Classic Defenders Vs Classic Avengers

Started by Accel5 pages

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Yes, at his highest showings, go figure. Your claiming that it happens on average.

Because it is. One instance of him being knocked out by a bomb vs several instances where he’s shown to take much more devastating explosions without being hurt.

Golly gee, I wonder which feats hold more ground?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Tony just stuns him with the repulsors and K.O.'s him like he did before.

Except he’s shown the inability to stun Hulk with his blasts, even when he shot Hulk in the face before.

Apparently, airplane explosion > Iron Man’s repulsors

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
all of which you exaggerated and ignore Hulks lows in favor of his ridiculously high end feats.

Hulk clapping away a cosmos is a ridiculously hig-end feat.

Hulk withstanding every thing Iron Man can throw at him and then some, that’s an average showing for him.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
I haven't ignored anything, versus you using red herrings (Current comics) and ignoring Hulks low ends.

-Because you keep digging his highest feats 🙂


Because his highest feats greatly dwarf his low ones in terms of quantity. For every instance you can list where he’s taken out by something insignificant, I can list at least a few instances where he’s taken far worse.

Consistency isn’t a hard concept, so you should be able to understand it eventually.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-He could do it again as long as he has the strength. He could stun him with a Magnetic repulsor and K.O. him

Except the magnetic repulsors didn’t stun. They just spun him around. There’s a difference.
And all Hulk has to do is thunderclap him away at that point, since you have yet to prove he can’t even move his limbs, much less just use his strength to resist the field in the first place.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Yes, because that is the only real one on one confrontation they've had.

So all the times Iron Man has proved useless, even with back up, he’s just been playing around, right?

The douche. He could have saved a lot of property damage if he could simply pull out the one-shot KO in any of those other confrontations.

Originally posted by Accel
Except that it clearly weakened Hulk by putting him in a daze in the first place. That much is obvious.

No, it did not, his durability did not magically decrease simply because he was stunned. That makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. 😬

He was simply stunned, he got punched. . .The End.

Originally posted by Accel

What you continue to fail to realize is that Hulk being so dazed that even Iron man can knock him out doesn’t make any sense when regarding the multiple times he hasn’t been phased by such things in the past.

It makes no sense because you keep reffering to his high end feats and ignore his averages. Besides Iron Man could simply stunn him with Magnetic repulsors or his chest Tractor Beam.

Originally posted by Accel

Iron Man couldn’t do any thing to Hulk in any of those scenarios. He couldn’t even do any harm by spinning him around in the air.

Which scenario's?

Avengers #1: He doesn't even have said abilities Yet.

Avengers #3: He does it.

Avengers# 5: The Avengers were on a mission when they were ambushed by Hulk. That skirmish did not last too long, anway.

Fantastic Four #26: Everybody kept getting in each others way.

Originally posted by Accel

What makes you think Hulk’s going to beaten like that? He’ll get dizzy and forfeit?

He'll get dizzy and punched just like before.

Originally posted by Accel

For that matter, what makes you think he couldn’t just thunderclap Tony away?

Of course he could, I never said he couldn't. But, more than likely Tony will see it coming. He isn't a half a brain like Hulk.

Originally posted by Accel

There was nothing to indicate he couldn’t move his limbs and he’s resisted force fields from cosmic beings like Stranger and villains like Doom.

1. That's not a force field.

2. When he's shown the ability to resist it, then we can argue that tangent.

Originally posted by Accel

And yet, in none of those instances was Iron Man able to do any thing. At all.

Even spinning him in the air isn’t any thing that’s shown it could keep Hulk from simply thunderclapping Tony away.

This is the most contradicting and ridiculous statement you've posted so far. How is completely immobilizing your opponent "nothing"? Hulk is a sitting duck, he couldn't do anything. Furthermore, if he could, it would take time. Tony can do the same punch by then.

Also, the avengers subdued Hulk.

What are you arguing here, your telling me The Hulk could solo the Avengers and the Fantastic Four?

Originally posted by Accel

And for every one of those, I could list at least 3-4 instances where he takes those kinds of attacks unphased, so why bring them up as if they’re more consistent than his high showings?

Because this isn't CBR, we do not only debate the highest of the highest showings. We take averages and factor them out. Hulks high-end feats are not averages. Otherwise, how does he lose to the leader and Gorgon? Your just basically asking us to pick the highest feats that make Hulk looks good, disregard everything else, and form a conclusion.

Originally posted by Accel

And you seem to only bring up Iron Man’s only real victory while I have brought up three instances in the past where he couldn’t do any thing to Hulk, even when fighting in a group and one instance in the last decade (where Tony’s armor is even stronger than before) where, once again, Tony couldn’t do any thing.

Because you seem to have your own perceptions of what a victory is?
Did Hulk K.O. or defeat Iron Man other then in Avengers #1? Was Tony even unable to fight really, No? Furthermore, if Tony stands no chance against Hulk, why was Hulk never able to One-Shot him?

Besides, he only fought Hulk for a few panels during their later brawls and the Hulk was subdued? Hulk never kept Tony down ever again afterwards, ever.

Originally posted by Accel

…says the guy who apparently thinks that Ant-Man can beat Namor.

Excuse me if I don’t trust your judgment on respective strength levels.

Nice red herring, you must be really desperate sweetie. 🙂

Originally posted by Accel

Except he still has a losing record against Hulk. In brute strength, Hulk’s proven to be his superior.

Stop the presses, Hulk stronger than Iron Man. . .really? 😆

Of course he's stronger in brute strength, did I say otherwise?

His win record does not shock me, since he can reach higher levels of strength. But, none of those can really be attributed to regular Hulk. He onlly stopped Tony once in his very first armour.

Originally posted by Accel

And if a guy who lifted the Midgard Serpent and far, far stronger than Tony couldn’t knock out Hulk while using an enchanted blunt weapon, then what makes you think that Tony doing it makes any sense whatsoever.

Tony's beaten Thor 2/3 times and the third time he held his own and only lost because he was weakened.

Originally posted by Accel

The only time he’s ever beaten the Hulk was in their first fight, when Abomination was far stronger than even the likes of Thor (until his strength was sapped to half it’s original level).

He's beaten Hulk several times, are you serious?!

Originally posted by Accel

Since then, the only time he’s ever been able to replicate it was when his strength returned to normal and Hulk still managed to take his pounding and get back up.
Originally posted by Accel

Not unlesss you go by Spider-Man’s ranking it’s not. You know, the same ranking where Surfer was rather low and even Iron Man says he can’t stay in the top ranking for more than two seconds.

Since was surfer a physical power house?

I believe it was five seconds, but that's enough time to K.O. the Hulk.

Originally posted by Accel

But, hey, let’s just play with your notion that Iron Man is top-tier in strength. So is Thor. So is Hercules. So is Wonder Man.

Then there’s Sasquatch, Wendigo, Namor, Drax the Destroyer, Juggernaut, etc.

Guess how many of them have knocked out Hulk with pure brute force and without resorting to water tricks or trickery.

Virtually most of them, and Hulk is only Higher because his strength is variable. Otherwise, why else does he struggle against them so much?

Originally posted by Accel

“Hulk been shown on multiple occasions to take nukes without being harmed.”

