Sabretooth vs Carnage, who wins?

Started by jinzin31 pages

😂

How am I supposed to take you seriously when the first thing you fixate on coming back to this discussion is Sabretooth's........ chode? 😘

😆

^ That's how I felt when you first brought up Sabretooth healing from a itty bitty piece of flesh. Go figure.

I just tried picturing it. Like... which piece of flesh is chosen to be the basis for regrowing the new body? Does Sabes' soul pick one? Would it pick a clump of brain matter? A piece of his pinky? The tip of his large intestine? I say... why not his chode? Trying to visualize here... help me out.

If that's what you say, more power to ya' I'M not gonna be ermmmmm "visualizing" that anytime soon though. 😕

And I'm DEFINITELY NOT gonna.... "help you out" 😘

For the vampiric symbiote check New Avengers #2 😄 (I never forgot).

Speaking of vampiric thing, dont remember Carnage doing anything "vampiric" like ever, NA 2 is the first time I heard of it. Maybe they were thinking of ult Carnage?🤨

No, it was 616, it hadn't been mentioned much before, but he and other characters have mentioned it and I could have sworn I saw him drain a character before. But nonetheless he does have it. *shrugs*

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Bendis...

Vampiric.

Carnage FTW

Faster, stronger, and everything else that I don't feel like explaining.

Originally posted by SamZED
Speaking of vampiric thing, dont remember Carnage doing anything "vampiric" like ever, NA 2 is the first time I heard of it. Maybe they were thinking of ult Carnage?🤨

Even in that comic he didn't really accomplish anything on panel that I can remember and he grabbed a couple of people... all I know is that if his supposed "vampiric touch" isn't strong enough to drain anything from Luke Cage, how the hell is it going to do anything to someone who could resist Omega Red... Even Colossus' skin was no match for him.. 😬

Carnage can use "vampiric touch" in a fight the same way Wolverine can disappear in front of his opponents in plain site, and Namor can blast people with electro currents... only.. not because unlike Carnage they've actually DONE that stuff. 😬

Originally posted by namorsubby
Carnage FTW

Faster, stronger, and everything else that I don't feel like explaining.

Faster stronger.. all anyone needs to beat ANYONE on the forums... cause no other powers matter in a fight... 🙄

Originally posted by jinzin

Faster stronger.. all anyone needs to beat ANYONE on the forums... cause no other powers matter in a fight... 🙄

Who said that besides you, Jinzin?

You guys and your ill-founded sarcastic remarks 🙄

See, I can use emoticons too.

Carnage FTW(of course you don't think so, for obvious reasons.....)

Originally posted by namorsubby
Carnage FTW(of course you don't think so, for obvious reasons.....)
you mean the one's that matter? Yeah...

Originally posted by jinzin
you mean the one's that matter? Yeah...
No, I mean the ones that collectively consist of your conflict of interest, but yeah, we'll go with that.......

Originally posted by namorsubby
No, I mean the ones that collectively consist of your conflict of interest, but yeah, we'll go with that.......
Ad hominem because there's no real argument that can be made to support Carnage here...

Of course... this coming from EVERYONE HAS PIS BUT SLADE! 🙄 what a joke.

Originally posted by jinzin
Ad hominem because there's no real argument that can be made to support Carnage here...

Of course... this coming from EVERYONE HAS PIS BUT SLADE! 🙄 what a joke.

yeah, that's why pretty much everyone but you thinks otherwise 🙄

Again, your idiotic sarcasm is way off base, but what else is new.....

Originally posted by namorsubby
yeah, that's why pretty much everyone but you thinks otherwise 🙄

Again, your idiotic sarcasm is way off base, but what else is new.....

lol... WHAT?! Hahaha!

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Creed wins in the end.

Originally posted by CHUPA
well sometimes sabretooth is fighting like a moron as well specially when he fight some female he is always jumping like a retard and getting his ass kicked

with all that being said sabretooth wins


Originally posted by chomperx9
if this is sabretooth with adamantium skeleton he has a shot for sure

Originally posted by SamZED
Kk, sounds fair, Jin. Eitherway, was never a fan of Carnage. He does tend to fight like a complete idiot most of the time, so might as well end up having his head cut off.

Originally posted by llagrok
Sabretooth, via decapitation.
Originally posted by kijenio
sabretooth wins he is a trained killer with a healing factor he will beat carnage worse then wolverine did
Originally posted by carver9
Depending on which Sabes we are talking about.

