for an easy win.

Gecko4lif Senior Member

Originally posted by darthgoober
As impressive as PC Supes was, he was also notoriously vulnerable to K-nite and red sun radiation(unlike current Supes who's built up a resistance to both), which is why Surfer is able to pull some wins against him IMO. Hell, Surfer could actually create gold k-nite for an easy win.

And pc supes will just use his anti surfer ray

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
And pc supes will just use his anti surfer ray

And when has he used this on panel?

Violent2Dope Restricted

Originally posted by darthgoober
And when has he used this on panel?

He doesn't need to. He's PC-Supes Goddamnit!

Gecko4lif Senior Member

Originally posted by Violent2Dope
He doesn't need to. He's PC-Supes Goddamnit!

Exactly

He has a power for any situation

he is part of the reason they had the crisis

Bad Ash231 Harbinger of Dur

Bah.

Superman could punch through the Surfer's energy blasts, punch through transmutation, and punch through Surfer's durability advantage. If the Surfer finds another way to beat him, he'd punch through it.

Priest Senior Member

Originally posted by darthgoober
Let's see...
Surfer vs All Star= Surfer 6-7/10
Surfer vs Sundipped= Even split unless Supes sunbathed for a while
Surfer vs Pre Crisis= Supes 6/10

👆

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Exactly
He has a power for any situation
he is part of the reason they had the crisis

powers that include getting his ass kicked by monkeys and Muhammad Ali?

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Violent2Dope
He doesn't need to. He's PC-Supes Goddamnit!

Bullshit. People are always acting like PC Supes could pull any random power at his ass due to all the one shot abilities he came up with, but he never really showed a greater number of abilities than Surfer or a GL, but no one gets to say that they can use an Anti-Thor out of no where ray because they've never done so before. A logical deduction of established abilities is one thing, but giving someone an unlimited number of abilities because of a decent(at best) number of one shot powers is bogus IMO.

Harry Fingerman Dead

Originally posted by Gecko4lif
Well i suppose YOU are going up on the troll-o-meter
Give it another month or 2 and you might surpass them.

Problem is, they are serious.
I'm not... most of the time.

Also, if you can't detect sarcasm, or anything like that, then well, that makes you some sort of not-detecting-sarcasm-kind of-guy... renske

Plus, I don't remember you ever seeing me debate... so how can I be 'going down' in your eyes?

Gecko4lif Senior Member

Originally posted by Harry Fingerman
Problem is, they are serious.
I'm not... most of the time.
Also, if you can't detect sarcasm, or anything like that, then well, that makes you some sort of not-detecting-sarcasm-kind of-guy... renske
Plus, I don't remember you ever seeing me debate... so how can I be 'going down' in your eyes?

That is exactly how. You not being serous.