Superman vs Silver surfer

Started by Ionceknewu387 pages

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Why is everyone crying so damn much. He made a post. Felt more like a closing post than an opening post to me, but it is what it is - Abhi agreed to continue the battle and was going to whip his ass. I say Bada delete all the posts after the opening, re-open the thread, and just let it continue.

I can step in to judge in Digi's place if both want/agree.

Balanced and fair.

If he is talking about how he will post scans, etc. how is that not relevant to future posts? Don't people bait each other here all the time? It seems like common practice to be honest. That is what I took it as.

But anyways, I just think for all the talk there was of having all these scans..I would of just said "okay, nice attempt to discredit me, now here are a bunch of scans that prove my case".

I still say if people have the scans just post them here. The mods will read through the BZ topic and decide what to do.

Originally posted by Blair Wind
Why is everyone crying so damn much. He made a post. Felt more like a closing post than an opening post to me, but it is what it is - Abhi agreed to continue the battle and said he was going to whip his ass. I say Bada delete all the posts after the opening, re-open the thread, and just let it continue.

I can step in to judge in Digi's place if both want/agree.

👆

I was very close to temp banning 6 of you. If you can't figure out who I mean then consider the people whose posts I had to delete in bulk. When Pr, or any mod, says stop then please stop.

If you want to challenge a person to a BZ that's okay. But please make a BZ discussion thread after a challenge is accepted. A mod will be happy to pin it at the top of the forum. I've just had to delete several pages of BZ discussion, then the ensuing nonsense posts.

And that BZ... facepalm Next time be sure of the rules, format, judges, post limit, time limit, etc. That entire thread was so horrible I had to bin it before it infected the rest of KMC.

Darthgoober, I saw your posts about me regarding a long story and it's a bad idea for me to judge. I had to look in your profile to see when you stopped posting. Then check my old PMs. I still don't get. It's been 5 years, and it wasn't important enough for me to remember without researching the subject. Move on bro. 👆

You shouldn't have to say please after the first time, tbh.

Damn! I missed it.

So No BZ. What the heck happened? I read the thread yesterday, then now it's gone.

LoB, Abhi and BW all have a week off. I like you guys, and it's fun joking on KMC. But when Pr, or any mod, says stop then it's best to do so. This behavior of trashing several threads and flat out ignoring mods is not acceptable. That and all the posts I had to delete.

Blue Area Vet and Carver, you both were very close. Pr felt you didn't deserve temp bans. Be very glad Pr is more forgiving than me. And Carver, remember this post the next time you accuse Pr of hating on you.

Darthgoober, you haven't been on KMC much lately and may have forgotten how things work here. I hope this behavior was an aberration in the heat of debate and won't happen again.

This isn't in reply to your actions Bada or what you said because I agree with all of it, including what was said about my actions. Just want Pr to know I was playing with him about the hate post. I know (or hope) he doesn't hate me, it's just fun messing with him. I guess it's hard to determine if someone is playing through typed words. Oh well.

What shame, I was looking forward to that much..

Originally posted by carver9
This isn't in reply to your actions Bada or what you said because I agree with all of it, including what was said about my actions. Just want Pr to know I was playing with him about the hate post. I know (or hope) he doesn't hate me, it's just fun messing with him. I guess it's hard to determine if someone is playing through typed words. Oh well.
Hard to determine...

Do you know about a smilies or emoticons? Maybe this will help you out. sneergun3

Lol...he should've known it wasn't real because he never said those words. I'll just use smileys next time.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...he should've known it wasn't real because he never said those words. I'll just use smileys next time.

Sure we all believe you, you are carver after all.

Damn, Badas rampage had some victims...

Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
Damn, Badas rampage had some victims...


Yup... Guess I should wait a while and let things cool off all around before I reissue the challenge 😂

Back on topic....

Surfer wins a definitive majority in a typical forum match with weakness exploitation as an option. Better ranged game, way more offensive options, way better defensive options, and closer to Clark in the couple areas in which Supes has an edge than vice versa.

Originally posted by carver9
This isn't in reply to your actions Bada or what you said because I agree with all of it, including what was said about my actions. Just want Pr to know I was playing with him about the hate post. I know (or hope) he doesn't hate me, it's just fun messing with him. I guess it's hard to determine if someone is playing through typed words. Oh well.

I know you don't think I hate you; some people think I do, though.

If you could stop lowballing and baiting, maybe you'd be less likely to end up on the chopping block.

Originally posted by Ambient
Damn! I missed it.

So No BZ. What the heck happened? I read the thread yesterday, then now it's gone.

Yeah, it was a mess.

Last thing I remember was seeing the score of 5-5, and wonder how anyone could have voted for anything based on a whole lot of nothing.. 😮

Originally posted by darthgoober
Yup... Guess I should wait a while and let things cool off all around before I reissue the challenge 😂

Back on topic....

Surfer wins a definitive majority in a typical forum match with weakness exploitation as an option. Better ranged game, way more offensive options, way better defensive options, and closer to Clark in the couple areas in which Supes has an edge than vice versa.

I agree. But let me say this.
Being more versatile or having more options could be a negative.
It can lead to a slower decisions in battle since one would need more time to think about which option to do. In a real fight against peers then there is hardly any time to think but only react. I would take 4 very effective powers over 100 different powers where I have to spend extra time trying to decide what to do.

As a pseudo explanation of why Surfer mostly blasts and maneuvers and doesn't use no where near all his powers is because he's in a real battle situation where there is hardly any time to think. Also, he simply doesn't think about every power every time he fights. He thinks blast first. Given more time or against much slower opponents he has more time to think through all his powers. Study long, study wrong and Surfer is hammered.

This fight is closer than most people think. It's still Surfer's fight to lose. But there exist good arguments why Superman should win.

Originally posted by h1a8
I agree. But let me say this.
Being more versatile or having more options could be a negative.
It can lead to a slower decisions in battle since one would need more time to think about which option to do. In a real fight against peers then there is hardly any time to think but only react. I would take 4 very effective powers over 100 different powers where I have to spend extra time trying to decide what to do.

As a pseudo explanation of why Surfer mostly blasts and maneuvers and doesn't use no where near all his powers is because he's in a real battle situation where there is hardly any time to think. Also, he simply doesn't think about every power every time he fights. He thinks blast first. Given more time or against much slower opponents he has more time to think through all his powers. Study long, study wrong and Surfer is hammered.

This fight is closer than most people think. It's still Surfer's fight to lose. But there exist good arguments why Superman should win.


Think about what you're suggesting for a sec. Would you say that in a h2h fight between the two that Karate Kid knowing more moves than Shang Chi would in any way be a negative or give Shang any kind of edge? And I know that you're giving Surfer the win so don't think I'm trying to actually trying to argue here, l'm just addressing that one specific point because it seems a little... Off.

Originally posted by ODG
Silver Surfer 7/10.