Bone claw Sabes lose the majority, Carnage 7/10.

Adamantium Sabes wins the majority, something like 8/10.

Originally posted by Starscream M
carnage cant even beat spiderman...what makes you think he could beat creed?
Originally posted by Wild Shadow
like i already said and showed any forced tearing of the sym will cause the host pain.. its an exploitative tactic that sabe would capitalize on.. especially with his pain threshold being off the chart compared to the whiny cowardly kasady.
Originally posted by redhotrash
My opinion on this one has been changed. On paper it'd seem that Carnage does enjoy a decent advantage, but in practice I dont see it working as well. He has some glaring vulnerbilities, not the least of which are his weak mind and general cowardice when things are going badly. I will say he has a puncher's chance of spilling Creed's intestines with a single swipe if hes able to land it, but thats seeming more like the exception than the rule. Really Carnage hasnt been written has that impressive of a threat since Maximum Carnage.

Gimme a break. Y'know if you're going to try insulting my intelligence the least you can do is avoid the grammatical errors along the way.... but hell, at least you fixed *your*.... 😛

And uh, yeah.... No it's not.

Originally posted by jinzin
lol... WHAT?! Hahaha!

Gimme a break. Y'know if you're going to try insulting my intelligence the least you can do is avoid the grammatical errors along the way.... but hell, at least you fixed *your*.... 😛

And uh, yeah.... No it's not.

Bet I can collect many more in support of Carnage? Nah, nevermind, they are all obviously just ignorant of Sabertooth's formmidability and painfully unaware of the fact that there's no way anyone can justify Carnage winning.

Somehow me discounting feats like Cap KOing Hulk or damaging Onslaught, while supporting feats of Slade fighting Donna Troy, who he has fought from his 1st appearance through the stages of her development up until now(in other words, the span of both their histories) turned into this?:

Originally posted by jinzin

Of course... this coming from EVERYONE HAS PIS BUT SLADE!

Yeah, that's the definition of idiotic sarcasm/absolutism, but I know you're just baiting with irrelevant nonsense like before......

Either way, I say Carnage. I know there's no way to support that, and Creed could probably take a team of carnages, but I'm just so into him I just can't help myself. Sorry.

He has the ability, IDLI IDH doesn't apply here, Spiderman didn't really use his communicating with insects much, doesn't mean he didn't have it. He can drain, and the debate with Luke Cage is subjective and even if he couldn't it could be because of skin.

Originally posted by namorsubby
Bet I can collect many more in support of Carnage? Nah, nevermind, they are all obviously just ignorant of Sabertooth's formmidability and painfully unaware of the fact that there's no way anyone can justify Carnage winning.
You certainly can, and it won't change the FACT that you were utterly wrong in pressuming that I was the only one arguing for Sabretooth's case, and that was omiting a number of people who implied he would win without saying it, or stated that it would be a close knit fight regardless of WHO won.

The rest of your rambling has nothing to do with anything since I've never treated any poster with such arrogance. Even you, though you deserve it.

Originally posted by namorsubby
Somehow me discounting feats like Cap KOing Hulk or damaging Onslaught, while supporting feats of Slade fighting Donna Troy, who he has fought from his 1st appearance through the stages of her development up until now(in other words, the span of both their histories) turned into this?:

Another assumption on your part. No the last 5 weeks of arguing that all of DS' feats are legitimate or posting them up for grabs while ignoring counter feats from counter positions is what lead me to this... And, it's not something that I could point out if it not for your ABSURDLY overwhelming hypocrisy.

Originally posted by namorsubby
Yeah, that's the definition of idiotic sarcasm/absolutism, but I know you're just baiting with irrelevant nonsense like before......

Either way, I say Carnage. I know there's no way to support that, and Creed could probably take a team of carnages, but I'm just so into him I just can't help myself. Sorry.

Again, quilty of your own accusations. What a farce.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
He has the ability, IDLI IDH doesn't apply here, Spiderman didn't really use his communicating with insects much, doesn't mean he didn't have it. He can drain, and the debate with Luke Cage is subjective and even if he couldn't it could be because of skin.

It not IDLI IDH... It's it wasn't on panel it didn't happen, or it isn't likely, it won't happen.

If someone only uses a power once in their career how does that possibly make it an effective forum ability? That's nonsense.