Which Side Do You Support? · Star Wars: Literature & Expanded Universe

MadMel Heh

@ exodus
are you serious?
ok firstly

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
Whatever. All I know is that by the time he was 14, Ben was already a murderer, thanks to the 'skillz' of the jedi. And didn't the 10 yr old Aurra Sing try to kill Qui-gon.

they let their anger overtake them...jedi do kill, but only as a last resort, and only in the name of justice (with the exception of mace windu killing jango fett, that was merely a plot point to make boba hate jedi)

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
No, it was the Fett clones that carried out order 66 and they all died shortly after. The personel were innocent and there were even a number of Wookie slaves on there (Rise of Darth Vader), most of the personel were probably coerced and had families and stuff.
But Luke doesn't care does he? Nope.

proof?
it was a war...people kill other people in wars...do they feel bad about it? yes..do they try to repress those felling to continue fighting in the the war? yes..does killing someone in a war make the killer evil? no

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
Yeah, but they still separate kids from parents

with their parent's permission...this was heavily implied in jedi apprentice 9 - the fight for truth

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
And once they take the baby the parents never see them again, except in special circumstances (Roan Shyne).

wrong
obi-wan got to revisit his family once, as did all jedi children (jedi apprentice 3)

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
Furthermore, what right do they have to just take a child and completely decide their entire life for them, indoctrinating them from birth. In my eyes thats much worse than what most Sith do.

several things wrong here -
1. they have the right because their parent let them take the child.
2. they dont decide the life of the padawan. the padawans, and any jedi for that matter, are allowed to leave the order when they wish, as what happened with ren s'orn and ray'noor (jedi apprentice - 11-13)

Darth Exodus The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

@ exodus
are you serious?

I'm never totally serious. Rule 4- never let anyone know your true stance or feelings.

1. they have the right because their parent let them take the child.

Do the parents have the right? Does anyone have the right to totally decide how the rest of your life will go? For me it just seems needlessly cold hearted and cruel to separate parents and children bwfore they even get the chance to know one anouther. I can barely imagine how psychologically damaging it would be for the child.

it was a war...people kill other people in wars...do they feel bad about it? yes..do they try to repress those felling to continue fighting in the the war? yes..does killing someone in a war make the killer evil? no

Oh I get it, so killing someone is only bad when its a faceless individual that you can just write off as obviously evil becuase their superiors were.
It's only bad when you can't turn round, point and say 'he made me do it'. Knowing that something is bad and still doing it obviously makes it okay.
Wow, truely you possess godlike wisdom and morals.

they let their anger overtake them...jedi do kill, but only as a last resort,

Bull, with their level of training and skill, jedi could easily disable or K.O. opponents but they don't.

Man of Christ Apostle and Preacher

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
I'm never totally serious. Rule 4- never let anyone know your true stance or feelings.
Do the parents have the right? Does anyone have the right to totally decide how the rest of your life will go? For me it just seems needlessly cold hearted and cruel to separate parents and children bwfore they even get the chance to know one anouther. I can barely imagine how psychologically damaging it would be for the child.
Oh I get it, so killing someone is only bad when its a faceless individual that you can just write off as obviously evil becuase their superiors were.
It's only bad when you can't turn round, point and say 'he made me do it'. Knowing that something is bad and still doing it obviously makes it okay.
Wow, truely you possess godlike wisdom and morals.
Bull, with their level of training and skill, jedi could easily disable or K.O. opponents but they don't.

Dath Exodus it seems you did not research lightsaber form zero like i told you.

tsk tsk tsk

MadMel Heh

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
I'm never totally serious. Rule 4- never let anyone know your true stance or feelings.

it certainly works for you, as peopl dont seem to take you seriously

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
Do the parents have the right? Does anyone have the right to totally decide how the rest of your life will go? For me it just seems needlessly cold hearted and cruel to separate parents and children before they even get the chance to know one anouther. I can barely imagine how psychologically damaging it would be for the child..

do parent have a right to send their child to school, even if it isnt a law (hypothetical) and the child doesnt want to? indeed, if it was for their own good. if jedi dont get trained there is a good chance they'll turn to the darkside..if jedi become to attatched to their families...they start to know attatchement, possesion, which are traits that lead to the darkside (xanatos, anyone??)

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
Oh I get it, so killing someone is only bad when its a faceless individual that you can just write off as obviously evil becuase their superiors were.
It's only bad when you can't turn round, point and say 'he made me do it'. Knowing that something is bad and still doing it obviously makes it okay.
Wow, truely you possess godlike wisdom and morals..

way to completely miss my point 🙄
in war, people have no choice but to kill other people, otherwise they die, or the other side "wins"..its a fact of life..killing people is wrong..killing people who are trying to kill you or someone you know and love is still wrong, but it has to be done..if luke hadnt destroyed the death star, it would have destroyed the rebels, meaning that the empire would still exist to brutalize nations, destroy whole planets (killing billions, instead of thousands) and have ridiculas taxes that end up killing more people eventually..
i know which side is less evil 😬

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
Bull, with their level of training and skill, jedi could easily disable or K.O. opponents but they don't.

yes they do, have you read and on the books set in the PT?? jedi dont kill unless they absolutely must..otherwise they do KO or disarm people (if there ever are any people, most of the time its droids 🙄 )
maybe you should actually read the PT books before making judgements about the jedi order..

Mr. Slippyfist Dead

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Blasphemy Qui-Gon owns 😠 so does maul

Qui-Gon sucks like an 80 year old whore.

Maul's cool though.

chik4lit Senior Member

Out of curiosity, how much can an eighty-year old whore really suck? I mean, think of the logistics.

Blax_Hydralisk Restricted

You are made of win for asking that.

chik4lit Senior Member

win?

Blax_Hydralisk Restricted

Right. Win.

I suppose that you're not familiar with the more nerdier parts of internet lingo?

MadMel Heh

win = he liked what you said 😬

Blax_Hydralisk Restricted

I was gonna say that in my edit.. beat me to it though.

MadMel Heh

hehehe 😈

Blax_Hydralisk Restricted

[lowblow]Laugh all you want. I'm gonna go play Brawl now. [/lowblow]

😈

chik4lit Senior Member

Thanks for clarifying, because it sounded kind of bad. 😕

Blax_Hydralisk Restricted

Nah... it's a compliment.

MadMel Heh

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
[lowblow]Laugh all you want. I'm gonna go play Brawl now. [/lowblow]
😈

you little *****..you sonnova ***** *** ***** im gonna tear off your *****, and shove them right up your ***** ***** *** and ******* in the ******* on your ******* ***** *** you ***** so then youll have to **** sideways.........****!!!!!

😛

Blax_Hydralisk Restricted

😆

😛

I don't even have the game yet... 🙁

MadMel Heh

we share the same pain 🙁

Mr. Slippyfist Dead

Originally posted by chik4lit
Out of curiosity, how much can an eighty-year old whore really suck? I mean, think of the logistics.

If she has no teeth, with a whore-age of experience, then a lot more than a 12-79 year old whore.

Darth Exodus The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

i know which side is less evil

Define 'evil'