Originally posted by Silent MasterI go by what was in this comic. I dont have to look at other comics here to figure out what the writer intended for this one. Odin meant serious business in both storylines.
No, you gave an answer and then added qualifiers to it so as to make the answer worthless for what I was asking.I didn't ask if each of the writers wrote what they thought was Odin's power level, I asked if Odin actually used the same amount of power, as in, would Thanos have fared as well if he replaced Seth during that battle?
Originally posted by darthgooberHuh? I said he wasnt holding back,which he wasnt. Anyways,neither side exhausted themselves of all of their energies. Hell,I dont think either character ever has to begin with.
I understand, but you have to be careful not to swing to far to the other side of the fence too. Let Galan and the other guys make the baseless claim that Odin was holding back, it's better to point out their error in reasoning than to start espousing it yourself with the claim that he was going all out. It's an effective tactic in showing others the folly in their thinking, but if you start it then technically they're showing you the folly of yours.
Originally posted by quanchi112
I go by what was in this comic. I dont have to look at other comics here to figure out what the writer intended for this one. Odin meant serious business in both storylines. Huh? I said he wasnt holding back,which he wasnt. Anyways,neither side exhausted themselves of all of their energies. Hell,I dont think either character ever has to begin with.
I didn't ask if he meant serious business in both fights, I asked whether the same amount of power was used in each fight, IOW were the attacks he used against Seth of the same power level as the ones he used against Thanos.
Again this is a simple yes or no question.
Originally posted by Silent MasterHe used different methods,but was trying to defeat both. He wasnt holding back. It was a different writer anyways,and I have already explained myself.
I didn't ask if he meant serious business in both fights, I asked whether the same amount of power was used in each fight, IOW were the attacks he used against Seth of the same power level as the ones he used against Thanos.Again this is a simple yes or no question.
Hey Silent wouldn't it be speculation either way? So, how does it matter. The fact is both writers were trying giving the impression Odin was out for the kill. Regardless of how the art work and words or other variables were depicted that fact remains true. So, how can you say one way or another which fight he was using more power when each writer depictes things differently. Mr. it has to be said for it not to be speculation..
So, Galan you asy you don't believe he just goes around killing people for no good reason. Yet in that comic the circumstances exactly ponit to that he thought THanos had kidnapped and imprisoned his son. couple that with him SAYING I'm going to kill you. I think on panel evidence is greater then your opinion as you like to say.
Originally posted by quanchi112
He used different methods,but was trying to defeat both. He wasnt holding back. It was a different writer anyways,and I have already explained myself.
Again, that isn't the question I asked, I askde if the attacks Odin used against Seth were of the same power level as the ones he used against Thanos
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Hey Silent wouldn't it be speculation either way? So, how does it matter. The fact is both writers were trying giving the impression Odin was out for the kill. Regardless of how the art work and words or other variables were depicted that fact remains true. So, how can you say one way or another which fight he was using more power when each writer depictes things differently. Mr. it has to be said for it not to be speculation..
It matters because one side is trying to say it's a fact that Odin was going all out in the Thanos fight when nothing of the sort was stated in the comic.
Do you think Odin used the same amount of power in the Seth and Thanos fights?
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Speculation either way. The only fact we do know is he was trying to kill both of them. So, logically it would be more likely he used a similiar amount of power but saying one was more then another without it being quantifiable is pure speculation.
So even though the effort, scale and consequences of the fights were completely different it's only logical to assume the same amount of power was used because he was "going for the kill" in both?
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
What makes you think the effort and scale were any different? What is your bases for this? You mean Odin said he was using x amount of power in each particular fight? Scans or is this just YOUR speculation
Having seen both fights, though that is my opinion, I take it you disgaree?
Also, would you say Thor used the same amount of power in the fights he had with Blockbuster and Mangog? He was after all going for the kill in both fights.
So, again that is your speculation correct? Each fight was written by a different writer so your basis for using that as your scale is very subjective and lacks foundation. If it was written and drawn by the same person you might have an argument. However, it's not and thus your the one speculating as in both cases he was going for the kill and expending a lot of energy. How much is subjective but what is fact is that he was going for the kill.
Excuse me, but I already said that it was my opinion, you'll notice that unlike some I'm not trying to pass off opinion as fact.
BTW, what about my question regarding whether it's logical to assume Thor was using the same amount of power in the Blockbuster and Mangog fights, since he was going for the kill in both.