“He’s also been KOed by lightning before, so his average is an ordinary bomb should knock him out.”

…….

Do you not see the ass-backwards logic in your reasoning? If Hulk’s shown to take high-level detonations multiple times consistently, then they must all just be high showings. If he’s beaten by single bomb on one occasion, that must be the standard to rate his durability.

But, he has not, he has not shown to be able to take nukes on a regular basis. Furthermore, his strength is variable. . .what are you arguing?

You honestly believe that a baseline Hulk can Take a nuke?

Originally posted by Accel

And of course if Iron Man has failed to down Hulk in about a dozen fights, then it’s just low showings. But is he manages to finally KO Hulk just once, then it must be where his strength level is at.

Too bad I did not say that, never once stated that Iron-Man average is instantlly being Able to K.O. the Hulk. But, since he's K.O.ed: Thor, beat Namor, Giant man, and Hurt surfer.

Why can't he hurt the Hulk?

Originally posted by Accel

It’s a little late to try and act high and mighty now when you’ve just resorted to a lame attempt to throw my own insult back at me.

Because I mocking you immaturity, obviously.

Originally posted by Accel

Then clearly you don’t know Wrecker. He’s held his own against the likes of Hercules and Thor multiple times .

And, So, has a weakened Iron Man. Regular Iron Man has defeated Thor twice before. Your saying wrecker is stronger than him? barker

Originally posted by Accel

Heck, even in the issue where you note he knocked out Hulk is the very same issue where the Wrecking Crew took out Strange. If you believe Strange being taken out to be PIS, then you must believe Wrecker knocking Hulk out to be PIS as well.

Fallacy of division, Is Hulk Dr.Strange?

Originally posted by Accel

Because they hold no weight in your pointless argument. Tony’s not going to bring lightning into the vicinity like Black Bolt did. He isn’t going to drown Hulk like Namor did. He’s not going to pound Hulk almost to death like Abomination has.

Iron Man cannot Fly Hulk into a water source?

He can immobilizes him with Magnetic repulsors or his tractor Beam.

Originally posted by Accel

Good for him. Not that it’s ever done him any good.
Laser blasts? Hulk’s already shrugged them off. Multiple times.

Magnetic Repulsors? All they’ve done is give Hulk a little joy ride that he could simply stop with a thunderclap.

Punching? Ineffective barring one instance where Tony was only able to do so with a cheap shot and it still nearly cost him his life.

Magnetic Repulsors will stun him long enough for Iron Man to finish him off

They were effective enough for Hulk to view him as a threat. Furthermore, Iron Man has the strength to boot.

Originally posted by Accel

What, that every one has low showings? These still don’t even come close to overshadowing Hulk’s higher showings, so they still hold no weight whatsoever to your dim-witted attempts to make Hulk appear Thing-level.

Why should they, did I say Iron Man>Hulk?

Originally posted by Accel

Never said he was owned, but he couldn’t take her down. In their first clash, it was made clear she could easily break open his armor. When Rogue absorbed Jen’s powers, it was shown Tony’s blasts didn’t even hurt her, so what do you expect them to do to Hulk?

ORLY?

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v282/Ironboy/iron%20man/ContestofChampions_02_22.jpg

Originally posted by Accel

We’re not debating Pre-Crisis characters here buddy.

And you never specified just how “classic” you want this. Even a comic that took place nearly ten years ago can be considered “classic.”

Ah, yes, clearly you know what he can do.

Classic as in pre mordern era and wikipedia=fail.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Too bad I did not say that, never once stated that Iron-Man average is instantlly being Able to K.O. the Hulk. But, since he's K.O.ed: Thor, beat Namor, Giant man, and Hurt surfer.

Why can't he hurt the Hulk?

Because Hulk happens to have an insane healing factor and has resisted attacks from people with much higher strength and energy out-put than IronMan in the past.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Iron Man cannot Fly Hulk into a water source?

He could but since Hulk doesn't need air anymore it would just piss him off.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
He can immobilizes him with Magnetic repulsors or his tractor Beam.

And then get hit by a thunderclap.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Magnetic Repulsors will stun him long enough for Iron Man to finish him off

Magnets don't drop his durability or HF though.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
They were effective enough for Hulk to view him as a threat. Furthermore, Iron Man has the strength to boot.

The strength needed to put down Hulk? He really doesn't when you consider the people that Hulk has tangled with.

Originally posted by Accel
Because it is. One instance of him being knocked out by a bomb vs several instances where he’s shown to take much more devastating explosions without being hurt.

What are these several instances you can never scan?
Are they from his respect thread which is High-End feats only?

Originally posted by Accel

Except he’s shown the inability to stun Hulk with his blasts, even when he shot Hulk in the face before.

Apparently, airplane explosion > Iron Man’s repulsors

Which instance are these?

Originally posted by Accel

Hulk withstanding every thing Iron Man can throw at him and then some, that’s an average showing for him.

Yet, his career villain has constantly deployed plastic men who pwn the Hulk with brute strength? Also, saying Iron Man cannot hrt the Hulk is false.

Originally posted by Accel

Because his highest feats greatly dwarf his low ones in terms of quantity. For every instance you can list where he’s taken out by something insignificant, I can list at least a few instances where he’s taken far worse.

At the highest levels of strength, though. Which one happens more often:

Hulk is K.O.ed by Plastic men or Hit by nukes and is not phased?

Originally posted by Accel

Consistency isn’t a hard concept, so you should be able to understand it eventually.

none of his high end feats are consistent, otherwise he should never be able to be injured by nukes.

Originally posted by Accel

Except the magnetic repulsors didn’t stun. They just spun him around. There’s a difference.

Pedantic drivel, he could not move and that's what counts.

Originally posted by Accel

And all Hulk has to do is thunderclap him away at that point, since you have yet to prove he can’t even move his limbs, much less just use his strength to resist the field in the first place.

Can't prove a negative, fail.

Originally posted by Accel

So all the times Iron Man has proved useless, even with back up, he’s just been playing around, right?

The douche. He could have saved a lot of property damage if he could simply pull out the one-shot KO in any of those other confrontations.

Or because the writers wanted to make a dramatic fight, Do you read comics? Why do you think Thor's fights in the avengers make no sense.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Because Hulk happens to have an insane healing factor and has resisted attacks from people with much higher strength and energy out-put than IronMan in the past.

And, has been K.O.ed by less, what's your point?

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos

He could but since Hulk doesn't need air anymore it would just piss him off.

This is classic, though.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos

Magnets don't drop his durability or HF though.

Doesn't have to, that punch will work all the same.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos

The strength needed to put down Hulk? He really doesn't when you consider the people that Hulk has tangled with.

Same can be said for Iron Man. Name one person Hulk has beaten that Iron Man cannot?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
And, has been K.O.ed by less, what's your point?

It usually takes more.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
This is classic, though.

'Kay. I admit that will make it much easier for IM.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Doesn't have to, that punch will work all the same.

I disagree. IM has never oneshotted someone like Hulk to my knowledge.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Same can be said for Iron Man. Name one person Hulk has beaten that Iron Man cannot?

Dormmamu 😏

But there is the Asgardian destroyer under Maestro's control. He took on one of the Elders IIRC.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
It usually takes more.

I know it does, I never even said Iron Man would win. Hulk would defeat him around 8-7/10. I'm just saying he stands a chance against him, that's all.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos

'Kay. I admit that will make it much easier for IM.

Of course, Iron Man cannot defeat WW Hulk.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos

I disagree. IM has never oneshotted someone like Hulk to my knowledge.

I don't think either one can one-shot the other. Unless Hulk is at his highest levels.

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos

Dormmamu 😏

😆 Yeah, remember when he beat mephisto?

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos

But there is the Asgardian destroyer under Maestro's control. He took on one of the Elders IIRC.

Elders seem to have problems with everyone, which is weird.

Asgardian destroyer, well, it's possible with current Hulks strength.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
No, it did not, his durability did not magically decrease simply because he was stunned. That makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. 😬

Of course it doesn’t make any sense, but that seems to be the case.

Which is why, yet again, it was inconsistent.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
It makes no sense because you keep reffering to his high end feats and ignore his averages. Besides Iron Man could simply stunn him with Magnetic repulsors or his chest Tractor Beam.

And you keep ignoring that on average, Iron Man has proved to be ineffective against Hulk. Magnetic repulsors? They didn’t hurt Hulk. They didn’t stun him. All they did was lift him up and throw him around, which says nothing that he couldn’t simply move his arms and thunderclap, as there’s nothing to indicate whatsoever that Iron Man’s magnetism is stronger than an Stranger’s field.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Which scenario's?

Avengers #1: He doesn't even have said abilities Yet.

Avengers #3: He does it.

Avengers# 5: The Avengers were on a mission when they were ambushed by Hulk. That skirmish did not last too long, anway.

Fantastic Four #26: Everybody kept getting in each others way.


And in none of those times does Iron Man do any real damage. At all.

In case you’ve forgotten in the split-second between reading this part of my response and the last part, no damage was done whatsoever Tony applied his magnetic repulsors. All he could do was spin Hulk around, which won’t prevent Hulk from simply thunderclapping him away.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Of course he could, I never said he couldn't. But, more than likely Tony will see it coming. He isn't a half a brain like Hulk.

Except he won’t be able to simply avoid it. It’s a shockwave that spreads out and damages every thing in its path.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
1. That's not a force field.

2. When he's shown the ability to resist it, then we can argue that tangent.


He’s already shown the strength to resist a simply magnetic field.

Come back when you’ve proven that Iron Man’s magnetic repulsors are stronger than any thing Hulk’s managed to overcome before.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
This is the most contradicting and ridiculous statement you've posted so far. How is completely immobilizing your opponent "nothing"? Hulk is a sitting duck, he couldn't do anything. Furthermore, if he could, it would take time. Tony can do the same punch by then.

Because it doesn’t do any damage whatsoever. This is the third time I’m stating this in this post alone, so it should be getting through your head by this point.

Was Hulk hurt? No. Stunned? Nope.

Could he have simply applauded Tony’s efforts? Sure.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Because this isn't CBR, we do not only debate the highest of the highest showings. We take averages and factor them out. Hulks high-end feats are not averages. Otherwise, how does he lose to the leader and Gorgon? Your just basically asking us to pick the highest feats that make Hulk looks good, disregard everything else, and form a conclusion.

We don’t debate highest feats either. We go by consistency.

And Hulk’s history has shown us that he consistently takes more punishment than Iron Man can dish out. Naturally, there’s going to be an inconsistency every now and then, but they’re ignored because they’re inconsistent. It’s why we know not to take every instance that Flash has been hit by a boomerang to take away from the fact that he’s consistently shown to move at light-speed; or that Superman being knocked out by a gas station exploding doesn’t take away that he can take consistently take insane amount of punishment; or that Green Lanterns having trouble with Deathstroke doesn’t take away that they consistently handle planetary and even universal-level threats; or…

Same for Hulk. He’s consistently shown the ability to take devastating explosions, hundreds of thousands of volts of electricity, and punches from Class 100 characters and shrug them off. The fact that he has a low showing doesn’t take any thing from that.

Do you understand? Consistency of feats does not equal averaging feats.

I could link you to a dictionary if you’re not following all this.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Because you seem to have your own perceptions of what a victory is?
Did Hulk K.O. or defeat Iron Man other then in Avengers #1? Was Tony even unable to fight really, No? Furthermore, if Tony stands no chance against Hulk, why was Hulk never able to One-Shot him?

Besides, he only fought Hulk for a few panels during their later brawls and the Hulk was subdued? Hulk never kept Tony down ever again afterwards, ever.


Mainly because Tony almost always fought with a group. Not like Hulk deliberately tries to take down Iron Man first when the Avengers attack him.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-Thor Should be able to whoop Hulks butt, and a mind controlled Thor attacked a weaken tony before. He managed to Hold his own just fine.

Originally posted by Accel
Except he still has a losing record against Hulk. In brute strength, Hulk’s proven to be his superior. And if a guy who lifted the Midgard Serpent and far, far stronger than Tony couldn’t knock out Hulk while using an enchanted blunt weapon, then what makes you think that Tony doing it makes any sense whatsoever.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Stop the presses, Hulk stronger than Iron Man. . .really? 😆

Of course he's stronger in brute strength, did I say otherwise?

His win record does not shock me, since he can reach higher levels of strength. But, none of those can really be attributed to regular Hulk. He onlly stopped Tony once in his very first armour.

Reading comprehension is your friend...

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
He's beaten Hulk several times, are you serious?!

Barring the two times he was restored to his original level, name even one occasion where Abomination beats the green Hulk in fisticuffs.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Since was surfer a physical power house?

😐

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
I believe it was five seconds, but that's enough time to K.O. the Hulk.

Even though it wasn’t for Thor? Or Hercules? Or the Asgardian Destroyer? Or Juggernaut? Or… ?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Virtually most of them

Then you’d be wrong, which seems to be a pattern.

The correct answer is none.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
But, he has not, he has not shown to be able to take nukes on a regular basis. Furthermore, his strength is variable. . .what are you arguing?

You honestly believe that a baseline Hulk can Take a nuke?


He’s shown the ability to take nukes far more than he’s shown the ability to not take a nuke and he’s done it far more than he’s been beaten by “plastic men.”

Again, consistency.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Too bad I did not say that, never once stated that Iron-Man average is instantlly being Able to K.O. the Hulk. But, since he's K.O.ed: Thor, beat Namor, Giant man, and Hurt surfer.

Why can't he hurt the Hulk?


Because, contrary to what you would love to believe, Iron Man taking out Thor and Surfer ARE high showings and aren’t consistent with the amount of damage that those two have shown to be able to take.

Not to mention, out of all of those listed, only Surfer is more durable than Hulk and none of them have a significant healing factor.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Because I mocking you immaturity, obviously.

No fooling? oh

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
And, So, has a weakened Iron Man. Regular Iron Man has defeated Thor twice before. Your saying wrecker is stronger than him? barker

And one of Wrecker’s Men took out Dr. Strange before. You’re saying Iron Man’s stronger than them?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Fallacy of division, Is Hulk Dr.Strange?

Doesn’t matter. It’s no use citing a comic issue to prove a point, only to call that very same issue PIS.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Iron Man cannot Fly Hulk into a water source?

He can immobilizes him with Magnetic repulsors or his tractor Beam.


