Originally posted by carver9fighting is like chess. You always see better moves and mistakes after the fight. Super speed cancels out super reflexes. Surfer and Superman fighting will resemble two humans fighting in both their own minds (not ours).
Lol...I can understand if you were talking about two humans that were fighting but these are super humans. They shouldn't have a problem determining whatever attack they want to use during any given moment. Surfer can phase if he wants and think of any attack he should or could do while Superman sat there and swung at him. Or he could ya know, create a force field around his body which would again, give him time to come up with a strategy. This is IF we want to go by the idea that these beings can't think of attacks on the fly. Especially when Surfer has his cosmic awareness that could aid him in his next moves.
Surfer doesn't think like that. He's more inclined to blast as his main offensive weapon because he believes it will be very effective. Why try to think of other powers when a simple blast will do the trick. Superman could go intangible too or sing Surfer out of existence, but that's not going to take here with most debaters.
Surfer definitely will employ shields though. It's fair to say that he will never use phasing in battle against a peer, since he never has and since it may not be practical (might take a second or more to achieve, which is an eternity).
Problem with cosmic awareness is that it doesn't aid him in his next moves in the actual comics. Otherwise he wouldn't do billions of stupid shit all the time. He is a known jobber.