Silver Surfer (exiles) vs Silver Surfer (616)

Started by xmarksthespot10 pages

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
So... let's take Galactus at a weak point... Surfer still isn't putting a hole through him, and putting him on his death bed. 🙂
What happens when you punch a hole through 616 Galactus? hmm

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
What happens when you punch a hole through 616 Galactus? hmm

Hey... that's sort of like 616 Surfer vs Uni-Lord... with the not getting brutally destroyed by being cut and all... Hmmm...

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
I've read the scan, the whole comic actually.

I read where he flew around physically attacking and/or fired energy blasts.
I read where he used his board as a weapon.
I read inwhere he couldn't react to the Exiles spacecraft.
I read where he flew around physically attacking and/or fired energy blasts.
I read where he got deboarded by someone I don't recognise.
I read where he flew around physically attacking and/or fired energy blasts.
I read where cosmic Sabretooth attacked him.
I read where he flew around physically attacking and/or fired energy blasts.
I read where he was gutted by cosmic Sabretooth.
I read where I read where he was stabbed by his own board traveling at a speed slow enough that Longshot can ride it.
I read where Manta drove the board through him killing him.
He did not fly around physically attacking and/or fire energy blasts subsequently, being dead.

So where in the comic did you see 522 Surfer phase or transmute matter or absorb energy or manipulate it significantly beyond blasting or use telepathy or shields or regenerate?
Or do anything else that 616 Surfer is capable of beyond physically attacking, attacking with his board or energy blasts?
Oh that's right nowhere. Because he's not 616 Surfer, none of 616 Surfer's feats apply to him and all he did was fly around, physically attack, attack with his board and fire energy blasts.

The scan I put up had him telling Sabretooth that he didnt possess the intellect to properly wield the power cosmic implying he could do more than blasts. 🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
The scan I put up had him telling Sabretooth that he didnt possess the intellect to properly wield the power cosmic implying he could do more than blasts. 🙂
Not really. It implies he can use it better than Sabretooth. And he does. He can blast while Sabretooth can't. 🙂

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Not really. It implies he can use it better than Sabretooth. And he does. He can blast while Sabretooth can't. 🙂
Yes because him being an astrophysicist and having years to work with the power cosmic makes perfect sense. 😆 I mean dont you get at all what the writer was trying to say to you.

He must not have been a very good astrophysicist, considering all he can do with the Power Cosmic is fly around punching and blasting. ermmhappy

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
He must not have been a very good astrophysicist, considering all he can do with the Power Cosmic is fly around punching and blasting. ermmhappy
His blasts were killing his foes. Why get fancy if what you are doing is working. 🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
His blasts were killing his foes. Why get fancy if what you are doing is working. 🙂
Inability to "get fancy" would be a pretty big obstacle.

Show it on panel.

Oh that's right... all he does on panel is fly around blasting... and he isn't 616 Surfer so none of 616 Surfer's feats are canon for 522 Surfer... and only what 522 Surfer did on panel which wasn't much is canon for 522 Surfer.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Inability to "get fancy" would be a pretty big obstacle.

Show it on panel.

Oh that's right... all he does on panel is fly around blasting... and he isn't 616 Surfer so none of 616 Surfer's feats are canon for 522 Surfer... and only what 522 Surfer did on panel which wasn't much is canon for 522 Surfer.

So what did his power cosmic entail? Did it take an astrophysicist years to learn how to emit blasts from his hands and to control his board.

Originally posted by quanchi112
So what did his power cosmic entail?
So what has he done on panel with his respective Power Cosmic?

Surfer runs around him at lightspeed nailing him with blasts... 616 that is.

616 has also absorbed stolen enough energy from a being to destroy a solar system (which Surfer did after absorbing the power). So... if he wants to get fancy... 522 is shit out of luck. Plus, 616 apparently can't be cut. 313

Originally posted by quanchi112
So what did his power cosmic entail? Did it take an astrophysicist years to learn how to emit blasts from his hands and to control his board.

Why didn't you address IW shooting a hole through 616 Galactus?

Originally posted by llagrok
Why didn't you address IW shooting a hole through 616 Galactus?
Galactus and his power fluctuates along with his very nature. I have seen Galactus bleed before.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
So what has he done on panel with his respective Power Cosmic?
He wasnt getting fancy and does what the regular Surfer does most of the time and blasted during his fights.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Surfer runs around him at lightspeed nailing him with blasts... 616 that is.

616 has also absorbed stolen enough energy from a being to destroy a solar system (which Surfer did after absorbing the power). So... if he wants to get fancy... 522 is shit out of luck. Plus, 616 apparently can't be cut. 313

But he can be armbarred and beaten down by a skrull no less.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Galactus and his power fluctuates along with his very nature. I have seen Galactus bleed before.

When he was cut by Tyrant? 😆

It's funny how you choose speculation and insinuations over hard cold evidence.

Originally posted by llagrok
When he was cut by Tyrant? 😆

It's funny how you choose speculation and insinuations over hard cold evidence.

That slash from Tyrant is canon. Galactus can bleed. 🙂

Galactus beat a fully powered Tyrant, then lost against a depowered one? The same one he had depowered himself? Tyrant who had more trouble putting down Thanos than Galactus?

I know logic doesn't go well with you, but try to use your head.

Originally posted by llagrok
Galactus beat a fully powered Tyrant, then lost against a depowered one? The same one he had depowered himself? Tyrant who had more trouble putting down Thanos than Galactus?

I know logic doesn't go well with you, but try to use your head.

Galactus did beat a fully powered Tyrant and then was getting his ass kicked by a depowered one. The depowered one had time to plan for this one. The first battle with Galactus was off panel for the most part. Bottom line is a depowered Tyrant can defeat Galactus and can cause him to bleed. Morg had to save his ass.

Actually, Tyrant initially betrayed Galactus.

Do you think that was a spontaneous thing?