You do realize Hulk can swim right? And that’s assuming that Hulk just sits around and lets him carry him instead of thunderclapping.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Magnetic Repulsors will stun him long enough for Iron Man to finish him off

Correction, you mean spin him around until he gets bored and takes Tony out with a thunderclap.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
They were effective enough for Hulk to view him as a threat. Furthermore, Iron Man has the strength to boot.

Good for Tony.

Hulk views every one as a threat. He’s viewed Spider-Man and Wolverine as threats before.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
ORLY?

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v282/Ironboy/iron%20man/ContestofChampions_02_22.jpg


Yeah.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Classic as in pre mordern era and wikipedia=fail.

The wikipedia article was there to inform you on who Captain Marvel was, since you made it clear you didn’t know who “he” was.

And a comic from eight years ago ain’t exactly modern.

Originally posted by Accel
-Of course it doesn’t make any sense, but that seems to be the case. Which is why, yet again, it was inconsistent.

-And you keep ignoring that on average, Iron Man has proved to be ineffective against Hulk.

-Magnetic repulsors? They didn’t hurt Hulk. They didn’t stun him. All they did was lift him up and throw him around.

- which says nothing that he couldn’t simply move his arms and thunderclap, as there’s nothing to indicate whatsoever that Iron Man’s magnetism is stronger than an Stranger’s field.

-Come back when you’ve proven that Iron Man’s magnetic repulsors are stronger than any thing Hulk’s managed to overcome before.

-And, it never happened. Hulk's durability never changed, that's your conjecture which isn't supported by any real facts other how you feel the fight should have went down. Iron Man has proven throughout his career that he has the strength to match the Hulk and he has been tiered as such. The only instances you can bring up are huge skirmishes that archaic.

-We went over this already, the only instance he was ineffective was when he lost in Avengers #1. He subdued him in Avenger#3, that's pretty effective in a fight. The only viable ones left are Avengers #5 and Fantastic Four #26. . .What particular instance are you referring too in said comics?
When Iron Man and the avengers caught Hulk in a "Dog Pile", be specific. Your simply spouting vague examples, which causes your Logic to fail.

-Why do they have to hurt him for? Does pain dictate effectiveness in a bout? The whole point of a fight is stop your enemy from being able to fight back. If Hulk was able to fight back, I want you too show me the scan of him doing so. Either way, he was a sitting duck and the Burden of Proof falls on you since you made the claim.

-Your right, nothing suggest that Iron Man field is stronger than the Strangers and Vice Verser. Lack of evidence is not evidence, just as Black is not white. Besides, why should I provide proof of anything? Does it have to be stronger, it held him right? So, it's effective since it was able to hold the Hulk. Once he does it, he can finish him off with that punch of his.

Originally posted by Accel

Except he won’t be able to simply avoid it. It’s a shockwave that spreads out and damages every thing in its path.

I never said he would avoid it, read again. He would Stop Hulk from clapping his hands with his field.

Originally posted by Accel

-We don’t debate highest feats either. We go by consistency.
And Hulk’s history has shown us that he consistently takes more punishment than Iron Man can dish out.

- Naturally, there’s going to be an inconsistency every now and then, but they’re ignored because they’re inconsistent.

-It’s why we know not to take every instance that Flash has been hit by a boomerang to take away from the fact that he’s consistently shown to move at light-speed; or that Superman being knocked out by a gas station exploding doesn’t take away that he can take consistently take insane amount of punishment; or that Green Lanterns having trouble with Deathstroke doesn’t take away that they consistently handle planetary and even universal-level threats; or…

-Same for Hulk. He’s [b]consistently shown the ability to take devastating explosions, hundreds of thousands of volts of electricity, and punches from Class 100 characters and shrug them off. The fact that he has a low showing doesn’t take any thing from that. [/B]

-Well, of course it has. Is his strength no dependent on his temperament?
That does not change the fact that Hulk's history has shown us that he is susceptible to a myriad forms of damage more so at certain points in his transformation. At bare minimum, Iron Man has displayed the ability to hurt people who are on Hulks class and The Hulk himself. Your claiming that Iron Mans attacks are not effective against the Hulk. Then, please post some scans. Show us these useless attacks. Because, if memory serves me right. You said the same about She-Hulk.

-Amazing, So, these consistency's can only be seen by you? Is that the reason why you've Copy & Pasted Hulks highest, while completely ignored his lows? Both are necessary to factor a characters average, my friend?
So, where is your explanation for Leaders (Hulks arch enemy) defeating the Hulk several times over? It wasn't because of Nukes, High-Level explosives or Space Rays. Just basic robots, and mutants. You've never even acknowledge them.

-Most of those feats do not come from Supermans arch-enemy, though. Same with the others, and neither do they rival his highs. You claimed they do not, So, where is the descriptions of these moments?

Originally posted by Accel

Mainly because Tony almost always fought with a group. Not like Hulk deliberately tries to take down Iron Man first when the Avengers attack him.

Yes, and the writer showcases each group member evenly. Besides, Tony subdued him with Magnetic Repulsors, which you purposely ignore.

Originally posted by Accel

😐

😐

Originally posted by Accel

Even though it wasn’t for Thor? Or Hercules? Or the Asgardian Destroyer? Or Juggernaut? Or… ?

Then you’d be wrong, which seems to be a pattern.

The correct answer is none.

-Juggernaut has K.O'ed Hulk.
-Thor fights are always stalemates versus iron Man who defeated Thor Twice.
-Destroyer is nothing more than PIS

Originally posted by Accel
He’s shown the ability to take nukes far more than he’s shown the ability to not take a nuke and he’s done it far more than he’s been beaten by “plastic men.”

Again, consistency.

He's lost to plastic men and Robots at minimum of over five times. How many times has he Taken a nuke, again no evidence is provided. Here's my evidence though:

Tales to Astonish #60

Maxes Himself out dealing with said bot and he is K.O'ed by a missle in said Issue.

Tales to Astonish #65

Subdue him.

Tales to Astonish #72

They almost Kill him.

Originally posted by Accel

Because, contrary to what you would love to believe, Iron Man taking out Thor and Surfer ARE high showings and aren’t consistent with the amount of damage that those two have shown to be able to take.
Not to mention, out of all of those listed, only Surfer is more durable than Hulk and none of them have a significant healing factor.

Yes, because variable strength has no barring to hulks durability.

Originally posted by Accel

And one of Wrecker’s Men took out Dr. Strange before. You’re saying Iron Man’s stronger than them?

Yes, because they suck. 😬

Originally posted by Accel

Doesn’t matter. . .

If logic doesn't matter, then why should I even bother?

Originally posted by Accel

You do realize Hulk can swim right? And that’s assuming that Hulk just sits around and lets him carry him instead of thunderclapping.

Who cares, once he's in the water. He'll be at a disadvantage versus Iron-Man. Who can out maneuver him easily.

Originally posted by Accel

Good for Tony.

Hulk views every one as a threat. He’s viewed Spider-Man and Wolverine as threats before.

Except, that none of them can hurt him like Tony can.

Originally posted by Accel

Yeah.

Wow, tony knocked down and still functional = a win? Was he K.O.ed like she was?

Originally posted by Accel

The wikipedia article was there to inform you on who Captain Marvel was, since you made it clear you didn’t know who “he” was.

And a comic from eight years ago ain’t exactly modern.

Captain Marvel is a he, unless you count the female version. 😬

Yes, did know he "He" was, but he has not summon lightning. The only Captain Marvel I know that can Summon Lightning is from Dc.

Originally posted by Accel

Reading comprehension is your friend...

hold the phone, when Has Hulk beaten Thor?

Originally posted by Accel

Barring the two times he was restored to his original level, name even one occasion where Abomination beats the green Hulk in fisticuffs.

Why are they barred, You stated that he consistently taken hit from Orignal abomination to no avail.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-And, it never happened. Hulk's durability never changed, that's your conjecture which isn't supported by any real facts other how you feel the fight should have went down. Iron Man has proven throughout his career that he has the strength to match the Hulk and he has been tiered as such. The only instances you can bring up are huge skirmishes that archaic.

The only time Iron Man has been stated to be in Spider-man’s strength ranking.

Go ahead and cite it if you really want to believe it holds any ground, but I guarantee if you do, no one on this board will take your views on respective strength levels seriously.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-We went over this already, the only instance he was ineffective was when he lost in Avengers #1. He subdued him in Avenger#3, that's pretty effective in a fight. The only viable ones left are Avengers #5 and Fantastic Four #26. . .What particular instance are you referring too in said comics?
When Iron Man and the avengers caught Hulk in a "Dog Pile", be specific. Your simply spouting vague examples, which causes your Logic to fail.

Because in all those moments, Tony never once hurt Hulk. The best he did was lift him off the ground, which for some strange reason, you consider to be a victory.

Keep reading then. You’ll see references to plenty of instances that also show his ineffectiveness against Hulk.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-Why do they have to hurt him for? Does pain dictate effectiveness in a bout? The whole point of a fight is stop your enemy from being able to fight back. If Hulk was able to fight back, I want you too show me the scan of him doing so. Either way, he was a sitting duck and the Burden of Proof falls on you since you made the claim.

Because your whole claim that Tony can just take Hulk out with a punch after he lifts him off the ground is both asinine and based of nothing.

Hulk’s not going to be so undertaken by being spun around that all of a sudden Tony can take him out.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
I never said he would avoid it, read again. He would Stop Hulk from clapping his hands with his field.

Based on what? The fact that he was able to spin Hulk in the air? Two things worng with you assumption:

1.) There’s absolutely nothing to indicate Iron Man could freely restrict Hulk’s limbs aside form being able to lift him up.
2.) There’s also nothing to indicate Iron Man’s field is any where near as strong as Vector’s telekinesis (which at one point have even repelled reality away) or even Stranger’s field (which was state dot be able to move a planet), both of which Hulk has overcome in very little time.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-Well, of course it has. Is his strength no dependent on his temperament?
That does not change the fact that Hulk's history has shown us that he is susceptible to a myriad forms of damage more so at certain points in his transformation. At bare minimum, Iron Man has displayed the ability to hurt people who are on Hulks class and The Hulk himself. Your claiming that Iron Mans attacks are not effective against the Hulk. Then, please post some scans. Show us these useless attacks. Because, if memory serves me right. You said the same about She-Hulk.

Oh looky, he doesn’t do any thing here, or here, or here; and even here, it’s noted that he “shrugs off Iron Man’s blasts with ease.”

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
--Amazing, So, these consistency's can only be seen by you? Is that the reason why you've Copy & Pasted Hulks highest, while completely ignored his lows? Both are necessary to factor a characters average, my friend?

I thought I explained this pretty clearly, but apparently you do need to learn the difference between “average” and “consistency.”

It’s not like averaging out test scores. If Hulk consistently has a low showing in a certain area, like say his speed, then we know where his limits are in that area. If he consistently has high feats in a certain area, like say his durability, then we know how powerful he is in that area.

If a character has many more high feats than low feats in a certain area, then those high feats do hold much more ground over the low ones. In this case, for each one of Hulk’s extremely low end feats, I can list several high end feats that overshadow them.

And Hulk’s high end feats, as much as you hate them, have been much more consistent than any of his low end ones.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
So, where is your explanation for Leaders (Hulks arch enemy) defeating the Hulk several times over? It wasn't because of Nukes, High-Level explosives or Space Rays. Just basic robots, and mutants. You've never even acknowledge them.

They’re low end showings that took place in the very beginning of Hulk’s comic career, before any one’s respective strength was established, and are vastly overshadowed by his higher showing later on.

Happy?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-Most of those feats do not come from Supermans arch-enemy, though. Same with the others, and neither do they rival his highs. You claimed they do not, So, where is the descriptions of these moments?

Where the hell are you getting your facts from? Superman’s low end feats only apply if Lex Luthor is behind them?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Yes, and the writer showcases each group member evenly. Besides, Tony subdued him with Magnetic Repulsors, which you purposely ignore.

Poppy Cock.

I’ve pointed out that:

- the magnetic repulsors didn’t hurt, stun, or even Hulk
- there’s nothing to suggest Hulk’s limbs were restricted, only that his body was spinning
- Hulk has resisted forces far stronger than Tony’s magnetic field (Stranger’s field and Vector’s TK) until you can prove Tony’s magnetism is in their league

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-Juggernaut has K.O'ed Hulk.
-Thor fights are always stalemates versus iron Man who defeated Thor Twice.

Juggernaut’s only KOed Hulk by tricking him. If you look at their fight, you’ll notice that Hulk doesn’t even throw a single punch the whole time.

The question:
“Guess how many of them have knocked out Hulk with pure brute force and without resorting to water tricks or trickery.”

The answer:
“None.”

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
He's lost to plastic men and Robots at minimum of over five times. How many times has he Taken a nuke, again no evidence is provided. Here's my evidence though:

Tales to Astonish #60

Maxes Himself out dealing with said bot and he is K.O'ed by a missle in said Issue.

Tales to Astonish #65

Subdue him.

Tales to Astonish #72

They almost Kill him.


Congratulations, you just cited three of Hulk’s first appearances, back when Marvel was still new in the business and its heroes’ abilities weren’t even fully established yet. What’s next, are we going to use Iron Man’s first armor in this fight or something?

Now, we also see Hulk fight Samson for six hours without tiring, stalemate Thor for an hour without maxing out, fought the Living Shadow for 11 hours,

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Yes, because variable strength has no barring to hulks durability.

His strength isn’t so variable that he starts out at mid-tier durability. Even newly transformed, Hulk is top-tier.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Yes, because they suck. 😬

Brilliant logic as always I see…

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
If logic doesn't matter, then why should I even bother?

What’s so logical about citing an issue as evidence one moment only to bar that very same issue as PIS the next moment?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Who cares, once he's in the water. He'll be at a disadvantage versus Iron-Man. Who can out maneuver him easily.

Except Iron Man can’t pull off the same tricks as Namor so it doesn’t matter. And Hulk can simply empty any bodies of water with a thunderclap, which he has already shown to do before.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Except, that none of them can hurt him like Tony can.

You mean like he’s done so many times in the past?

I think Hulk’s more apprehensive of Wolverine’s claws then he is of Iron Man’s blasts.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Wow, tony knocked down and still functional = a win? Was he K.O.ed like she was?

