Silver Surfer vs Pheonix vs Galactus

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Irrelevant. Galactus is a being who requires outside sustenance. Phoenix is hooked up to an infinite energy source. Glaactus could have just eaten a planet and still lost to Phoenix.

He would eventually exhaust his energy reserves and then be back to square one.

Galactus admitted his major disadvantage to Phoenix in their conflict which you're referring to:

"I hover near to death, exhausted in our struggle, while you are neither weary, nor hungry, because you tap into a source of near limitless potential"

Here Galactus' limitations are highlighted again by Maelstrom who at the time was an avatar for Oblivion:

Galactus is limited by his need for outside sustenance. He eats, his reserves are depleted, then he must eat again.

👆

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Irrelevant. Galactus is a being who requires outside sustenance. Phoenix is hooked up to an infinite energy source. Glaactus could have just eaten a planet and still lost to Phoenix.

He would eventually exhaust his energy reserves and then be back to square one.

Galactus admitted his major disadvantage to Phoenix in their conflict which you're referring to:

"I hover near to death, exhausted in our struggle, while you are neither weary, nor hungry, because you tap into a source of near limitless potential"

Here Galactus' limitations are highlighted again by Maelstrom who at the time was an avatar for Oblivion:

Galactus is limited by his need for outside sustenance. He eats, his reserves are depleted, then he must eat again.

Yeah pretty much.

Originally posted by Mr Master
[B]When he isn't.

Right, cause he's Starving.

Originally posted by Terryc250
Galactus is always in need of sustanance, so its not really that irrelevant that he says it

It was never stated that he was starving.. hes his normal size that he usually is, phoenix was like the size of his nose

Its pointless, he's arguing not to get to the bottom of things, not to uncover the truth but instead to support his hierarchy. 👇

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Its pointless, he's arguing not to get to the bottom of things, not to uncover the truth but instead to support his hierarchy. 👇

I predict a massive, inflated, pre-written, and rhetoric post (with much manipulated content) will soon follow.

GS attacking someone for manipulating scans and twisting context ?
oh the delicious irony

Originally posted by 123KID
GS attacking someone for manipulating scans and twisting context ?
oh the delicious irony

Kid, you registered just in November.

Its common for people to refrain from joining and just read for a few weeks, maybe even a month or two before joining but nearly a year?

😬

Because thats about how long it was since that bullshit got brought up and proved wrong. 🙂

So either you're a former user under a different name or a current user under a different name. I wonder who you could be? 😖hifty:

Originally posted by id369
I predict a massive, inflated, pre-written, and rhetoric post (with much manipulated content) will soon follow.

Unfortunately thats inevitable. 🙁

I'm no longer debating with him with regards to this issue.

He's not stupid, he knows we're right, he just can't publicly admit it because of the implications it will have for his hierarchy 🙂

I refuse to play his game any longer.

Any long winded spamfest will be met with a re-post of my questions, which Mr Master has never EVER answered in the 2 years of his membership.

Our interpretations fit in with the comic and with the handbook entry on the matter. Any queries with regards to our interpretations can be explained away by referencing other New X-men issues.

Mr Masters interpretation however raises and leaves unanswered about half a dozen questions. I wonder why? 😖hifty: