Originally posted by darthgooberI'll do it, but nobody said i have to prove superman wins now did they. 😖mart: 😖hifty:
Ok lets settle this once and for all because I'm sick of seeing people duck and dodge points and act like they've argued to a legitimate impasse. I'm throwing down the gauntlet to anyone who's man enough to pick it up and let the onlookers and judges decide who's "won" the debate.Battlezone.
Surfer vs Supes
Me vs anyone interested
Who wants some?
Originally posted by Priest
Non of this is any substance to this debate.
All it is is a ploy to ignore points made and just respond by going off topic just for the sake of it.Anywayz here is my orginal aurgument:
Anyone else who wants to actually debate this without dancing around it like Avolon, feel free.
What is there to debate, SS is a high end energy type and Supes is a high end brawler. SS would need to keep at good distance and ultalize his powers effectivly, if the gab is closed the ball is in Supes court...thats pretty much it.
Originally posted by The Great Galen
What is there to debate, SS is a high end energy type and Supes is a high end brawler. SS would need to keep at good distance and ultalize his powers effectivly, if the gab is closed the ball is in Supes court...thats pretty much it.
Originally posted by darthgoober
Ok lets settle this once and for all because I'm sick of seeing people duck and dodge points and act like they've argued to a legitimate impasse. I'm throwing down the gauntlet to anyone who's man enough to pick it up and let the onlookers and judges decide who's "won" the debate.Battlezone.
Surfer vs Supes
Me vs anyone interested
Who wants some?
Originally posted by ultimatethorPlease stop with the insults. Thanks.
LOL a million times. 😂 U are talking about being dense? Yet u use ABC logic to determine that superman beats silver surfer and actually think its valid. 🙄 How foolish.Not only that but u are also highly confused. U r talking about going back and forth? You make stupid assertions and when called out on them u start bringing in irrelevant topics and circumventing the issue that was in question. 😂 And yes ive made up my mind, are u trying to tell me that u havent? U have decided that it could go either way, ive decided that Ss wins( as most people have btw)
Missing the obvious?lol Are u freaking blind? It seems u have not looked at the poll where Ss has almost 70 percent of the votes. In ur blindness u might not have seen it but most people do agree that SS wins.
Oh come on Supes fans, I’m not even talking about a Battlezone to prove who wins in a forum fight between Surfer and Supes because that’d be way to easy for me and we‘d probably never agree on the judges anyway. I’m talking about a Battlezone to determine which side is actually “winning” the debate itself. In other words, which side of the argument is doing a better job of raising valid points and addressing and countering the points of their opponents rather than sidestepping/making BS claims and then claiming “victory“ in the argument. If your of the opinion that the result is an even split then go ahead and debate that, it’s about the debate itself not who wins a fight between Surfer and Supes.
So come on, don’t be scared. All you have to do is bring a reasonable arguement to the table and you've got a legitimate shot at winning. Of course if you already know that all you're really doing is talking out of your ass...
Originally posted by darthgoober
Oh come on Supes fans, I’m not even talking about a Battlezone to prove who wins in a forum fight between Surfer and Supes because that’d be way to easy for me and we‘d probably never agree on the judges anyway. I’m talking about a Battlezone to determine which side is actually “winning” the debate itself. In other words, which side of the argument is doing a better job of raising valid points and addressing and countering the points of their opponents rather than sidestepping/making BS claims and then claiming “victory“ in the argument. If your of the opinion that the result is an even split then go ahead and debate that, it’s about the debate itself not who wins a fight between Surfer and Supes.So come on, don’t be scared. All you have to do is bring a reasonable arguement to the table and you've got a legitimate shot at winning. Of course if you already know that all you're really doing is talking out of your ass...
They really cant bring a reasonable argument to the table, if they did then they wud have done it already. All u will probably hear is "without exploiting weaknesses SS loses everytime" or " supes will find a way to win" or my personal favorite, " surfer cant beat thor and supes has beaten thor in a crossover so he wins"
Originally posted by Badabing
I guess the polite requests and warnings aren't getting through to you. Shall we let this escalate? Stop flaming and stop changing user names when quoting in order to insult.
Alright its cool, not gonna get mad over something so trival even inspite of the sheer levels of bias BS going around here.
Originally posted by Redlineshifter
Given the numerous feats for both of these characters, neither of them can be dismissed with a simple 10/10.SS and Supes aren't going down without a hard fight. Trying to push against that obvious truth is what leads to a 230+ page thread.
Originally posted by darthgoober
10/10 is extreme... which is why I only give Surfer the win 8-9/10 😉 . Supes can make a show of it just as Thing can make a show in a fight with the Hulk, but he's almost always going to be the one KO'd in the end.
ill agree with this...supes can squeeze in a win MAYBE two
Originally posted by DestinyGuy678
question, isnt it possible for superman to vibrate though surfers blasts?
Originally posted by ultimatethor
Ok lets go over this again, someone( not me) brought up surfers good showings on the astral plane during In thy name. You then talked about in thy name and tried to argue that he didnt have a good showing by sighting how the creature defeated him on the[B]physical plane and how he was crucified which also happened on the physical plane.
And now, You are saying that the arc showed that surfer showed he was not adept at using the astral plane just because he did not instantly know that the creature was linked to it even though in that same arc he proved invincible to the creature? 😕 [/B]
Your right it was probably just PIS or CIS on part of the Surfer since he defeated Thanos on the astral realm and not a creature who is as great as the mad titan. There's all the evidence needed. I almost forgot that battle.
Originally posted by darthgoober
Surfer's blasts have proven capable of tagging intangible beings before....
http://i118.photobucket.com/albums/o106/bigbran1/comic/surfer1.jpg
http://i118.photobucket.com/albums/o106/bigbran1/comic/surfer2.jpg
Why is there only tal of supes vibrating when surfer can do the exact same thing?