No, it shows his blasts not hurting her. After Rogue absorbs She-Hulk’s strength, Iron man blasts her and you can see the result for yourself in the scan.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Captain Marvel is a he, unless you count the female version. 😬

Yes, did know he "He" was, but he has not summon lightning. The only Captain Marvel I know that can Summon Lightning is from Dc.


😐

http://img.photojerk.com/Jonathanos/IIAB/IH321.jpg
http://img44.echo.cx/img44/5048/avengersih300b5wl.jpg

🙂

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
hold the phone, when Has Hulk beaten Thor?

Into unconsciousness? No, but he has proved his physical superiority in Sub-Marine #35 and Mighty Thor #385. He even demolished the Crypto-Man, which was stated to be even stronger than Thor and Thor was even worried that Hulk could kill him in Incredible Hulk #300.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Why are they barred, You stated that he consistently taken hit from Orignal abomination to no avail.

Good luck quoting me on that. All I’ve said is that original Abomination is far stronger than Iron Man, so citing the instance where he beats Hulk into the ground does absolutely nothing to prove Iron Man can do the same.

I’ve then stated Hulk has taken Abomination’s blows and proceeded to beat the shit out of him, which he has. Several times. And even Abomination at half his original strength I far stronger than Tony.

Originally posted by Accel
-The only time Iron Man has been stated to be in Spider-man’s strength ranking.

Go ahead and cite it if you really want to believe it holds any ground, but I guarantee if you do, no one on this board will take your views on respective strength levels seriously.

-Keep reading then. You’ll see references to plenty of instances that also show his ineffectiveness against Hulk.

-Because your whole claim that Tony can just take Hulk out with a punch after he lifts him off the ground is both asinine and based of nothing.

-Hulk’s not going to be so undertaken by being spun around that all of a sudden Tony can take him out.

-I don't really care of members of some forum do not hold my word. This isn't a popularity contest or High-School. We've seen Iron Man constantly deal with Class 100 hundreds and succeed. Yet, according to you he's not that strong. Your opinion is irrelevant to what has been shown.

-What instances, you mean the ones you do not post. If your making the claim, then the burden of proof is on you. Infact, those comics don't even show any real fights. Fantastic Four #26 had a 2 panel dog pile fight, which attacks of tony's were shown to be ineffective there. . . His bum rushing skills?

-Except that he has lifted him of the floor, and finished him with a punch that will burn out his armor. Or weaken him with several attacks and finish him off.

-Why, because you say so?

Originally posted by Accel

Based on what? The fact that he was able to spin Hulk in the air? Two things worng with you assumption:

1.) There’s absolutely nothing to indicate Iron Man could freely restrict Hulk’s limbs aside form being able to lift him up.
2.) There’s also nothing to indicate Iron Man’s field is any where near as strong as Vector’s telekinesis (which at one point have even repelled reality away) or even Stranger’s field (which was state dot be able to move a planet), both of which Hulk has overcome in very little time.

1) Despite the fact Hulk is spinning like a top and could not escape, and was eventually subdued? If your claiming he could escape, then fine I agree. But, if your claiming that he was not restricted, I would to see some proof besides your unsupported post.

2) Post some scans of this "Very Little" time. Because., I've never seen Hulk bust out a field of that magnitude in mere seconds. Furthermore, the spinning would disorient him and it proves his attack was effective since it caused Hulk to be subdued.

Originally posted by Accel

Oh looky, he doesn’t do any thing here, or here, or here; and even here, it’s noted that he “shrugs off Iron Man’s blasts with ease.”

😆

First Scan:

Even though, the Hulk is shown to be on one knee after the punch?
You call that ineffective, tell me who else can do that in one punch?
Furthermore, Iron Man's one punch failing to K.O. him means all his attacks are ineffective? So, with that logic, if Hulk does not one shot Iron Man, his attacks are ineffective by your logic.

Second Scan: Not regular Hulk, he's been separated by banner and is stronger.

Third Scan: Not Classic, I don't care. . .No post mordern Age comics.

Fourth: Once again, your simple reasoning comes into play. Iron-Man has more then one type of repulsors. If Hulks shrugs it off, that's fine. But, it's funny that the next panel shows Iron Man Knocking down the Hulk. . .so, much for ineffective attacks. You act like unless all of Iron Mans attacks send hulk flying, they are all ineffective.

Originally posted by Accel

-It’s not like averaging out test scores. If Hulk consistently has a low showing in a certain area, like say his speed, then we know where his limits are in that area. If he consistently has high feats in a certain area, like say his durability, then we know how powerful he is in that area.

-If a character has many more high feats than low feats in a certain area, then those high feats do hold much more ground over the low ones. In this case, for each one of Hulk’s extremely low end feats, I can list several high end feats that overshadow them.

-And Hulk’s high end feats, as much as you hate them, have been much more consistent than any of his low end ones.

-Where are these consistent High-end showings. I'm still waiting for them and they are no where to be found. Show me Hulk consistently Taking Nuke level attacks, Like you stated.

-Please list them, I've been asking for them for awhile now. Show me Hulks mass quantity of High-End feats out weighing his low ones.

-According to you, with no scans at all.

Originally posted by Accel

They’re low end showings that took place in the very beginning of Hulk’s comic career, before any one’s respective strength was established, and are vastly overshadowed by his higher showing later on.

That was just to get the ball rolling. I'm still waiting for these vast amount of High-End feats that over shadow his low ends in quantity. We still have him:

-Being K.O.ed by The wrecker
-Being K.O'ed By Doc Samson
-Being hurt By Captain america

Et Cetera. . .I have more, I'm just waiting for you to follow suit. If you cannot then your simply being irrational.

Originally posted by Accel

Where the hell are you getting your facts from? Superman’s low end feats only apply if Lex Luthor is behind them?

Superman is the most inconsistent character in comics, he has no barring in this thread

Originally posted by Accel

Poppy Cock.

I’ve pointed out that:

- the magnetic repulsors didn’t hurt, stun, or even Hulk
- there’s nothing to suggest Hulk’s limbs were restricted, only that his body was spinning
- Hulk has resisted forces far stronger than Tony’s magnetic field (Stranger’s field and Vector’s TK) until you can prove Tony’s magnetism is in their league

And, I've countered:

-They do not have to hurt him, they subdued him.

-Except the fact that he was subdued

-Doesn't have to be, I never said it would Hold. It would just restrain him long enough for him to be K.O.ed by that super punch. If Thor Had time

Originally posted by Accel

Juggernaut’s only KOed Hulk by tricking him. If you look at their fight, you’ll notice that Hulk doesn’t even throw a single punch the whole time.

The question:
“Guess how many of them have knocked out Hulk with pure brute force and [b]without
resorting to water tricks or trickery.”

The answer:
“None.” [/B]

What "Trickery" did the wrecker use?

Juggernaut cuaght him by suprise, that's all. . . Besides, Juggy>Hulk.

Abomination steam rolled the Hulk, Banner had to use a machine to weaken him. That's the only reason why the Hulk won.

Originally posted by Accel
Congratulations, you just cited three of Hulk’s first appearances, back when Marvel was still new in the business and its heroes’ abilities weren’t even fully established yet. What’s next, are we going to use Iron Man’s first armor in this fight or something?

