Stayne Vs Thanos.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
It does matter because power is depicted by words and illustration correct?

Let me guess, even if one of them writes a far more impressive looking and sounding fight, the power they used will be the same because Thor was going for the kill in both?

Originally posted by King KAM
meaning?

I think he means that it doesn't matter what actually happens in each fight, the power used is equal so long as each writer has the person in the same midset.

No that is not what I'm saying. I'm saying it's speculation regardless. For you to assume that a character written and drawn by two totally different will depict them the same is not logical. One can speculate all we want about what the writter was trying to convey and it COULD be that one was trying to illustrate more power. However, the opposite is also true and it could very well be that they were trying to give the same impression of how much power used it was just draw different.

I see, so writers intent means more than what is actually shown?

Who said that? So, your saying two different artist will depict power and scale the same everytime thus conveying the true proper message each and everytime?

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Who said that? So, your saying two different artist will depict power and scale the same everytime thus conveying the true proper message each and everytime?

I'm trying to figure out how you judge two different fights to determine which was more impressive in terms of power used.

That wasn't my question. Are things depicted the same by different writter/artists? Could it be possible that there could be two fights in which the same power was trying to be illustrated but came across differently?

So you're saying that intent trumps what is actually shown, thank you, that was all I wanted to know.

Thank you I'll take you not answering my questions as a concession

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Thank you I'll take you not answering my questions as a concession

Says the guy that hasn't answered my questions.

I must admit, I find it funny and telling how quickly you jumped to this tactic considering you still haven't answered my question regarding the Thor vs Blockbuster and Mangog fights.

You ended it by saying Thank You that's all I wanted to know... saying a statement I never made. So you saying Thank you I kinda figured you had enough. You have still yet to answer my question and I have answered yours in that they appear to be different in that particular fight in the amount of power used. However, you have still not answered my question.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
You ended it by saying Thank You that's all I wanted to know... saying a statement I never made. So you saying Thank you I kinda figured you had enough. You have still yet to answer my question and I have answered yours in that they appear to be different in that particular fight in the amount of power used. However, you have still not answered my question.

Just to get this moving No, different people will not always draw scenes exactly the same, However that doesn't mean that one writer/artist's destroyed planet would indicate the same power level of another writer/artist's slightly damaged building.

BTW, you still haven't answered my question either and to be fair I asked it mulitple posts before the one you're accusing me of not answering, so how about answering my question?

I just did answer it. Which question then?

Did Thor use the same amount of power in his attacks during the Blockbuster and Mangog fights?

In both comics he was fighting his hardest.

So is that a yes?

There's no way to know. In both comics he was using his maximum level of power. Two different writers may have different conceptions of Odin's power. One might think he maxes at Galaxy Busting, the other at Planet Busting.

So we are back to writers intent matters more than what is actually shown.

Originally posted by Silent Master
So we are back to writers intent matters more than what is actually shown.

A. Odin was using the same power as he was against Set, and Thanos is just that tough.

B. Between those showings, Odin was upgraded.

C. The Set showing is PIS.