Superman vs Silver surfer

Started by carver9387 pages
Originally posted by Raoul
superman is honest to a fault. is gorgon?

But how does superman know that he is throwing planet destroying punches when he has never physically punched a planet to dust. How can you say you can do something when you have never done it.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
I suppose all of SS's speed feats could easily be narrative hyperbole as well, show me a scan were SS destroys planets with his fist. Oh and thats pure speculation in terms of strength, as it stands SS has no strength feats to suggest he could easily amp himself to clarks levels.
He destroys planets with his power cosmic. His power cosmic would severely handicap Superman imo.

Originally posted by Raoul
superman is honest to a fault. is gorgon?

But how can superman know that hes honest about something that he has never attempted. Its nothing but hyperbole. I think that I can punch a hole in a wall but I never tried, can I really do it, well...... 😕

Originally posted by carver9
But how can superman know that hes honest about something that he has never attempted. Its nothing but hyperbole. I think that I can punch a hole in a wall but I never tried, can I really do it, well...... 😕
Three reasons why you can put faith in Superman's words: 1) Superman has experience in fighting on those levels of power. You may not know if you could break a few wooden boards, but a competent soldier trained in Basic might, even if he never did; 2) Superman has retained his super intelligence and calculative abilities from when he was Superman Blue. In a JLA/Teen Titans crossover, everybody is trying to breach Cyborg's forcefield. He flies up in the air and thinks to himself about how he retains that type of calculative ability despite having just changed back to normal Superman and figures out exactly how intense his heat vision needs to be, how hard he has to fly into it and when the other folks have to hit it; and 3) Superman was thinking to himself about the force he was using on Konvikt. There was no motivation to hyperbolize either.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Three reasons why you can put faith in Superman's words: 1) Superman has experience in fighting on those levels of power. You may not know if you could break a few wooden boards, but a competent soldier trained in Basic might, even if he never did; 2) Superman has retained his super intelligence and calculative abilities from when he was Superman Blue. In a JLA/Teen Titans crossover, everybody is trying to breach Cyborg's forcefield. He flies up in the air and thinks to himself about how he retains that type of calculative ability despite having just changed back to normal Superman and figures out exactly how intense his heat vision needs to be, how hard he has to fly into it and when the other folks have to hit it; and 3) Superman was thinking to himself about the force he was using on Konvikt. There was no motivation to hyperbolize either.

He said small planets but there are some planets that is smaller then earths moon.

Oiii......the Mageddon wheel feat alone proves he can one-shot planets. 😬

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Oiii......the Mageddon wheel feat alone proves he can one-shot planets. 😬

No sir it does not.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Oiii......the Mageddon wheel feat alone proves he can one-shot planets. 😬

Totally disagree, that feat is overrated.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Oiii......the Mageddon wheel feat alone proves he can one-shot planets. 😬
Explain.

Please.

Originally posted by carver9
He said small planets but there are some planets that is smaller then earths moon.

No there aren't. There are planetoids or dwarf planets smaller than Earth's moon. Not planets.

crylaugh

Originally posted by Soljer
No there aren't. There are planetoids or dwarf planets smaller than Earth's moon. Not planets.
He's probably referring to Pluto, which is smaller than Earth's Moon. Walk onto the street in and I guarantee you most people don't know that in 2006, Pluto was reclassified as a "dwarf planet" and not a true planet.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Three reasons why you can put faith in Superman's words: 1) Superman has experience in fighting on those levels of power. You may not know if you could break a few wooden boards, but a competent soldier trained in Basic might, even if he never did; 2) Superman has retained his super intelligence and calculative abilities from when he was Superman Blue. In a JLA/Teen Titans crossover, everybody is trying to breach Cyborg's forcefield. He flies up in the air and thinks to himself about how he retains that type of calculative ability despite having just changed back to normal Superman and figures out exactly how intense his heat vision needs to be, how hard he has to fly into it and when the other folks have to hit it; and 3) Superman was thinking to himself about the force he was using on Konvikt. There was no motivation to hyperbolize either.

This is correct, narative hyperbole is one thing but Supes has never been portrayed to be a"braggart"of any sort that would exagurate(sp?) feats. Besides we could easily deduce that SS speed feats are"hyberbole"in nature but we just take his word for it. At any rate aside from combat speed and physical strength I dont see clark having any real advantage...SS 7/10

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
He's probably referring to Pluto, which is smaller than Earth's Moon. Walk onto the street in and I guarantee you most people don't know that in 2006, Pluto was reclassified as a "dwarf planet" and not a true planet.

I guarantee you that Superman knows the difference, however.

Earth is a small planet. ermm

Originally posted by batdude123
Earth is a small planet. ermm

The smallest planet known has a mass roughly equal to half that of Mercury. The largest planets are around thirteen times the size of Jupiter.

If that helps. *shrug*.

Originally posted by Soljer
The smallest planet known has a mass roughly equal to half that of Mercury. The largest planets are around thirteen times the size of Jupiter.

If that helps. *shrug*.

"If that helps"? I wasn't asking a question. I'm pretty familiar with Astronomy.

Originally posted by batdude123
"If that helps"? I wasn't asking a question. I'm pretty familiar with Astronomy.

It wasn't directed at you, it was directed at the problem of what, exactly, is a small planet.

It was simply a continuation of the thought started in your post. Hence the quote.

Originally posted by Soljer
I guarantee you that Superman knows the difference, however.
I think it's more dependant on whether the writer actually knows. After all, apparently nobody in Marvel knows that the human skull is encased in bone. But considering that Busiek actually wrote in Trinity #2, captions for John Stewart about how he still thinks Pluto is a planet despite what everybody else says... then yeah. But you can still have planets smaller than the Moon. Pluto just doesn't have sufficient mass to classify as one.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Explain.

Please.

Jesus ****ing.......Did you even read the story? Tell me who Mageddon is, then. 😬