Oh, you mean like how you cited Avengers #1 where Iron Man had has original armor?

Originally posted by Accel

Now, we also see Hulk fight Samson for six hours without tiring, stalemate Thor for an hour without maxing out, fought the Living Shadow for 11 hours,

Samson's K.O.ed the Hulk and Iron Man's beaten Thor, something Hulk has not done.

Originally posted by Accel

His strength isn’t so variable that he starts out at mid-tier durability. Even newly transformed, Hulk is top-tier.

What a joke, at baseline he's class 70.

Originally posted by Accel

Brilliant logic as always I see…

You don't even use logic, when I pointed out a logic fallacy. You stated: "You didn't care."

Originally posted by Accel

What’s so logical about citing an issue as evidence one moment only to bar that very same issue as PIS the next moment?

Because it's a fallacy of division, Strange is not Hulk. But, using your logic:

http://img462.imageshack.us/img462/6127/avengersih11a9zo.jpg

This scan is PIS completely, because Captain America's shield hurt Hulk when Iron Man's repulsors could not. 🙂

Originally posted by Accel

Except Iron Man can’t pull off the same tricks as Namor so it doesn’t matter. And Hulk can simply empty any bodies of water with a thunderclap, which he has already shown to do before.

Or, Tractor Beam and Magnetic Repulsor underwater until Hulk drowns.

Originally posted by Accel

You mean like he’s done so many times in the past?

I think Hulk’s more apprehensive of Wolverine’s claws then he is of Iron Man’s blasts.

Yeah, like when he K.O.ed him with that Super Punch or had him on one knee.

Originally posted by Accel

No, it shows his blasts not hurting her. After Rogue absorbs She-Hulk’s strength, Iron man blasts her and you can see the result for yourself in the scan.

Once again I ask, are all repulsors the same?
I just showed you him one shotting her and now you show me a scan of someone with her powers being okay to prove that she could take his blast? Is Jen now rougue, you've done this several times now.

Originally posted by Accel

http://img.photojerk.com/Jonathanos/IIAB/IH321.jpg
http://img44.echo.cx/img44/5048/avengersih300b5wl.jpg

🙂


Hulk being electrocuted is not being hurt?
Furthermore, that's not regular Hulk. . .

Balckbolt hit Hulk with hundreds of Lightning bolts which is why he was K.O.ed.

Originally posted by Accel

Into unconsciousness? No, but he has proved his physical superiority in Sub-Marine #35 and Mighty Thor #385. He even demolished the Crypto-Man, which was stated to be even stronger than Thor and Thor was even worried that Hulk could kill him in Incredible Hulk #300.

Which is why he could never defeat Thor, right? Even though Iron Man has, Twice.

Originally posted by Accel

Good luck quoting me on that. All I’ve said is that original Abomination is far stronger than Iron Man, so citing the instance where he beats Hulk into the ground does absolutely nothing to prove Iron Man can do the same.

I’ve then stated Hulk has taken Abomination’s blows and proceeded to beat the shit out of him, which he has. Several times. And even Abomination at half his original strength I far stronger than Tony.

Originally posted by Accel

Then you have the fact that people like Thor, Hercules, Thing, Wonder Man, Abomination, Bi-Beast, and many other people who pack far more raw power than Iron Man have pounded on Hulk to no avail on multiple occasions.

So, said punches never had effect on Hulk?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-I don't really care of members of some forum do not hold my word. This isn't a popularity contest or High-School. We've seen Iron Man constantly deal with Class 100 hundreds and succeed. Yet, according to you he's not that strong. Your opinion is irrelevant to what has been shown.

No, it’s not a popularity contest. It’s a forum filled with individuals who are far more knowledgeable in comics than you are. Ask any one and they’ll gladly point out to you why Surfer being in the same ranking as Spider-Man alone proves the fallacy of using that rating as proof of any thing.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-What instances, you mean the ones you do not post. If your making the claim, then the burden of proof is on you. Infact, those comics don't even show any real fights. Fantastic Four #26 had a 2 panel dog pile fight, which attacks of tony's were shown to be ineffective there. . . His bum rushing skills?

His so-called physical might if you will…

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-Except that he has lifted him of the floor, and finished him with a punch that will burn out his armor. Or weaken him with several attacks and finish him off.

Except you continually forget three important factors:

1.)Lifting Hulk off the ground and spinning him around doesn’t weaken him in any way, nor does it mean any one else’s attacks will all of a sudden hurt him a lot more than they previously would have.
2.)Hulk won’t weakening from Iron Man’s attacks because of his healing factor.
3.)Hulk will undoubtedly get more pissed off, thus getting stronger, more durable, more damage resistant, and more likely to take Tony out with a thunderclap.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-Why, because you say so?

No, common sense does.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
1) Despite the fact Hulk is spinning like a top and could not escape, and was eventually subdued? If your claiming he could escape, then fine I agree. But, if your claiming that he was not restricted, I would to see some proof besides your unsupported post.

2) Post some scans of this "Very Little" time. Because., I've never seen Hulk bust out a field of that magnitude in mere seconds. Furthermore, the spinning would disorient him and it proves his attack was effective since it caused Hulk to be subdued.


I don’t need to prove any thing. You’re claiming that Iron Man could restrict Hulk’s limbs are based on what, the fact that he could lift him up using the iron in his blood and spin him around?

Nothing about that exactly screams “Master of Magnetism.”

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
😆

First Scan:

Even though, the Hulk is shown to be on one knee after the punch?
You call that ineffective, tell me who else can do that in one punch?


On one knee, but totally unharmed. Yeah, I bet Hulk was shaking in his shorts right there.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Furthermore, Iron Man's one punch failing to K.O. him means all his attacks are ineffective? So, with that logic, if Hulk does not one shot Iron Man, his attacks are ineffective by your logic.

No, the fact that he himself admits that his attack is ineffective… proves it’s ineffective.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Second Scan: Not regular Hulk, he's been separated by banner and is stronger.

And yet it still seems to be a recurring pattern throughout their history.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Third Scan: Not Classic, I don't care. . .No post mordern Age comics.

I don’t care that you don’t care. It changes nothing.

It’s just yet another example of how Tony’s attacks don’t phase Hulk in the slightest.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Fourth: Once again, your simple reasoning comes into play. Iron-Man has more then one type of repulsors. If Hulks shrugs it off, that's fine. But, it's funny that the next panel shows Iron Man Knocking down the Hulk. . .so, much for ineffective attacks. You act like unless all of Iron Mans attacks send hulk flying, they are all ineffective.

Iron Man- “Yes, I managed to actually move the Hulk a few inches back! Bring on the Juggernaut!”

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
-Where are these consistent High-end showings. I'm still waiting for them and they are no where to be found. Show me Hulk consistently Taking Nuke level attacks, Like you stated.

-Please list them, I've been asking for them for awhile now. Show me Hulks mass quantity of High-End feats out weighing his low ones.

-According to you, with no scans at all.


Well, if you want a shitload of scans, you’re more than welcome to visit his respect thread, ‘cause I’m not going through the trouble of bringing it to you.

And before you start bitching to me about how the respect thread only has ridiculously high-end feats, you also have to take 3 things into consideration:

1.)that you need to learn to differentiate between ridiculously high-end feats (i.e. Hulk withstand an attack that ripped apart a cosmos) and the tamer high-end feats (i.e. Hulk taking a nuclear detonation unharmed).
2.)that that it also contains more of these high-end feats than you can possibly think of for his low end feats
3.)since you love averaging feats together so much, you should have no problems averaging out low-end instances like Hulk being taken out by a bomb and a snake with redciously high-end instances like Hulk withstanding a cosmos and being charged through an asteroid 2X the size of Earth completely unharmed.
The rest, like Hulk consistently taking massive explosion and not being dazed should be more acceptable to you then.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
That was just to get the ball rolling. I'm still waiting for these vast amount of High-End feats that over shadow his low ends in quantity. We still have him:

-Being K.O.ed by The wrecker
-Being K.O'ed By Doc Samson
-Being hurt By Captain america

Et Cetera. . .I have more, I'm just waiting for you to follow suit. If you cannot then your simply being irrational.


-Irrelevant. Apparently the Wrecking Crew was also able to easily subdue Dr. Strange in that same issue.
-Except Samson only did so when Hulk thought he was an illusion and wasn;t even thinking about fighting, so Samson managed to cheapshot him. If you take those instances into consideration, Hulk’s done the same to both Thor and Surfer.
-Cap hurts every body. We’re talking about the guy who briefly knocked around King Thor using nothing but the power of patriotism, Son.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Superman is the most inconsistent character in comics, he has no barring in this thread

Superman’s nothing special. It happens to every one in comics. Wonder Woman’s taken punches from Doomsday, Captain Marvel, and Superman and gotten back up just fine; but she’s been knocked out by a simple bullet to the head. Same deal with Thor, who’s taken blows from the likes of Hulk, Hercules, and even Sky-Fathers, yet he’s been knocked out by a bullet before. Juggernaut’s been able to charge War Hulk through the desert, yet he’s been stopped by cement.

You could name just about any one and they’ll have had their highs and their lows.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
And, I've countered:

-They do not have to hurt him, they subdued him.

-Except the fact that he was subdued

-Doesn't have to be, I never said it would Hold. It would just restrain him long enough for him to be K.O.ed by that super punch. If Thor Had time


- except they do have to do something other than that. Otherwise, it’s nothing but an annoyance to Hulk. In a one-on-one, Hulk could simply pull out the ol’ thunderclap. In this thread, even if Hulk doesn’t do any thing, Iron Man is just left spinning him around until Surfer or Srange or Namor takes him out from behind

-which doesn’t translate into him not being able to move his limbs. Tony isn’t Magneto and he hasn’t shown any where near the kind of control that he can do more than simply lift Hulk up in the air.

-where the hell do you get your reasoning that Hulk gets weaker when he’s in the air? You honestly think Hulk being spun around is going to suddenly make him lose strength or something?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
What "Trickery" did the wrecker use?

Feel free to point out Wrecker on that list of people I gave.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Juggernaut cuaght him by suprise, that's all. . . Besides, Juggy>Hulk.

And tricked him into not fighting back; he even admitted it himself. Or do I need to point out to you again that Hulk doesn’t throw a single punch the entire time?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Abomination steam rolled the Hulk, Banner had to use a machine to weaken him. That's the only reason why the Hulk won.

Against original Abomination (though he did manage to handle original Abomination when they fought again because of the Galaxy Master).

But again, feel free to point out where I said original Abomination, because I thought I made it clear I wasn;t referring to original Abomination in that list.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Oh, you mean like how you cited Avengers #1 where Iron Man had has original armor?

Except my reference was brought up to show yet another example where Iron Man couldn’t do any thing to Hulk, just as he had been doing consistently through =out their battles barring one time.

Your reference doesn’t even go beyond the 60s.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Samson's K.O.ed the Hulk and Iron Man's beaten Thor, something Hulk has not done.

Except Samson has only done so when Hulk literally wasn;t paying any attention and wasn’t even thinking about fighting. Hulk’s pulled the same bullshits and tricks on Thor back in one of their most recent clashes, when he cheap-shotted Thor and proceeded to pummel him into the ground.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
What a joke, at baseline he's class 70.

Even though he’s shown to move billions of tons of tectonic plates before without getting that angry at all? Or the fact that’s he’s shown to hold a 150 billion ton portion of a mountain range? Or the fact that he’s shown to be able to stalemate and even beat Class 100 brawlers like Thor, even in the beginning of fights?

Yeah, he just screams Class 70 baseline strength.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
You don't even use logic, when I pointed out a logic fallacy. You stated: "You didn't care."

I just don’t care for you’re asinine ways of interpreting things. Nothing more.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Because it's a fallacy of division, Strange is not Hulk.

It’s also a fallacy to cite a comic issue to prove something when you even admit it’s PIS.

Honestly, I never once thought I’d have to explain such a simply concept like that to any one.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
But, using your logic:

http://img462.imageshack.us/img462/6127/avengersih11a9zo.jpg

This scan is PIS completely, because Captain America's shield hurt Hulk when Iron Man's repulsors could not. 🙂


Have fun proving it hurt him. eat

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Or, Tractor Beam and Magnetic Repulsor underwater until Hulk drowns.

Or instead of retardedly twiddling his thumbs while Stark attempts to this, he could hold his breathe and then simply clap every thing around him into oblivion.

And that’s still assuming he just lets Tony carry him to any the nearest body of water instead of thunderclapping right away and getting it over with.

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Yeah, like when he K.O.ed him with that Super Punch or had him on one knee.

Except Logan's never needed an airplane explosion to stun Hulk for him. 🙂

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Once again I ask, are all repulsors the same?
I just showed you him one shotting her and now you show me a scan of someone with her powers being okay to prove that she could take his blast? Is Jen now rougue, you've done this several times now.

Because you asked me for instances where Iron Man had trouble with She-Hulk. So, what, Rogue (pre-Ms. Marvel) using She-Hulk’s powers is somehow… more powerful than She-Hulk?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Hulk being electrocuted is not being hurt?
Furthermore, that's not regular Hulk. . .

Balckbolt hit Hulk with hundreds of Lightning bolts which is why he was K.O.ed.


That was to show you the ‘other’ Captain Marvel who could summon lightning, mainly since you made it clear you didn’t know who she was.

Referring to your lightning example, I wonder how many times I have to mention the fact that Hulk’s shown the ability to take lightning bolts like he does there, millions of volts through underground wires, and hundreds of thousands of volts on more than one occasion from Zzzax to show you that they greatly overshadow his stint with Black Bolt there before it finally gets through to you?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
Which is why he could never defeat Thor, right? Even though Iron Man has, Twice.

Except he did win two of their brawls in the first two issues I cited to you. He didn’t knock Thor out, but mainly because he became tired of fighting in both instances and left.

But since you love the idea of people knocking each other out, no matter how they do it, Hulk did once pummel Thor into submission at one point. He only did it so easily because it was a massive cheap-shot, but hey, that stuff doesn’t matter does it?

Originally posted by Fire Ninja
So, said punches never had effect on Hulk?

Never said that, but he has shrugged them off and kept coming for more, which is a lot more than what Iron Man could say when an airplane didn’t explode around him.

BTW, feel free to point out where I mention original strength Abomination on my little list there.